Concept
Agreements Cannot Block Transfer
Alienability of debtor’s rights (§ 9-401)
Agreements Cannot Block Transfer
Section 9-401(b) takes one question out of the parties' hands: whether the debtor may transfer its rights in the collateral. An agreement between the debtor and the secured party that prohibits a transfer of the debtor's rights in collateral, or that makes the transfer a default, does not prevent the transfer from taking effect.1
The sentence covers two drafting techniques. A flat prohibition says the debtor may not transfer. A default clause leaves the transfer possible but declares that making it breaches the security agreement. On the question the statute addresses, both clauses get the same answer: the transfer still takes effect.
Consider Dana, who borrows from Lakeside Bank and grants it a security interest in her delivery truck. The security agreement says Dana may not transfer her rights in the truck without the bank's consent, and that any transfer is a default. Dana sells her rights to Eli without asking. The clause, however carefully drafted, does not stop the sale. The transfer takes effect, and Eli becomes the transferee. What Eli takes is a separate question, and the sections that follow address it.
The commentary lists this rule among other provisions that are ineffective if a secured party includes them in a security agreement. One of them is a term prohibiting transfer of the debtor's equity in the collateral, which the commentary ties to § 9-401(b) of the 1999 revision.2 A secured party who writes such a term has written an ineffective one. The practical lesson is that a no-transfer clause, whether it forbids the transfer or only labels it a default, cannot keep the debtor's rights from passing to someone else.