Concept
Consumer-to-Consumer Sales Only
Buyer of consumer goods
Consumer-to-Consumer Sales Only
The consumer buyer rule protects one kind of sale, and the opening words of § 9-320(b) say whose: a buyer of goods from a person who used the goods, or bought them for use, primarily for personal, family, or household purposes takes free of a security interest, even if perfected, provided the buyer satisfies the conditions that follow.1 The buyer must buy as a household too. Together the two requirements confine the rule to a consumer buying consumer goods from another consumer,2 or, in Professor Gilmore's phrase, to sales "by amateurs to amateurs."3 This unit takes the seller's end of that pairing; the buyer's own purpose is the third of the four buyer conditions taught next.
The seller-side limit matters because the default favors the secured party. A debtor's transfer of collateral raises the question whether the security interest continues in the goods or is cut off by the transfer.4 The donee shows the default at its plainest: Article 9 has no provision protecting donees, so the secured party prevails and can assert its security interest against the donee, even if the secured party never perfected.5 Section 9-320(b) is a provision that does protect a transferee, and its seller-side requirement marks where that protection ends.
The case for letting a household buyer take free rests on facts about household credit, and the seller-side limit follows those facts. If creditors had to file on every consumer credit transaction, the filing offices would bulge at the seams.6 The benefits of filing such security interests are marginal in any event.7 Potential creditors have long known that these conditional sales are perfected automatically, so they are on guard when a consumer tries to borrow against consumer goods.8 Most consumer goods, moreover, cost little and depreciate quickly.9 Creditors other than purchase money lenders seldom rely on them in making loans, so a later creditor is unlikely to be fooled by the absence of a public filing.10 Those facts describe household goods in household hands. They offer nothing comparable for a merchant's stock, which fits a rule that stops where the household stops.
Applying the seller-side test means asking what the person who sold to the buyer did with the goods. The lead-in turns on use: the seller must have used the goods, or bought them for use, primarily for personal, family, or household purposes.11 Use sorts sellers, so the same kind of item can fall on either side of the line. A stove that cooks for a family makes its owner a household seller; a stove in a restaurant kitchen does not. A seller who is in the business of selling the goods falls outside the section altogether, and so does a buyer who is purchasing for a business.12
A dealer in the chain shows the seller-side requirement failing while every other fact favors the buyer. Debtor bought an expensive television from S for use at home, paying over time, and S kept a purchase-money security interest that it never filed and that was perfected automatically.13 Debtor then sold the set to P, a store that buys and sells used televisions, and P put it in inventory. B later bought the set from P for home use, paid full price, and knew nothing of S's interest. B cannot invoke § 9-320(b), because B's seller was in the business of selling such goods and the section does not apply to that seller.14 B stands where any transferee stands who lacks a protecting provision, and S's interest continues in the set.15 The defect lies one step back from B: B's own purpose was household, yet the goods reached B from a merchant.
Remove the dealer and the result reverses. Debtor bought a computer on credit from S for use at home, giving S a purchase-money security interest that S never filed, and later sold the computer to B, who bought it for use at home. Debtor sold as a household seller and B bought as a household buyer, so if B also meets the remaining buyer conditions, B takes free of S's interest even though it was perfected.16 Had S filed a financing statement before B bought, B would not take free.17
The seller-side question, then, comes down to what the immediate seller did with these goods. A consumer who buys from a dealer is outside the rule for that reason alone, however household the buyer's own purpose may be,18 and a buyer outside the rule is left with the default that favors the secured party, as the donee is.19 Whether some other buyer rule might still help that consumer is a separate question, taken up in the comparison section below.