Concept
The Basic Rule
Buyer in ordinary course of business
Buyer in Ordinary Course
The Basic Rule
A customer who buys a refrigerator from an appliance dealer takes it free of any lien held by the dealer's lender, and does so without searching the filing records first. Section 9-320(a) of the UCC says so: except as subsection (e) provides, a buyer in ordinary course of business, other than a person buying farm products from a person engaged in farming operations, “takes free of a security interest created by the buyer's seller, even if the security interest is perfected and the buyer knows of its existence.”1 A security interest is a lender's property claim in goods, held to secure a debt. The sentence does three things. It names the protected party, a buyer in ordinary course of business, a defined term taken up in the next section. It names the claim that loses, a security interest created by that buyer's own seller. And it sets the strength of the protection: the buyer wins against a perfected interest, and wins even when the buyer knows the interest exists. Two carve-outs open the sentence, one for farm products and one in subsection (e). Later sections take them up in turn.
Without § 9-320(a), the buyer would lose. A security agreement is effective against purchasers of the collateral, and § 9-315(a)(1) confirms that the security interest “continues in collateral notwithstanding sale . . . or other disposition.”2 The interest ends only if the secured party authorized the disposition free of it, or if the buyer takes free under some other provision of Article 9.3 A buyer who takes collateral from the debtor on any other terms takes subject to the lien, as a buyer of mortgaged land takes subject to the mortgage. If the debtor then defaults, the secured party may repossess the goods from the disappointed buyer.4 The secured party is not limited to the goods, because its interest also attaches to the proceeds of the sale. It may claim both the goods and the proceeds, but it may have only one satisfaction.5 Most of the interesting buyer cases arise under § 9-320(a), the provision that reverses this default.6
The reason for the reversal is commercial. Neither the customer, nor the public at large, nor even the secured creditor would expect a refrigerator buyer to take subject to the lien, and no one would expect the buyer to search the files to learn whether the seller had granted a security interest in its inventory to a third person.7 The Code also treats a debtor's freedom to sell as an ordinary feature of secured financing. Whether the debtor may sell the collateral and handle the proceeds is a matter for agreement between debtor and secured party, and a security interest is not invalid as fraudulent against creditors solely because the debtor may dispose of collateral or use its proceeds.8 Section 9-320(a) follows that reality. The secured party keeps its claim against the debtor and its claim to the proceeds, and the customer keeps the goods.
The rule does independent work only when the secured party did not authorize the sale. If the secured party authorized the disposition free of its interest, § 9-315(a)(1) ends the lien by its own terms.9 Where there was no authorization, as in the hypothetical, where the loan agreement forbade sales, the buyer needs another provision of Article 9 to take free, and § 9-320(a) is that provision.
Section 9-320(a) is also one priority rule among several. A priority dispute is solved by identifying the basis of each party's claim and then selecting the rule that fits those claims, because a single first-in-time, first-in-right rule will not resolve every dispute.10 The sections that follow apply that method to this rule. They define who counts as a buyer in ordinary course, then ask what it means for the security interest to be created by the buyer's seller.