Concept
Compliance With Other Law
Perfection: filing and other required steps
Compliance With Other Law
Section 9-311(a) withdraws the filing default for property that another body of law already governs. Except as subsection (d) provides, filing a financing statement is neither necessary nor effective to perfect a security interest in property subject to the statutes the section lists.1 The first circumstance is a federal statute, treaty, or regulation that gives a secured party its own method of obtaining priority over a lien creditor and that preempts Article 9's method. The federal aviation act's registration system for interests in aircraft is an example.2 The second is the state certificate-of-title statute. Automobiles and trucks are generally subject to title laws, but coverage of snowmobiles, motorcycles, all-terrain vehicles, boats, construction equipment, and farm equipment varies widely from state to state.3 For anything other than a car or truck, the lender must therefore check the title law of the relevant state, because Article 9 will not answer the question.
The deference rests on one premise: these assets already have a recording system of their own, and Article 9 yields to it. The opening words of § 9-311(a) carry two consequences. Because filing is not necessary, a lender who completes the other system's step need not also file in the Article 9 index. Because filing is not effective, a lender who files there anyway has taken no perfecting step, and it remains unperfected if the other system's step is missing.
The exception is narrow, and federal preemption shows how narrow. Section 9-109(c)(1) preempts all of Article 9 (reviewed in Chapter II). Section 9-311(a)(1) preempts only Article 9's filing system and leaves the remaining Article 9 rules as governing law.4 A lender perfected through the federal aircraft registry therefore still looks to Article 9 for every rule except the filing rule. A student who sees a title statute and concludes that Article 9 has dropped out of the picture has discarded rules that still apply.
Goods stored with a warehouse or carrier raise a related problem. When the bailee has issued a document of title, Article 9 tells the lender which step perfects in the goods, and the answer depends on whether the document is negotiable. The next two subsections take the cases in turn.
Negotiable Documents
A lender who wants to perfect in goods stored under a negotiable document deals with the paper, not the goods. A bailee is a warehouse or carrier that holds goods for someone else, and the document it issues, such as a warehouse receipt or bill of lading, is a document of title.5 A receipt issued “to order of S” is negotiable; one issued “to S” is not.6 Section 9-312(c) does two jobs while a bailee holds goods under a negotiable document it has issued.7 It lets the lender perfect in the goods by perfecting in the document.8 It also ranks an interest perfected in the document ahead of any interest that becomes perfected in the goods by another method during that time.9
The paper controls because the goods are locked up in it. So long as a negotiable document covering goods is outstanding, title to the goods is locked up in the document and the proper way of dealing with the goods is through the document. An interest taken on the goods themselves in that period is subordinate to an interest taken in the document.10 A garnishment shows the effect. S stores goods with warehouse W and receives a negotiable receipt to its order, then negotiates the receipt to B. When C, a creditor of S, serves a writ of garnishment on W, no lien attaches to the goods. Had the receipt been nonnegotiable, the lien would have attached unless W had already received notification of B's rights.11 The next subsection returns to that contrast.
Perfecting in the document means using the methods Article 9 already provides for that collateral. A secured party may file as to a negotiable document under § 9-312(a),12 take possession of a negotiable tangible document under § 9-313(a),13 or take control of an electronic document under § 9-314(a).14 Possession deserves particular attention for a tangible document. For instruments, the Code's commentary treats perfection by possession as better protection than filing, and it says a prospective lender should be suspicious when the debtor does not hold the paper.15 The same reasoning fits a negotiable receipt: a lender who holds the tangible paper stands better than one who files against the document and leaves the paper with the debtor.
The priority sentence displaces an instinct from ordinary goods financing. When two perfected lenders compete, the first-in-time habit asks who filed or perfected first. Section 9-312(c) gives a more specific answer here: an interest perfected in the document outranks one that becomes perfected in the goods by another method while the document is outstanding.16
Lender Two aimed its perfecting step at the wrong object. Its filing is perfection in the goods by another method, and the rule ranks that method below perfection in the document, so Lender One's later date does not matter. The sentence has limits that its own words mark. It reaches interests that become perfected in the goods during the time the bailee holds them under the document, so a lender perfected in the goods before the document issued falls outside its wording. It also compares a document-perfected interest with one perfected in the goods. Two lenders who are both perfected in the document are not ranked by this sentence, and the general priority rules supply the answer.17
The rule runs only as long as its premise. It applies while the goods are in the possession of a bailee that has issued a negotiable document covering them.18 Perfection in the document reaches the goods because the document stands for goods the bailee holds, so a lender perfected only in the document should not assume that its perfection follows the goods out of the warehouse. The sensible precaution is a financing statement that also covers the goods, which protects the lender before and after they depart.
