Concept
Multi-Party Priority Problems
Priority of liens arising by law (§ 9-333)
Multi-Party Priority Problems
Section 9-333 settles one contest: a possessory lien on goods outranks a security interest in the goods unless the statute creating the lien expressly provides otherwise.1 Real collateral draws more than two claimants, though. The cash register a repairer is holding may also be claimed by the seller that financed it, by the seller’s own lender, and by a bank with a lien on all of the debtor’s equipment. Ranking all of them takes a method, and the method rests on two premises.
The first premise is that priority is decided asset by asset. A creditor can rank first in one asset and last in another, so the question to answer is where this creditor stands in this particular asset.2 The second premise is that priority is decided pair by pair. Article 9 states a separate rule for each kind of contest, so three claimants to one asset produce three contests, and those contests may be governed by three different rules.3
Picture two secured parties and an execution lien creditor, all claiming the same asset. The asset presents three disputes: one secured party against the other, and each secured party against the lien creditor.4 A possessory lienor adds one more kind of claimant. Section 9-333 is the rule written for the lienor’s contest with a secured party, and it says nothing about how two secured parties rank against each other. The ordinary rule for that contest, first to file or perfect, would put a lender that filed years ago ahead of a repairer who arrived last week, so it cannot be used to rank the lienor.5 Each rule answers only the contest it was written for, and a complete ranking comes from using each rule where it belongs.
The lienor’s contests are the easy ones. A qualifying lienor still holding the goods beats every security interest in them unless its own statute provides otherwise, so it takes first place without any comparison of filing dates.6 What remains is a contest among the secured parties alone, and the ordinary rules decide it. Perfected interests rank by the earlier of filing or perfection,7 a perfected interest outranks an unperfected one, and conflicting unperfected interests rank by the order in which they attached.8 Applying § 9-333 first and the ordinary rules second yields a complete ranking without forcing either rule to decide a contest it was not designed for.
The cash-register facts show the method at work. On January 2, 2018, Ace bought new registers for its two retail stores from Grassley Associates, a sole proprietorship that supplies equipment to retail stores. Ace paid $10,000 down and granted Grassley a security interest in the registers to secure the $30,000 balance.9 Grassley’s own inventory is financed by Continental Bank, which holds a security interest in all of Grassley’s present and future inventory and filed a financing statement against William Grassley in Idaho on July 1, 2013.10 On July 1, 2018, one register broke. Ace took it to Gadgets Repair, Inc., which spent $750 in labor and materials fixing it and still has possession.11
Four assumptions complete the picture. State law gives a repairer in Gadgets’ position a possessory lien, and the statute says nothing about priority. Continental’s 2013 filing was effective, so its interest is perfected. Grassley never filed a financing statement against Ace. National Bank, which lent to Ace under an agreement covering all of Ace’s equipment, now owned or later acquired, has not filed either. The asset is the register, which in Ace’s hands is equipment, and four claimants hold four different claims to it:
- Gadgets Repair holds a possessory lien for $750 in repair charges, effective while Gadgets holds the register.
- Continental Bank holds a perfected security interest, created by Grassley, that attached to the register while it was Grassley’s inventory.
- Grassley holds the security interest Ace granted for the $30,000 balance, which is unperfected.
- National Bank holds an unperfected security interest in all of Ace’s equipment, which includes the register.
Step three begins with the lienor. Gadgets beats Continental, Grassley, and National Bank under § 9-333(b), and it makes no difference that Continental filed five years before the repair or that two of the other claims are unperfected.12 Three secured parties remain. Continental’s perfected interest outranks the two unperfected ones. Grassley’s and National Bank’s interests both attached when Ace acquired rights in the register, so the first-to-attach rule does not separate them.13 If Ace did not buy as a buyer in ordinary course of business, the ranking is:
- Gadgets’ possessory lien.
- Continental’s perfected security interest.
- Grassley’s and National Bank’s unperfected security interests, neither outranking the other.
Whether Ace bought as a buyer in ordinary course changes the list of competitors. Such a buyer takes free of every security interest created by its seller, but only of those, and the interests the buyer itself granted remain.14 Continental’s interest was created by Grassley, Ace’s seller, so it drops out. Grassley’s and National Bank’s interests were created by Ace, so they stay. Gadgets still ranks first, because § 9-333(b) never depended on how strong the other claimants were, and only the number of claimants behind it has changed:
- Gadgets’ possessory lien.
- Grassley’s and National Bank’s security interests, neither outranking the other because both attached at the same moment.
The order controls who is paid from the register’s value. Suppose that in the first scenario the register sells for $1,000. Gadgets takes $750, Continental takes the remaining $250 toward what it is owed, and Grassley and National Bank receive nothing from this asset. Each must try to collect its unpaid claim, its deficiency, from Ace by other means.15 Gadgets’ first place is a position in this one register. It says nothing about National Bank’s rank in the rest of Ace’s equipment, where no repairer holds anything and the security interests are ordered among themselves.
