Concept
Backstop for Instrument Purchasers
Holders and purchasers of negotiable instruments
Backstop for Instrument Purchasers
A holder in due course of a negotiable instrument takes priority over an earlier security interest, even if perfected, but only “to the extent provided in” Article 3.1 That test demands a great deal of a buyer of paper, and a buyer who fails it is not automatically left to the lender. Section 9-330(d) supplies a second route. A purchaser of an instrument has priority over a security interest in the instrument “perfected by a method other than possession” if the purchaser “gives value and takes possession of the instrument in good faith and without knowledge that the purchase violates the rights of the secured party.”2 The two rules reach the same result, priority over a perfected lender, by different paths, so a problem about paper should be run through both.
The second route exists because lenders so often finance paper without holding it. A dealer sells a car on credit, for example, and the customer signs a promissory note; the note is an instrument, and it is proceeds of the dealer’s inventory.3 Article 9 lets a lender perfect without possession in comparable settings: a lender in negotiable documents may perfect by filing, or temporarily for 20 days, as well as by taking possession or control.4 A debtor who keeps the paper can then pass it to someone else. If that third person takes possession, the third person holds an interest as a purchaser in conflict with the lender’s nonpossessory but perfected interest, and § 9-330 says when the person who took possession wins.5 The rule’s limit follows from the same facts. It runs only against an interest perfected by a method other than possession, so a lender who holds the paper never faces it.6
The two rules differ on three points:
- Due course status belongs only to the holder of a negotiable instrument, while § 9-330(d) reaches the purchaser of any instrument, negotiable or not.7 Article 9 defines an instrument to include a negotiable instrument and any other writing that evidences a right to payment of a monetary obligation, is not itself a security agreement or lease, and is of a type ordinarily transferred by delivery with any necessary indorsement or assignment.8
- A holder in due course must take without notice of any claim to the instrument, as the earlier discussion of notice showed, so a buyer who knows of the lender’s interest cannot qualify. A § 9-330(d) purchaser loses only by knowing that the purchase violates the secured party’s rights, and that knowledge is tested at the time the purchaser takes possession.9
- A holder in due course takes free of the secured party’s claim even if the security interest is perfected,10 while a § 9-330(d) purchaser defeats only an interest perfected by a method other than possession.11
The second difference does the most work. A buyer who learns only that a lien exists may reasonably think the debtor’s sale is permitted. A buyer who learns that the sale breaches the lender’s rights cannot think so, and § 9-330(d) withholds priority from that buyer alone.
Section 9-330(d): Purchasers of Instruments
Four elements decide a § 9-330(d) contest: the claimant must give value, take possession of the instrument, act in good faith, and lack knowledge that the purchase violates the secured party’s rights.12 The claimant need not be an outright buyer. A secured party counts as a purchaser, so a lender that takes an instrument as collateral can claim the priority as readily as a buyer can.13
Knowledge is measured when the purchaser takes possession, so what the purchaser learns afterward does not defeat it.14 The paper itself can supply the knowledge. A purchaser is considered to know of the violation if the note bears notice of a prior assignment, which is why competing assignees of a mortgage note typically resolve their conflict by possession: whoever takes possession prevails, unless the note carries notice of the earlier assignment.15 A lender that cannot keep the paper can still mark it, and a buyer who sees the mark cannot claim ignorance.
The credit union filed first and was perfected in both contests, so the filing date explains nothing. What separates the buyers is what each knew when it took possession. A stem that pairs a filed lender with a buyer who learned of the filing is asking which kind of knowledge the buyer had: that a lien existed, or that the sale breached the lender’s rights.
Section 9-332: Transferees of Money and Deposit-Account Funds
A transferee of money takes the money free of a security interest in it, even if perfected, unless the transferee acts in collusion with the debtor in violating the secured party’s rights.18 A transferee of funds from a deposit account takes those funds free of a security interest in the account on the same terms.19 Either transferee may be a secured party, so a lender that the debtor pays from the till or the bank account is as well placed as a stranger.20
Section 9-332 asks less of the transferee than §§ 9-330 and 9-331 do. The transferee need not give value and need not be a holder in due course, and the only question is whether it joined the debtor in violating the secured party’s rights. The bar is high. Comment 4 stresses that the transferee must truly be a “bad actor” to be “in collusion,” and ordinarily its knowledge that the payment violates the senior creditor’s security interest is not enough.21 The reasoning looks to both creditors. The junior creditor has a right to payment, while the senior creditor failed to take steps that would have protected its proceeds, such as requiring a lockbox.22
A lockbox protects only as its terms are written, and who counts as the transferee can decide the contest. In one case a junior creditor had customer payments directed to a lockbox account, but the account’s owner was specified to be the debtor, so the debtor and not the junior creditor was the transferee of the funds. The senior creditor’s rights in the payments survived.23
The standard illustration shows how little the payee must establish. Lender holds a perfected security interest in Debtor’s deposit account at Bank A, and Debtor draws a check on the account payable to Payee. The check is an order to pay funds from the account and not proceeds of the account, so Lender’s interest in the account does not give rise to an interest in the check. Payee deposits the check and Bank A pays it. Unless Payee acted in collusion with Debtor in violating Lender’s rights, Payee takes the funds free of Lender’s security interest, and that is true whether or not Payee is a holder in due course of the check and even if Payee gave no value for it.24
The same section settles a recurring contest between lenders. Suppose a senior creditor holds a perfected security interest in a debtor’s inventory, so that the cash and checks the debtor receives on sales are its proceeds,25 and the debtor then pays a junior secured creditor. The junior creditor is probably protected as to cash by § 9-332(a) and as to checks drawn on the debtor’s account by § 9-332(b), and it fails only if it acted in collusion with the debtor in violating the senior creditor’s rights.26
The transferee’s protection looks different when the secured party claims a check as proceeds. In the Runnells Grain Elevator decision, a grain elevator mailed a check representing the proceeds of a debtor’s grain harvest to the debtor’s landlords, though the drawer had notice of a perfected security interest. The secured party held a prior perfected security interest, yet the landlords qualified as holders in due course and took free of it.27 The result turned on the landlords’ own status as holders in due course, so a landlord with notice of the claim could not have taken the same way.
A problem that pits a secured party against someone who was paid therefore begins with what the secured party claims. If it claims money or funds from a deposit account, the transferee wins unless it colluded, and its knowledge of the lien, its failure to give value, and its lack of due course status drop out of the analysis. If it claims an instrument such as a check as proceeds, the instrument rules decide the contest, and they turn on the taker’s own status and knowledge.