Concept
Goods Held by the Secured Party
Buyer in ordinary course of business
Goods Held by the Secured Party
Subsection (a) of § 9-320 is generous. It frees a buyer in ordinary course of business from a security interest created by the buyer’s seller, even if the interest is perfected and the buyer knows of it, and it announces its own limit at the start: “Except as otherwise provided in subsection (e).”1 Subsection (e) takes the generosity back in one case. Subsections (a) and (b) “do not affect a security interest in goods in the possession of the secured party under Section 9-313.”2 That case is the pledge. A pledge requires more than an agreement: the debtor must deliver possession to the secured party or, in some instances, to a third person acting for it.3 When goods sit in the lender’s custody and the debtor purports to sell them, the buyer does not cut off the lender’s interest, however well the buyer would otherwise qualify.
Three features of the buyer rule explain why possession changes the outcome.
The first is commercial expectation. Consumer Jones buys a refrigerator that is subject to a perfected security interest. Neither Jones, the public at large, nor even the secured creditor would expect Jones to take subject to that interest, and no one would expect Jones to search the files to learn whether the seller had granted an interest in its inventory. Section 9-320(a) “bows to that commercial reality.”4 A lender that holds the goods has left no such reality to bow to. It has kept the stock out of the seller’s hands, and nothing in the transaction invites a buyer to treat the goods as the debtor’s to sell.
The second is the buyer’s own possession. Section 1-201(b)(9) denies buyer-in-ordinary-course status to a buyer who does not obtain possession or possessory rights, and a seller whom the lender has shut out of the goods cannot deliver what it does not hold.5 Subsection (e) overlaps with that requirement. It also rejects the result in Tanbro Fabrics Corp. v. Deering Milliken, Inc. and, together with § 9-317(b), prevents a buyer of goods from taking free of a security interest when the collateral is in the secured party’s possession.6 When the secured party keeps the goods to the exclusion of both seller and buyer, the case against ordinary-course status is at its clearest.7
The third reason looks from the lender’s side. Possession perfects the lender’s security interest without a filing, so a lender that relies on a pledge leaves no financing statement for anyone to find.8 Its protection is its physical hold on the goods. If the debtor could sell goods in the lender’s custody and pass them free to a buyer in ordinary course, that protection would last only until the debtor chose to sell.
Move the same watches into the wholesaler’s own display cases, with the bank holding only a filed financing statement, and the result reverses. A customer who buys in the ordinary course takes free, because the bank’s interest is perfected but the bank does not hold the goods.9 The bank, the lien, and the goods are the same in both scenes. What differs is who holds the goods: the bank in the vault, the debtor in the showroom.
Subsection (e) measures possession “under Section 9-313,” so the question is always who actually holds the goods. The secured party may hold them itself or through a third person acting for it.10 A third-party bailee holds for the secured party only in some circumstances. For collateral other than certificated securities and goods covered by a document of title, the secured party takes possession only when the bailee has authenticated a record acknowledging that it holds the collateral for the secured party’s benefit.11 The debtor cannot hold the goods for the lender. There is no pledge where the debtor remains in possession, even where the debtor purportedly acts as the lender’s agent.12 The purpose of the carve-out explains the rule: a debtor-agent would keep the stock on the debtor’s own premises, available to display and sell, with every premise of the buyer-in-ordinary-course rule intact.
Field warehousing tests that rule. The lender’s control is placed on the borrower’s own premises, and it works as a pledge only if the supervision is tight. The danger is “too loose supervision of the warehouse operations,” and a lapse of control can cost the lender its possession. A lender that wants as much control as it likes without risking that lapse can also file a financing statement under Article 9. Its interest then stays perfected even if the warehouse is not properly conducted.13 When a fact pattern puts goods in a warehouse, ask who controls access to them. A lender that keeps real control through its custodian has possession. A lender whose custodian lets the debtor come and go freely risks losing it.
Subsection (e) also limits subsection (b), the casual-buyer rule, which this chapter takes up later.14 A secured party that still holds the goods can enforce its interest against a casual buyer just as it can against a buyer in ordinary course, whether or not it ever filed a financing statement.