Concept
Related Buyer Protections
Buyer in ordinary course of business
Related Buyer Protections
A buyer in ordinary course of business takes free of a security interest created by the buyer's seller even if the interest is perfected and the buyer knows of it, which makes that buyer the best-protected purchaser of goods under Article 9.1 It is not the only protected transferee, though, and a student who has just mastered § 9-320(a) is tempted to carry its elements into every dispute in which a buyer beats a lender. This unit sets the rule beside its neighbors so that you can tell which rule fits which transferee.
Every dispute of this kind starts from one default: the security agreement is effective against purchasers of the collateral, and the security interest continues in the collateral after a sale or other disposition unless the secured party authorized the disposition free of it.2 A buyer in an unauthorized sale therefore takes subject to the lien, and if the debtor defaults the secured party can potentially repossess the collateral from that buyer.3 The buyer escapes only if some other provision of Article 9 applies, and the security interest also attaches to the proceeds of the sale.4
Those provisions fall into two groups that reach different distances. Some transferees take free even of a perfected security interest: the buyer in ordinary course, the consumer buyer, certain purchasers of chattel paper and instruments, and the holder in due course of negotiable paper.5 Others take free only of an interest that is still unperfected when they satisfy the statute's conditions. The principal member of that second group is the buyer who gives value and receives delivery without knowledge of the security interest before it is perfected, and the same pattern covers certain lessees and licensees.6
Because the two groups reach different distances, the analysis starts with sorting. First establish the status of the secured party. Then classify the transferee as a purchaser for value who took delivery without knowledge of the interest, a buyer in ordinary course, or a casual buyer under § 9-320(b), and the pairing of the two statuses selects the priority rule.7 The first part below sets the buyer who lacks ordinary-course status against the buyer who has it. The second part identifies the other transferees who share the power to prevail over a perfected interest, with just enough about each to show what separates it from § 9-320(a).
Buyers Who Are Not Ordinary-Course
A buyer who falls outside the ordinary-course category cannot use the sentence in § 9-320(a) that forgives perfection and knowledge. Buyers of goods that are not inventory are the standard example. A buyer of a car that a repair garage used as equipment, where the garage was not an auto dealer, is not ordinarily regarded as a buyer in ordinary course and takes subject to a perfected security interest created by the seller, whereas a buyer of a car from a dealer takes free of the interest the dealer gave its lender.8 The buyer outside the category falls back to the default rule and escapes the lien only if some other provision applies.9 The most important of those provisions is § 9-317(b), and it protects far less.
Under § 9-317(b), a buyer who gives value and receives delivery of the collateral without knowledge of the security interest and before it is perfected takes free of it.10 Each condition does its own work. Value means any consideration, including a preexisting debt, so a creditor who takes goods in payment of an existing obligation has given value.11 Knowledge means actual knowledge and not notice, so a transaction can look a little suspicious and still leave the buyer protected if the buyer did not in fact know of the lien.12 Delivery means physical delivery of the goods.13 The neighboring subsections apply the same pattern to lessees and licensees: the party who is to defeat the secured creditor must give value and, in the case of tangibles, receive delivery, all without knowledge of the security interest.14
Timing is where these buyers usually lose. Farmer Jones sold a tractor to Farmer Brown on February 2, and Brown paid the full price. Second State Bank, Jones's lender, filed a financing statement on February 3; Brown took delivery on February 4; and Jones defaulted on the loan on February 5. The bank takes the tractor, because Brown did not take possession until after the bank perfected by filing, whereas Brown, assuming no knowledge of the lien, could have kept the tractor had delivery come before the filing.15 Payment gave Brown value but not delivery, and the bank's filing fell in the gap between the two.
Both buyers paid full price against a lender that had filed. What separated them was the transaction, not the lender's filing or the buyer's state of mind: one bought equipment from a seller that does not deal in mixers, and the other bought inventory from a dealer.