Gadgets’ first place lasts only as long as its lien does. A possessory lien qualifies only if its effectiveness depends on the lienor’s possession of the goods,16 which is why step three confirms possession before ranking and not after.
Agricultural Liens
A possessory lien depends on the lienor holding the goods.18 An agricultural lien is defined by the opposite feature. To qualify, the lien must be created by statute, must run in favor of someone who furnishes goods and services (or rental property) in the ordinary course of business in connection with farming operations, and must be nonpossessory, meaning it cannot depend on the creditor’s possession.19 The lien attaches to farm products. The possessory-lien definition demands possession and the agricultural-lien definition forbids dependence on it, so no lien fits both. An agricultural lien is never a possessory lien, and § 9-333 does not rank it.
The definition also shows who holds this kind of lien. A farm lender whose interest in farm products rests on a security agreement holds an ordinary security interest, because an agricultural lien must be created by statute and not by agreement. The holders are almost always landlords owed rent and trade creditors who sell goods such as feed and seed or provide services such as custom cutting and veterinary care. Any of them could also take a security agreement from the farmer, but none is obliged to.20 A farm landlord’s lien on crops for unpaid rent on the land where the crops grew is therefore an agricultural lien, and Article 9 covers it.21 That sets it apart from the ordinary landlord’s lien taken up in the next subsection.
Article 9 reaches this lien because possession is missing. A repairer holding a tractor tells every lender that a claim exists, since the tractor is out of the debtor’s hands. A supplier whose lien attaches to a crop growing in the farmer’s field announces nothing: the farmer keeps the goods, and a lender who inspects the farm sees only the farmer. A hidden lien that ranked first by default would undercut collateral the lender was counting on. Perfection exists to give the public notice of a claim,22 so Article 9 brings the agricultural lien into its perfection and priority system. The lien stands with one foot in Article 9 and one foot outside it: the lien statute decides whether the lien exists, and Article 9 decides how it is perfected and how it ranks.23
Perfection and ranking then follow a filing logic. A perfected agricultural lien, perfected ordinarily by filing a financing statement, has priority over a conflicting unperfected security interest or agricultural lien. If both conflicting interests are unperfected, the first to attach or become effective prevails, and a lien creditor defeats an unperfected agricultural lien.24 When the lien statute states no priority rule, the normal Article 9 rules apply, so perfected interests rank by the earlier of filing or perfection.25 A seed supplier that files after a bank has filed therefore ranks behind the bank.
The lien statute can change that result. Under § 9-322(g), a statute creating an agricultural lien may give the lien priority over a conflicting security interest or agricultural lien in the same collateral, and when it does, the statute governs the priority of a perfected lien.26 Legislatures sometimes make that choice because farm operations depend on suppliers of seed, fertilizer, feed, and veterinary services.27 The design is the same two-layer one that § 9-333(b) uses, a default plus a statutory exception, but the defaults point in opposite directions. The possessory lienor wins by default unless its statute expressly provides otherwise, and the agricultural lienor ranks by filing unless its statute expressly gives it priority.28 Each default fits the lien’s visibility. The possessory lienor’s hold on the goods is a public signal that can fairly outrank earlier filings, while the nonpossessory lienor has only its filing to offer, so the order of filing decides.
Valley Seed supplied the farm’s inputs and the shop only fixed a machine, yet the shop outranks the bank and the seed supplier does not. Two features sorted them: whether the lien’s effectiveness depends on possession, and whether it attaches to farm products. Asking whether the creditor served a farmer is the tempting shortcut, and it fails because both creditors did. The classification is better run as a short sequence applied to the lienor’s facts.
Landlords' Liens
A landlord whose tenant stops paying rent often holds a claim against the tenant’s belongings, and Article 9 mostly stays out of it. The Article does not apply to “a landlord’s lien, other than an agricultural lien.”30 Two things keep a landlord from borrowing the priority rule for possessory liens. The lien is excluded from Article 9, and it also fails the definition of a possessory lien, which § 9-333(b) requires before it will rank a lien ahead of a security interest.31
A possessory lien must secure an obligation for services and materials that the lienholder furnished with respect to goods in the ordinary course of its business. It must also be created by a statute or rule of law other than Article 9, depend on the lienholder’s possession of the goods, and arise under a statute that does not expressly provide otherwise.32 The ordinary landlord’s lien fails the first condition. Rent is the price of occupying space under a lease. A landlord who rents an apartment or a storefront has furnished the space and has done nothing to or with the tenant’s goods, so the debt is not one for services or materials furnished with respect to goods. A landlord’s lien may satisfy the other conditions, but the conditions are cumulative, so failing the first ends the inquiry.
