Concept
Filing Office Duties
Assignment of a security interest
Filing Office Duties
Filing is how most security interests in personal property are perfected; only deposit accounts, letter-of-credit rights, and money fall outside that rule.1 Searchers depend on the filed record, so an assignment raises two questions: what the filer must put in the record, and what the filing office does with it. This unit starts with the office's side and then follows the three ways an assignment can reach the record.
Article 9 spells out the filing officer's duties. Under § 9-519, the office marks each financing statement and other filing with a file number and the date and hour of filing, makes it available for public inspection, and indexes it in the debtor's name.2 An assignment is a filed record like any other, so these duties apply equally to an initial financing statement that names an assignee and to an amendment that moves the secured-party role. The file number links the two filings: the office marks it on the initial statement, and a later amendment must cite it to reach the right file.
Filings tied to land follow a second indexing pattern. A financing statement covering timber to be cut, minerals or the like (including oil and gas), or accounts resulting from the sale of minerals at the wellhead or minehead is indexed under the debtor's name and any owner of record shown on the statement, in the same fashion as a real estate mortgage. So is a statement filed as a fixture filing.3 For filings of that kind, an assignment must be indexed under the name of the assignor as grantor.4
An assignment reaches the record in one of three ways. The assignee can be named on the initial statement, a later amendment can reflect the transfer, or, for a fixture interest covered by a mortgage, the mortgage itself can be assigned. The office handles each filing under the same duties, and the filer's choice depends on timing, scope, and the kind of record that covers the collateral.
Assignment on the Initial Statement
Section 9-514(a) provides the first route. Except as subsection (c) otherwise provides, an initial financing statement may reflect an assignment of all of the secured party's power to authorize an amendment by giving the assignee's name and mailing address as the name and address of the secured party.5 The route fits one situation: the assignment already exists when the first statement is filed. The filer puts the assignee in the secured party's place, and the assignee is the secured party of record from the day of filing.6
Naming Financer at the outset beats naming Seller and amending later. One record does the work of two, and the file never carries a stretch in which it names Seller as secured party after Seller has transferred everything. An assignee becomes secured party of record only when an assignment is disclosed in a filing, so until then the record keeps pointing at the original holder.8
Subsection (a) asks for two things about the assignee, and each does separate work. The name puts the current holder in the secured party's place. The address serves people who must send notifications. An official comment explains that the address on a filed financing statement is an address reasonable under the circumstances. A person required to notify the secured party therefore satisfies the requirement by sending the notification to that address, even if the address is or becomes incorrect, and the secured party is deemed to have received it.9 That is why the assignee's address matters. A statement that named Financer but carried Seller's old address would let a sender notify the wrong party and still comply. The filing office may refuse a record that omits the secured party's mailing address, a point taken up in the section on refusal of defective records.10
The subsection speaks of an assignment of all of the secured party's power, and that wording sets its limit. An initial financing statement has one place for the secured party, so naming one person there says that person holds everything the secured party held. The form cannot show a transfer of only part of the interest, and it cannot show a transfer made after the statement was filed.
Filing the assignment is not what keeps the assignee perfected. If a secured party assigns a perfected security interest, no Article 9 filing is needed to continue perfection against creditors of and transferees from the original debtor.11 The initial-statement route simply puts the assignee on the record at no extra cost when the transfer comes first. On a fact pattern, ask two questions in order. Did the assignment exist when the first statement was filed? Did it cover all of the secured party's power? Two yeses point to the initial statement, and anything else points to an amendment.
Assignment by Amendment
Section 9-514(b) governs an assignment made after the initial financing statement is on file. A secured party of record may assign of record all or part of its power to authorize an amendment by filing in the filing office an amendment that contains three items.13 A filing of this kind is, in form, an amendment of the original statement.14 The assignor is the secured party of record, so the debtor's signature is unnecessary; a secured party of record may amend a filed financing statement without it.15 The debtor's authorization matters for an amendment that adds collateral or adds a debtor, and an assignment adds neither.