The ordinary-course buyer also takes free of an unperfected security interest created by its seller, so the dates that decide the § 9-317(b) buyer's case never matter to it.16 Knowledge works in opposite directions under the two rules. The ordinary-course buyer takes free even though it knows the interest exists.17 The § 9-317(b) buyer loses its protection if it has actual knowledge: buyers who know of the security interest take subject even to an unperfected one, and lessees who take delivery with knowledge do the same.18
A buyer who does take subject to the lien gets one more form of relief, because § 9-323(d) cuts off the lien's reach over later advances. The buyer takes free of the security interest to the extent it secures advances made after the earlier of the time the secured party acquires knowledge of the buyer's purchase or 45 days after the purchase, unless the advance is made under a commitment entered into without knowledge of the purchase and before the 45 days expire.19 In a standard illustration, the debtor's machine is sold on default for $20,000, and the secured party has priority only as to $10,000, because its future advance was made more than 45 days after the sale.20 The rule trims later debt and leaves the earlier loan secured, so the buyer still loses the goods to the extent of the debt that existed at the sale. The ordinary-course buyer never needs the rule, because a buyer who takes free of the seller's interest also takes free of an interest securing an advance made after the sale.21
Other Protected Transferees
The buyer in ordinary course is one of several transferees who defeat a perfected security interest, and each of the others holds that position under its own provision with its own elements.23 Each class has a full treatment of its own, so one sentence per class is enough here:
- A consumer buyer takes free of a perfected security interest under § 9-320(b) when the seller used or bought the goods primarily for personal, family, or household purposes and the buyer buys for those purposes, as long as no financing statement covering the goods has yet been filed (or, for a motor vehicle, the lender has not yet perfected on the certificate of title).24
- A purchaser of chattel paper who in good faith and in the ordinary course of its own business gives new value and takes possession of tangible paper or control of electronic paper has priority under § 9-330 over a security interest claimed merely as proceeds of inventory, as long as the paper does not show an assignment to someone else; against any other security interest in the paper, the purchaser must also lack knowledge that the purchase violates the secured party's rights.25
- A purchaser of an instrument under § 9-330(d) who gives value, takes possession in good faith, and lacks knowledge that the purchase violates the secured party's rights has priority over a security interest perfected by a method other than possession.26
- A holder in due course of a negotiable instrument, and a purchaser with the analogous status for a negotiable document or an investment security, has priority under § 9-331 over an earlier security interest even though it is perfected, and filing under Article 9 is not notice of that interest to the holder or purchaser.27
The elements differ because each class answers a different problem. The consumer rule answers automatic perfection. A seller that keeps a purchase-money interest in a household refrigerator is perfected without filing or any other public act, so someone who later buys it from the original owner has no way to learn of the interest, and it is only fair that the amateur buyer takes free; once the lender files, the protection ends.28 The chattel paper rule answers the inventory lender's claim to proceeds. A secured creditor with a floating lien on inventory may claim chattel paper as proceeds and may have expected the debtor to sell that paper and remit the cash, so when the debtor sells the paper and fails to reduce the loan, the lender and the purchaser assert conflicting claims to it.29 The lender keeps a safe harbor, because if it stamps the paper to show that it has been assigned to the lender, the purchaser's claim is subordinated.30 The holder-in-due-course rule defers to Article 3: one who enjoys a holder in due course's rights, or similar rights under Article 7 or 8, enjoys them against the secured creditor, and if Article 3 would cut off the secured party's rights, nothing in Article 9 changes the outcome, because filing a financing statement is not notice of a claim or defense.31
Because the reasons differ, the tests do not transfer, and an answer goes wrong when it carries the ordinary-course elements into a class where they have no work to do. The ordinary-course buyer ordinarily buys inventory from a dealer, and a buyer of goods that are not inventory is not ordinarily regarded as one.32 The consumer rule runs the other way: it covers sales from one household user to a buyer who also buys for household purposes, so it does not apply if the seller is in the business of selling the goods or if the buyer is buying for its business.33 Knowledge shifts from class to class as well. The ordinary-course buyer takes free although it knows of the interest.34 A purchaser of chattel paper whom the lender challenges only as proceeds can prevail even though it knows the lender finances the dealer's inventory, but against any other security interest in the paper it must also lack knowledge that the purchase violates the secured party's rights, and a purchaser of an instrument under § 9-330(d) faces the same requirement.35
The same household freezer shows the consumer rule succeeding and failing. Jones bought a deep freeze for home use from Appliance Company and gave Appliance an unfiled purchase-money security interest. When Jones traded it in to Frosty, another dealer in deep freezes, Appliance's interest remained superior to Frosty's rights, because Frosty did not buy for personal, family, or household purposes; a neighbor who bought it from Jones for home use would take free.36 A dealer's single sale can also set off two protections at once. A dealer sold a car to a buyer who signed a security agreement for the unpaid price, and the dealer physically transferred that agreement to financer B, which regularly acquires such paper from the dealer and gave value. Financer A, which finances the dealer's inventory, has no priority over B as to the paper even though B knew of A's financing, and A's only claim is to the proceeds of the dealer's sale of the paper to B.37 The car buyer meanwhile takes the car free of A's inventory lien as a buyer in ordinary course, so each transferee is tested under its own rule.38 When a fact pattern puts an instrument, a stack of installment contracts, or a household appliance in a transferee's hands, the first move is to classify the transferee and the collateral before reciting any elements.39
Two relatives of the ordinary-course buyer share its definition, and one neighbor in Article 2 does not belong to Article 9 at all. A lessee in ordinary course takes its leasehold free of a security interest created by the lessor even if the interest is perfected and the lessee knows of it, and a licensee in ordinary course presumably has the same protection, although the comment does not say so explicitly.40 Article 2 adds a separate route aimed at an owner instead of a secured party. If an owner leaves goods with a merchant who deals in goods of that kind, such as a watch left with a dealer who repairs and sells watches, the merchant has power to pass the owner's rights to a buyer in ordinary course.41 That route has its own questions, which are what counts as entrusting, who is a merchant dealing in goods of that kind, what rights pass, and who is a buyer in ordinary course, so it is analyzed apart from § 9-320(a) even though the two share the ordinary-course idea.42