Concept
What the Transferee Takes
Alienability of debtor’s rights (§ 9-401)
What the Transferee Takes
A debtor's transfer of collateral usually succeeds, and the transferee usually takes the collateral with the security interest still attached. Two sections produce that result, and each answers a different question. Section 9-401(b) answers whether the transfer happens: an agreement that prohibits the debtor from transferring its rights in collateral, or that makes a transfer a default, does not prevent the transfer from taking effect.1 Section 9-315(a)(1) answers what the transferee holds: a security interest continues in collateral notwithstanding a sale, lease, license, exchange, or other disposition, unless the secured party authorized the disposition free of the interest or another provision of Article 9 lets the transferee take free.2
The two rules fit together because the security interest has already attached to the collateral. A transferee steps into the debtor's position and receives rights in collateral that the interest already burdens. If every effective transfer also stripped the interest, a debtor could defeat its lender by selling the collateral to the first buyer who would pay.
The standard case shows the result. A gives B a security interest in all of A's equipment and then sells one machine to C. Unless B authorized a sale free of its interest or an Article 9 priority rule protects C, B's security interest stays attached to the machine in C's possession.3 C's ignorance of B's interest does not change that outcome; only authorization or a priority rule does. B's security interest also attaches to the proceeds of A's sale, so B may claim both the machine and the proceeds, but B may have only one satisfaction of the debt.4
The first way a transferee takes free is the secured party's own authorization. The interest belongs to the secured party, so the secured party may release it by authorizing the sale in the security agreement or otherwise.5 Authorization may be express. It may also be implied from conduct, as where the debtor repeatedly sold collateral of the same kind on earlier occasions, the secured party knew of those sales, and no one objected. The secured party may even be deemed to have waived a term that prohibits sale, because consent can arise through waiver and estoppel.6 None of this conflicts with § 9-401(b). A prohibition clause cannot stop the transfer, but the secured party's own conduct can release its interest in the collateral.
The two versions differ in one fact: whether the secured party's conduct signaled that sales could go forward without the lien. A single sale the lender never heard of sends no such signal, and a long, tolerated pattern of sales does.
Students often read a right to proceeds as permission to sell. It is not. The secured party's right to the proceeds of a disposition is not an express or implied authorization to dispose of the collateral free of the security interest.7 The proceeds right adds a second claim and does not release the first, so the secured party keeps its interest in the collateral in the transferee's hands and may also claim the proceeds, with a single satisfaction as the limit.8
When the secured party has not consented, Article 9 still protects some transferees. A buyer in ordinary course of business of goods other than farm products, buying from a seller that created the security interest, takes the goods free of a perfected security interest even if the buyer knows the interest exists, and also takes free of an unperfected one.9 This is § 9-320(a), and it is an exception to the continuing-interest rule of § 9-315(a)(1), not a consequence of § 9-401(b).
The protected buyer must buy from the seller that created the security interest, and a transaction one step removed can fail that requirement. Suppose a manufacturer's inventory is subject to a perfected security interest, and the manufacturer transfers some items to a retailer in satisfaction of a debt it owed the retailer. The secured party has not consented, so the retailer does not qualify as a buyer in ordinary course of those items and takes them subject to the interest. The retailer then sells one item to a customer who is a buyer in ordinary course of the retailer's business. The customer still takes subject to the interest, because the protection reaches only security interests created by the buyer's own seller, and the manufacturer created this one, not the retailer.10 A customer who qualified as a buyer in ordinary course of the manufacturer itself would take free.
A second priority rule protects a buyer who is not in ordinary course. A buyer without knowledge of the security interest who gives value and takes delivery while the interest is unperfected takes free of it.11 Knowledge means actual knowledge, not mere notice, and value includes any consideration, including a preexisting debt. The critical time for the secured party is the moment of perfection, which may differ from the moment of filing. A buyer with actual knowledge of the interest cannot use this rule.
Some transferees receive no protection at all. Article 9 has no provision protecting donees, so a donee takes the collateral subject to the security interest, and the secured party prevails even if it never perfected.12 Value is the dividing line: the buyer who paid may take free under a priority rule, and the donee who paid nothing may not.