Section 9-312(c) applies only where the bailee has issued a negotiable document. A nonnegotiable document, or no document at all, calls for different steps, which the next subsection takes up.
Nonnegotiable Documents and Bailees
A nonnegotiable document gives the lender three routes to perfection in the goods, and filing is only one of them. While goods are in the possession of a bailee that has issued a nonnegotiable document covering them, a security interest in the goods may be perfected in any of three ways.20 The first is issuance of a document in the name of the secured party.21 The second is the bailee's receipt of notification of the secured party's interest.22 The third is filing as to the goods.23
A document here means a document of title, such as a bill of lading or a warehouse receipt.24 A nonnegotiable receipt runs to a named person and not to that person's order, and it does not lock the goods up in the paper the way a negotiable receipt does. The garnishment example from the last subsection shows the gap. Against a nonnegotiable receipt, the creditor's lien would have attached unless the warehouse had already received notification of the buyer's rights, and that notification fixes the buyer's rights against the warehouse and all third persons.25 Transfers of nonnegotiable documents follow the same pattern outside Article 9: until the bailee receives notice of the transfer, a creditor of the transferor who could treat the transfer as void may defeat the transferee.26
Holding the paper is therefore not enough. Section 9-313(a) lists possession of negotiable tangible documents, not nonnegotiable ones,27 and none of the three routes in § 9-312(d) consists of holding the receipt. A lender with a nonnegotiable receipt in hand has taken no perfecting step; the Code points it to the bailee or to the public record.
The first two routes work through the bailee, and neither needs a financing statement. Section 9-310(b)(4) excuses filing for goods in a bailee's possession that are perfected under § 9-312(d)(1) or (2).28 The Code's own summary lists the routes as alternatives: file as to the goods, send a notice to the warehouse, or obtain the document issued to the secured party.29
Under the first route, the bailee issues the document in the secured party's name.30 A nonnegotiable receipt runs to the person named in it, so naming the lender puts the lender in that position.
Under the second route, the secured party notifies the bailee, and perfection arrives when the bailee receives the notification.31 Receipt completes the route; the sender's act does not. That tracks the garnishment example, where notification to the warehouse is what fixed the buyer's rights.
The third route is the ordinary one: a financing statement filed as to the goods.32 It points at the goods and not at the receipt, so everything the earlier subsections required of a sufficient filing still applies. Filing also protects a secured party that conducts a field warehouse on the borrower's premises. If the warehouse operation is not properly conducted, the filing secured party remains perfected, so it can keep as much control as it wants without risking the consequences of a lapse in control.33
That contrast explains why the routes differ in durability. The first two are framed around goods that are in the bailee's possession, while a filing does not depend on the bailee's continued custody.
Temporary perfection when goods are released to the debtor is a separate subject, covered later in this chapter. Apart from that, a lender in Lender One's position should file as to the goods directly. The previous subsection reached the same conclusion for goods that leave the warehouse after a negotiable document has issued.
Goods sometimes sit with a bailee that has issued no document at all, and § 9-312(d) then has nothing to act on. Section 9-313(c) governs instead. It applies to collateral other than certificated securities and goods covered by a document, and it says when a secured party takes possession of collateral held by someone other than the debtor, the secured party, or a lessee of the collateral from the debtor in the ordinary course of the debtor's business.34 The condition is that the bailee authenticate a record acknowledging that it holds the goods for the secured party's benefit.35 Without a document, the bailee's signed record is what shows for whom it holds the goods. A lender whose bailee refuses to sign can still file as to the goods.36
The two settings differ in what the bailee must do. A bailee that issued a nonnegotiable document completes the lender's perfection by receiving a notice.37 A bailee that issued no document must authenticate a record of acknowledgment.38 A lender who writes to a storage company has therefore done something effective if the company holds the goods under a nonnegotiable receipt and receives the letter, and nothing effective if the company issued no receipt and never signs.