The amendment route also reaches further than the initial-statement route. Subsection (a) reflects an assignment of all of the secured party's power, while subsection (b) permits an assignment of all or part of it.19 The initial statement can say only that one person holds everything, whereas an amendment can record a transfer of less than everything.
An exam problem about an assignment after filing usually asks what the assignee already has and what it still lacks, and the two answers come apart.
In July, Financer's interest is still perfected against Buyer's creditor, because a perfected interest that is assigned stays perfected without a new filing.20 Until October, the file still names Seller. From the October filing, Financer is the secured party of record.21 Filing an assignment is optional for perfection. It becomes necessary when a continuation, release, or termination statement is presented that someone other than the secured party of record has signed, and the amendment makes Financer the party the file recognizes.22
An amendment that gives the file number and both names but omits Financer's mailing address does not accomplish the October result. The filing office may refuse a record that lacks the secured party's mailing address, and a record the office properly refuses is not an effective filing, as a later section develops.23 Financer's perfection is untouched by the refusal, because it never depended on the amendment, but the file would go on naming Seller.
One more limit concerns what an assignment amendment changes. It changes who holds the power to authorize amendments. It does not extend the period of effectiveness of the financing statement, which only a continuation statement can do.24 An assignee who wants both a corrected record and a longer-lived filing needs a continuation statement as well.
Fixture Filings and Mortgages
Section 9-514(c) takes one kind of assignment out of the two routes above and sends it through a different system. Suppose a security interest in a fixture is covered by a record of a mortgage that is effective as a financing statement filed as a fixture filing under § 9-502(c). An assignment of record of that interest may then be made only by an assignment of record of the mortgage, in the manner state law outside the Uniform Commercial Code provides.26 Subsection (a) makes its own initial-statement route subject to subsection (c).27 The word only closes the UCC routes for this situation. The amendment from the previous section cannot reflect the transfer, and the mortgage must be assigned under the law that governs mortgages.28
The reason lies in where this kind of mortgage lives. It is a real-property instrument recorded in the land records, and it doubles as the fixture filing, so one recorded document does both jobs. Title searchers in those records follow the chain of recorded assignments to learn who holds the mortgage. If the fixture interest could pass by a UCC amendment while the mortgage passed by a separate recorded assignment, one interest would have two paper trails that could name different holders. Requiring an assignment of the mortgage keeps one chain, in the system where the searcher is already looking.
The routing also fits a boundary of Article 9, which generally does not apply to the creation or transfer of an interest in or lien on real property. That exclusion reaches real estate mortgages, even though fixtures are within Article 9.29 A mortgage is a real-property interest, so the law that already governs mortgage transfers is the natural place to look for how this one passes.
The hinge is whether the record covering the fixture is the mortgage itself. A lender whose financing statement covers a retailer's inventory, with no mortgage anywhere in the transaction, assigns under subsection (a) or (b) as the earlier sections described. Installed equipment covered by a freestanding financing statement filed as a fixture filing also falls outside the text of subsection (c), which speaks of a fixture covered by a record of a mortgage.30 The question to put to any fixture fact pattern is whether a recorded mortgage is doing the filing work.
Subsection (c) answers a question about the record, and perfection is a separate matter. An assignee of a perfected security interest stays perfected against the original debtor's creditors and transferees without a new Article 9 filing.31 A second lender that takes the loan outright and records nothing in the land records therefore remains perfected, although those records will keep showing the first lender as holder. A different mistake involves a lender that takes the mortgage note itself as collateral. An official comment states that an attempt to perfect a security interest in a secured obligation by complying with non-Article 9 law, as by an assignment of record of a real-property mortgage, would be ineffective.32 Subsection (c) tells an assignee how to show a transfer of the fixture filing of record, and it leaves perfection of an interest in the obligation with Article 9.