The failure on the first condition tracks the reason a repairer outranks a lender. Statutory liens have generally taken priority over perfected security interests on the rationale that parties who contribute inputs or services to another should have a first claim to payment.33 A repairer’s work goes into the goods themselves. A landlord contributes space and nothing to the goods, so the rent obligation supplies no reason to rank the landlord ahead of a lender that financed them. Article 9 accordingly leaves the landlord with whatever rank the lien statute and other state law provide.34
The word possessory can mislead here. Suppose a state’s statute lets a landlord evict a tenant who has not paid and keep the tenant’s personal property until the rent is paid. That retention resembles a repairer’s hold on a repaired machine, but § 9-333 asks first what the lien secures. A landlord who keeps the tenant’s furniture still holds a lien for rent, and a lien for rent is not a lien for services or materials. The usual error is to start with the third condition, find possession, and conclude that § 9-333(b) applies, when the analysis should begin with the first condition and, for a landlord, end there.
Because Article 9 supplies no ranking, the landlord’s rank against a lender depends on state law and may differ from state to state. A landlord who wants certainty can bargain for a security interest. That is the standard advice for a farm landlord owed cash rent: sign a security agreement and file a financing statement, because a perfected security interest is good against purchasers of farm products as well as other creditors.35
The one landlord’s lien that Article 9 does govern is named in the exclusion itself. An agricultural lien is a statutory lien in farm products that may secure rent on land leased for the debtor’s farming operation, so long as its effectiveness does not depend on possession.36 When a landlord rents 100 acres to a farmer to plant corn and state law gives the landlord a lien on the crops raised there to secure the rent, that lien is an agricultural lien and Article 9 governs it.37 The apartment landlord’s lien sits outside Article 9 and the crop lien sits inside it, and the difference lies in the collateral and the use: the crop lien attaches to farm products raised in a farming operation on the leased land. Inside Article 9 the lien is ranked by the filing system, so if its statute is silent on priority, perfected claims rank by the earlier of filing or perfection.38 Section 9-333 never applies to it, because an agricultural lien does not depend on possession.
Federal Tax Liens
Section 9-333 ranks a possessory lien against a security interest in the goods and goes no further.40 A repairer’s contest with the federal government is governed by a federal statute, 26 U.S.C. § 6323(b)(5). Even after notice of a federal tax lien has been filed, that lien is not valid against the holder of a local-law lien securing the reasonable price of repairing or improving tangible personal property, if the holder is, and has been, continuously in possession of the property from the time the lien arose.41 In United States v. Kimbell Foods, the Supreme Court set this provision beside the Model UCC rule of its day, which ranked a lien for services or materials on goods in the lienor’s possession ahead of a perfected security interest unless the lien statute expressly provided otherwise. The Court described the Tax Lien Act of 1966 as extending similar protection to repairmen.42
The federal rule matters because the tax lien’s reach depends on a filed notice. The federal tax lien is inferior to the interest of a purchaser, holder of a security interest, mechanic’s lienor, or judgment lien creditor until notice of the tax lien has been filed, so an Article 9 security interest perfected before the notice is filed beats the tax lien.43 Filing the notice does not end the contest. Section 6323(b) lists ten exceptions under which a creditor or purchaser whose interest attaches after the filing still takes priority, and the repairer’s possessory lien is one of them.44 The repairer’s claim against the government is therefore decided under § 6323 and not under § 9-333.
The exception follows the logic behind repairers’ liens generally: parties who contribute services to property should have a first claim to payment.45 A repair done after the notice is filed improves the taxpayer’s own property, and a shop that had to rank behind the filed notice would have little reason to repair a tax debtor’s equipment without payment in advance. The possession requirement ties the federal rule to the same feature that supports § 9-333. A shop holding the goods has leverage over the owner, and its hold is a visible sign of its claim. The statute asks for continuous possession from the time the lien arose, so a repairer that hands the goods back has broken the chain, and on the statute’s wording, getting the goods back later does not repair it.
The two rules reach the same result for the same reason, but they come from different bodies of law and answer different questions. Section 9-333(b) is state law that ranks a possessory lien against a security interest, and it gives way to a lien statute that expressly provides otherwise. Section 6323(b)(5) is federal law that ranks the repairer’s lien against a filed federal tax lien. When a repaired truck is claimed by the repairer, a bank, and the IRS, the pair-by-pair method assigns each contest to its own source. The repairer’s contest with the bank falls under § 9-333, its contest with the federal government falls under § 6323(b)(5), and the bank’s contest with the IRS turns on whether the bank’s interest was perfected before the notice was filed.46