Concept
Twenty-Day Temporary Perfection
Perfection: filing and other required steps
Twenty-Day Temporary Perfection
Article 9 gives a secured party three twenty-day windows in which a security interest is perfected without the usual filing, possession, or control. Subsection (e) opens one for a lender that has just given new value. Subsections (f) and (g) open the others for a lender that is already perfected and releases collateral to the debtor for a limited purpose. All three close the same way: after the 20-day period specified in subsection (e), (f), or (g) expires, perfection depends upon compliance with Article 9.1 A secured party that lets the twenty days pass without completing one of the ordinary methods is therefore unperfected when the period ends.2 The windows are bridges and not destinations, so every scenario in this section turns on one question: what had the lender done by the end of day twenty to reach filing, possession, or control?
New Value Window
Under UCC § 9-312(e), a security interest in certificated securities, negotiable documents, or instruments is perfected without filing or the taking of possession or control for a period of 20 days from the time it attaches, to the extent that it arises for new value given under a signed security agreement.3 Three conditions must hold, and each one narrows the rule. The collateral must be one of the three named kinds. The interest must arise for new value, and the words to the extent confine the window to the part of the secured obligation that represents new value, so an interest securing only a debt the debtor already owed gets nothing from it. And the new value must be given under a signed security agreement. The clock starts when the interest attaches, so a lender that signs early and funds late has twenty days from the funding.
The Code defines a document as a document of title, such as a bill of lading or a warehouse receipt, and subsection (e) reaches the negotiable ones.4 While the window runs, the lender needs no financing statement. The Code's list of interests that can be perfected without filing includes an interest in certificated securities, documents, goods, or instruments that is perfected without filing, control, or possession under § 9-312(e), (f), or (g).5 During those twenty days nothing on the public record and nothing in the lender's hands shows the interest, which is why the Code keeps the period short.
The window gave both lenders the same twenty days, and what separated them was the step taken before the window closed. The lender can choose among the ordinary methods. It can take possession of an instrument or a negotiable tangible document, or take delivery of a certificated security. It can file as to instruments, negotiable documents, and investment property. And it can obtain control where the collateral is investment property or an electronic document.6
A step taken in time also preserves the lender's place in line. An interest originally perfected by one method and later perfected by another, without an intermediate period when it was unperfected, is perfected continuously.7 If instead the lender waits until after the twenty days and leaves the collateral with the debtor, the chain is broken. The date of perfection becomes the date of the late step, and the interest is vulnerable to any interest that arose during the gap and takes priority over an unperfected security interest.8
The window has boundaries that fact patterns tend to probe. It covers only certificated securities, negotiable documents, and instruments. A dealer that sells goods under a security agreement reserving a security interest for the unpaid price holds chattel paper, and a bank that takes an assignment of that paper gets no twenty days from subsection (e), because chattel paper is not among the three kinds of collateral the subsection names.9 Chattel paper is perfected by filing, among other methods.10 The window also covers only the new-value part of the interest, and it opens at attachment. The windows in subsections (f) and (g) open instead when a lender that is already perfected lets go of the collateral, which the next subsection takes up.
Release to the Debtor
Under UCC § 9-312(f), a perfected security interest in a negotiable document, or in goods held by a bailee that has issued no negotiable document for them, remains perfected for 20 days without filing if the secured party makes the goods or the documents representing them available to the debtor for one of two stated purposes.13 Subsection (g) gives the same twenty days to a perfected security interest in a certificated security or an instrument when the secured party delivers the certificate or instrument to the debtor for one of two purposes of its own.14 Both rules begin with a perfected security interest. The release extends that perfection for twenty days, and it cannot create perfection for a lender that never had it. The new-value window is different, because it opens when the interest attaches.
A financed import shows why the rule exists. An importer grants a security interest in goods it is bringing in and in the negotiable bill of lading that covers them. The bank takes possession of the bill and thereby perfects its interest in both the bill and the goods.15 The importer needs the bill to procure the goods from the carrier and sell them, and the sale is the source of repayment. When the bank releases the bill for that purpose, the bank continues to have a perfected security interest in the documents and goods for 20 days, and it files a financing statement before the period ends.16 Without the rule, the transaction the bank financed would have stripped the bank of perfection at the first step of the importer's performance.
Subsection (h) marks the end point once more: after the 20-day period expires, perfection depends upon compliance with Article 9.17 While the debtor holds the paper, the lender's position rests on nothing a searcher can check, and the short, fixed period lets the debtor carry out the sale or the presentation without allowing the arrangement to run on indefinitely.
The permitted purposes follow the collateral, so they are best learned as two short lists, one for each subsection.
- Under subsection (f), for goods and the documents representing them: ultimate sale or exchange, or loading, unloading, storing, shipping, transshipping, manufacturing, processing, or otherwise dealing with them in a manner preliminary to their sale or exchange.18
- Under subsection (g), for a certificated security or an instrument: ultimate sale or exchange, or presentation, collection, enforcement, renewal, or registration of transfer.19
Both lists describe the ordinary business of the collateral. For goods, that business is moving them toward a sale, and for paper it is presenting, collecting, enforcing, renewing, or transferring it. A fact pattern will describe the release in ordinary words, and the question is whether that reason appears on the list for that collateral. The verbs also follow the collateral. Subsection (f) speaks of making goods or documents available, which reaches goods a bailee holds as well as paper the lender holds. Subsection (g) speaks of delivery, which fits a certificate or note that physically changes hands.
The twenty days are not a general grace period for any release of collateral. They attach to a release made for a listed purpose, and a release for any other reason leaves the lender where the ordinary possession rules put it.
During a proper window the lender's job is to replace the temporary perfection with an ordinary method before the period runs out. Filing is available for negotiable documents, instruments, and investment property, possession or delivery is available for the same kinds of paper, and control is available where the collateral is of a kind that control can perfect.20 A step completed in time leaves the interest perfected continuously, because it was originally perfected by one method and later perfected by another with no intermediate period when it was unperfected.21 A step taken after the period closes finds the chain broken, and the date of perfection becomes the date of the late step.22