Concept
Four Buyer Conditions
Buyer of consumer goods
Four Buyer Conditions
Section 9-320(b) begins with the seller, and a sale that clears the seller-side gate must still pass four tests about the buyer's own purchase. The subsection lets a buyer of goods from a person who used or bought them primarily for personal, family, or household purposes take free of a security interest, even a perfected one, if the buyer buys in four listed ways.1 The third item ends with the word “and,” which joins the four into a single test.2 A buyer who meets three conditions and misses one takes nothing from the exception, and the default rule from the opening section returns: the security interest continues in the goods after the sale.3
The four conditions describe the amateur buyer the exception was built for. A seller who finances a refrigerator for a consumer is perfected automatically, with no filing or other public act, so a person who later buys that refrigerator from the consumer has no way of finding out about the seller's interest. Fairness then says the amateur buyer should take free, and one treatise calls the result the “garage sale” exception while adding that it is hard to exaggerate its unimportance.4 Each condition tests one feature of that purchase. The first asks what the buyer knew, the second what the buyer gave, the third what the buyer meant to do with the goods, and the fourth what the public record showed on the day of the sale.5
The deep freeze illustration shows how much hangs on these tests. Jones bought a freezer for home use from Appliance Company on a purchase-money security interest and later sold it to a next-door neighbor, Smith, who bought it for home use. Appliance's interest was perfected, yet Smith took free if he bought for value and without knowledge of it. Had Appliance filed, Smith's purchase would have been subject to the security interest.6 The subsections below take the conditions in the order the statute lists them.
Without Knowledge of the Security Interest
The first condition asks what the buyer knew: the buyer must buy without knowledge of the security interest.7 Because the lead-in ties all four conditions to the verb “buys,” the question is what the buyer knew when buying.8 A buyer who hears of the lien a week after paying did not know of it when buying.
Knowledge means actual knowledge, as § 1-202 defines it, and notice does not suffice.9 A transaction can look a little suspicious and still leave the buyer as victorious as one “without knowledge.”10 Suspicion, a bargain price, a hurried seller, and a question the buyer never asked therefore all fall short. The same definition serves the buyer who defeats an unperfected interest under § 9-317(b),11 and every Article 9 buyer rule requires that the buyer take without knowledge of the security interest.12
Actual knowledge suits the buyer the exception protects. Automatic perfection leaves nothing of record, so the neighbor who buys a used freezer cannot learn of the lien by searching.13 A test of actual knowledge asks only what this buyer was told or shown.
The public record belongs to the fourth condition. A buyer who knew nothing of a filing still loses if a financing statement covering the goods was on file before the sale, because any buyer takes consumer goods subject to the security interest once the purchase-money secured party files.14 The two conditions divide the work. A buyer who never looked at the files can pass the first and still fail the fourth, and a buyer who was told of the lien fails the first even when the record is empty.
Smith, the neighbor in the deep freeze illustration, takes free only if he bought without knowledge of Appliance's interest.15 Exam facts rarely say that so plainly, and the harder question is whether the details around a sale amount to actual knowledge.
Ruiz satisfies the condition because all he had was suspicion. Lindqvist fails it because the seller's own statement put the lien in her head before she paid. That one failure returns her to the default rule: the store's interest continues in the freezer, and the store may reach it if the seller defaults, even though the store never filed.16
A buyer in ordinary course shows how strict this condition is. A buyer who purchases a refrigerator from a merchant takes free even though the buyer may know the merchant has given a security interest in it, and the fact that the goods are on sale does not take the sale outside the ordinary course of business.17 The consumer buyer has no comparable allowance: actual knowledge of the security interest defeats the exception. The section on other buyer rules develops the comparison.
For Value
The second condition asks what the buyer gave: the buyer must buy “for value.”19 Value is broadly defined to include any consideration, including a preexisting debt, and § 1-204 sets only minimal requirements for it.20 Cash qualifies. So does a trade of other property, a promise to pay next month, or the satisfaction of a debt the seller already owed. The condition asks whether the buyer gave consideration, not whether the buyer paid a fair price, so Ruiz's $300 freezer from the preceding subsection satisfies it even though the price was low.
The condition shuts out one kind of transferee, the donee, who receives goods as a gift and gives nothing for them. Article 9 has no provision protecting donees, so the secured party prevails and its security interest can be asserted against the donee. It prevails even if it never perfected.21 Nor is value a peculiarity of this exception. The Article 9 buyer rules differ in detail, but each requires that the party who defeats the secured creditor give value.22
Gifts between neighbors and relatives trap students because the facts sound sympathetic: the recipient is innocent, the use is domestic, and no financing statement was ever filed. A student who checks knowledge, purpose, and filing, then stops, misses the defect. The four conditions are cumulative, so a donee who passes the other three still loses.23 When a transfer between households was not a sale, the value condition is the first place to look.
