Concept
Working Through a Priority Contest
Purchaser of chattel paper: proceeds claim
Working Through a Priority Contest
A priority contest over chattel paper starts with a roster, not a rule. For each asset, identify who claims an interest and what kind of interest it is; only then choose the priority rule and apply it.1 Here the asset is a piece of chattel paper, the claimants are an inventory lender and a purchaser of the paper, and the governing rule is § 9-330(a). That subsection lets the purchaser defeat a security interest claimed merely as proceeds of inventory, but only if the purchaser meets every condition it lists.2
The lender starts ahead, because its interest in the inventory reaches the paper as proceeds. Each condition is a step the purchaser must take to show that it bought the paper in a way the Code protects, and a purchaser that misses one step leaves the lender where it began. Order matters, because the facts of a problem arrive mixed together and each fact belongs to a particular step.
Stated without the subsection numbers, the purchaser takes free of the lender's interest if it acts in good faith in the ordinary course of its business, gives new value, and takes possession or control of the paper, so long as the paper carries no legend saying it was assigned to the lender or to anyone else.5
No step asks what the purchaser knew about the lender. Neither paragraph of the subsection states a knowledge condition, and the only mental-state element sits inside good faith. The instrument rule shows the contrast: under § 9-330(d), a purchaser of an instrument gets priority only if it gives value and takes possession in good faith and without knowledge that it is violating the secured party's rights.6 A student who has met that knowledge test is tempted to add it here, and the addition produces wrong answers on the facts below.
The dealer-and-financers contest shows the sequence at work. Financer A holds a security interest in a dealer's automobile inventory. The dealer sells a car, the buyer signs a security agreement for the unpaid price, and the dealer physically transfers that agreement to financer B. B acquires it for value and regularly buys such agreements from this dealer. B also knows that A finances the dealer's inventory, and the instinct is to treat that awareness as fatal. The steps say otherwise. The agreement is chattel paper and proceeds of inventory, A's claim to it is merely as proceeds, B bought in the ordinary course of its own business, paid value, and took the paper in hand, and nothing in the facts shows a legend or a reason to doubt B's honesty. B has priority as to the buyer's security agreement, and A's remaining claim is to the proceeds the dealer received when it sold the paper to B.7
A failure at step four ends the same way even when every element of paragraph (1) is met. A purchaser that pays cash, deals honestly, and takes the original still loses if an authoritative copy indicates an assignment to an identified assignee other than the purchaser, because paragraph (2) is an independent condition.9
When any step fails, subsection (a) drops out and the purchaser has no special priority. The contest returns to the ordinary first-to-file-or-perfect rule, which favors the lender that filed against the inventory before the purchaser took the paper. Subsection (a) displaces that default only when every condition is met, so a single failed condition restores it in full.