Concept
Other Law Governs Transferability
Alienability of debtor’s rights (§ 9-401)
Alienability of Debtor's Rights
Other Law Governs Transferability
Article 9 does not decide whether a debtor may sell, pledge, or lose its interest in collateral. Section 9-401(a) hands that question to other law: except as subsection (b) and Sections 9-406, 9-407, 9-408, and 9-409 provide, whether a debtor's rights in collateral may be voluntarily or involuntarily transferred is governed by law other than Article 9.1
The rule runs in both directions. A voluntary transfer is one the debtor chooses, such as a sale of the collateral or the grant of another security interest. An involuntary transfer is one a creditor imposes through attachment, levy, garnishment, or other judicial process.2 Either way, a question about whether the debtor's interest can be moved or seized starts outside Article 9, and it returns to the article only if a named exception applies. The practical method is therefore to check the exceptions first. If the question falls under § 9-401(b) or §§ 9-406 through 9-409, Article 9 answers it. If not, the answer lies elsewhere.
The exception a debtor is most likely to trip over is § 9-401(b). A security agreement may forbid the debtor to transfer the collateral, or declare that any transfer is a default. Such a clause does not prevent the transfer from taking effect.4 The debtor can still sell its equity in the collateral, and the equity passes subject to the security interest. What the clause can do is make the transfer an event of default between the debtor and the secured party.5 The next section treats this rule in detail.
The statute speaks of the debtor's rights in collateral, not of the collateral itself, and that wording sets the limit. A transfer carries only what the debtor holds. A debtor with just a leasehold in machinery has only that leasehold to pass on, whether it sells the leasehold or grants a lender a security interest in it.6 Once the debtor has granted a security interest, what remains to transfer is the debtor's equity, which passes subject to that interest.7
Transferability also leaves the secured party's own position untouched. A security interest reaches only the collateral duly described. If the description is too narrow, the secured creditor lives with it and holds a security interest only in the collateral the description covers.8 The first question asks what the debtor can pass on or lose. The second asks what the secured party actually holds.