Buyer's Personal Use
The third condition asks what the buyer means to do with the goods: the buyer must buy primarily for the buyer's personal, family, or household purposes.25 It mirrors the seller-side requirement, so a consumer must stand at both ends of the sale. If the seller is in the business of selling these goods, the section does not apply, and it does not apply if the buyer is purchasing the goods for its business.26 The two requirements confine the exception from opposite directions. A retailer's sale to a household fails the seller side, a business's purchase from a household fails the buyer side, and only a sale between households passes both.
The dealer who takes goods in trade shows the buyer side failing. Jones bought a deep freeze for home use from Appliance Company and gave Appliance a purchase-money security interest that Appliance never filed. When Jones traded the freezer to Frosty, another dealer in deep freezes, for a more expensive model, Appliance's interest was superior to Frosty's rights, because Frosty did not buy for personal, family, or household purposes.27 The missing filing did not help Frosty, and the purpose condition alone defeated him. Smith, who bought the same freezer for home use as a next-door neighbor, takes free if the remaining conditions are met.28
The condition speaks of the buyer's purposes, so it asks what this buyer intended and does not ask what the goods were designed for.29 The lead-in ties it to the verb “buys,” which fixes the inquiry at the purpose with which the buyer buys.30 The word “primarily” matters when a buyer has more than one use in mind. The statute supplies no percentage and no formula for dividing a mixed use, so a buyer who plans both household and business use raises the question which purpose predominated when the buyer bought.31
A buyer who fails the purpose condition loses the exception however well the other three are met.32 Innocence, a full price, and the absence of any filing do not repair a business purpose. The security interest then continues in the goods under the default rule, and the secured party may reach them if the debtor defaults.
Purchase Before Filing
The fourth and last condition looks at the public record: the buyer must buy “before the filing of a financing statement covering the goods.”34 The first three conditions describe the buyer. This one asks a single question about the record on the day of the sale: was a financing statement covering the goods on file? The buyer's diligence plays no part in the answer. A buyer who never visited the filing office loses if a statement was already there, and a buyer who would have found an empty record wins even if a filing appears a day later.
The record is often empty because a purchase-money security interest in consumer goods is perfected automatically on attachment, with no filing and no taking of possession. Fixtures and motor vehicles are the main exceptions.35 Requiring a filing for every consumer credit sale would leave the filing offices bulging, and the benefits would be marginal. Potential lenders know of automatic perfection and are on guard when a consumer tries to borrow against consumer goods, and such goods cost little and depreciate quickly, so lenders other than purchase-money lenders seldom rely on them.36 The price of that system is a silent record, which leaves the neighbor buying a used refrigerator nothing to search, and § 9-320(b) is the antidote.37
The exception lasts only as long as the record stays silent. Once the purchase-money secured party files, any buyer takes the consumer goods subject to the security interest.38 Filing stays available on an optional basis even for consumer goods, and unless a financing statement is filed, a third person who buys consumer goods from the consumer-debtor may take free even of a perfected interest.39 A secured party that wants its interest to hold against a household buyer can therefore file, and one that does not file risks losing to a qualifying neighbor.
The deep freeze illustration shows both outcomes. Jones sold the freezer to a next-door neighbor, Smith, who bought it for home use. Appliance's interest was perfected, and the sale was free of it if Smith bought for value and without knowledge. But if Appliance had filed, Smith's purchase would have been subject to the security interest.40 The condition says “before the filing,” so a financing statement filed after Smith bought does not reach him.41
Step two has a wrinkle. The quoted text uses only the verb “buys,” and a problem may place a filing between the contract date and the delivery date.42 The rule that protects a buyer against an unperfected interest expressly requires the buyer to receive delivery, but that requirement belongs to that rule and is not part of the quoted consumer-buyer text.43 When the filing falls between the two dates, work the problem under each and flag the ambiguity.
Titled goods vary the pattern. A motor vehicle bought for personal or family use is outside automatic perfection, so the lender perfects only by filing or by complying with the state certificate-of-title law.44 For the casual buyer, a lien the secured creditor has effected on the certificate of title does the work of a financing statement, and the buyer does not take free once the lien is on the certificate.45 The public act that perfects a titled-goods lien is also the act that warns, so no gap opens between a perfected lien and an empty record.
If a lender never completed the lien on the certificate, it is unperfected, and the rules protecting buyers against unperfected interests take over. Under those rules a buyer wins by giving value and receiving delivery without knowledge, before the interest is perfected.46 The mistake to avoid is treating a perfected interest as one that necessarily beats the buyer. A purchase-money interest in a household appliance is perfected on attachment and still loses to a qualifying casual buyer, because no financing statement was filed before the sale.47