Concept
Sufficient Financing Statements
Perfection: filing and other required steps
Sufficient Financing Statements
A financing statement perfects only if it contains what Section 9-502(a) requires, and the section states the requirement as a limit: subject to subsection (b), a financing statement is sufficient only if it carries three items.1 The record must provide the name of the debtor, provide the name of the secured party or a representative of the secured party, and indicate the collateral it covers.2 Each item is therefore a condition of perfection by filing, and a record that lacks one perfects nothing, however carefully the lender chose its filing office. The preceding section asked in which state, and in which office within it, the record must be filed.3 This section asks what the record must say when it arrives, and the answer is less than a newcomer to Article 9 might expect.
The requirement is modest because a financing statement gives notice and nothing more. The record tells a searcher only that the named secured party may have a security interest in the collateral indicated; the searcher must then ask the parties for the rest, and Section 9-210 provides a procedure under which the secured party, at the debtor's request, may be required to disclose.4 Article 9 does not promise a filing system like real estate recording, where the public record lets a searcher determine the state of title to a parcel. A person who finds a financing statement must inquire into more facts than the record shows before learning the nature and extent of interests in the debtor's personal property.5 The three required items serve that limited purpose. The debtor's name is the key to the index, because financing statements are indexed under it and searchers look for them there.6 The secured party's name tells the searcher whom to ask, and the indication of collateral tells the searcher which assets the secured party claims.
Sufficiency to perfect is a different question from whether the filing office should have accepted the record. Section 9-516(b) imposes additional requirements, such as a mailing address for the debtor, and Section 9-520(a) directs the filing officer to refuse a record that does not meet them.7 A record that the office accepts and that satisfies Section 9-502(a) and (b), however, is effective even though the office should have refused it.8 An accepted record that omits the debtor's address is therefore effective for most purposes, because the address belongs to Section 9-516(b), while a record that omits the secured party's name fails under Section 9-502 whatever the clerk did.
Getting the record right matters because filing is the perfection step for most kinds of collateral. Goods (including fixtures), chattel paper, negotiable documents, instruments, investment property, accounts, and general intangibles may or must be perfected by filing; deposit accounts and letter-of-credit rights may be perfected only by control, and money only by possession.9 Even where filing is available, it is not always the strongest step. A security interest in a negotiable instrument perfected by filing is not valid against a person who later takes the instrument as a holder in due course, while a secured party who perfects by taking possession is better protected, because possession leaves no room for a holder in due course.10 The subsections below take the three required items in order, then the added content for collateral tied to land, and finally the effect of a filing made before the security interest attaches.
Debtor's Name
Section 9-502(a)(1) makes the debtor's name the first required item.11 Article 9 is exacting about that name because the name is the only handle by which a searcher can find the record. The filing officer composes the index from the debtor names on the statements, and later parties search the index under a debtor's name, so a wrong name yields a wrong index entry and misleads the searcher.12 Names go wrong in ordinary ways: Vaughan becomes Vaught, “Inc.” drops off a corporate name, or the filing officer cannot tell whether Peter or Christian is the surname.13 A rule that forgave such variants would force every searcher to guess at the spellings under which someone might have filed. The drafters accordingly served two audiences at once: filers, who need a simple and predictable way to determine a name that will be sufficient, and searchers, who need to find the record.14 The burden of accuracy therefore falls on the filer, who holds the security agreement, can check the name against a public record or a license, and gains perfection from the effort.
For a registered organization, an entity such as a corporation that exists because a state filed its founding document, the statement must give the name stated in the organization's most recent public organic record.15 The 2010 Amendments chose that source because it is official, public, and equally available to filer and searcher. Without a fixed source, a cooperative could be abbreviated Cent. Wisc. Ag. Coop, Central Wisconsin Ag. Co-op, or Central Wisc. Agricultural Co, and so on without end, even though the organization has a precise name stated in its organizational documents.16 Tying the name to the organic record narrows the universe of possible names enough that search software can catch most of the remaining variations, such as typographical errors.17
An individual has many versions of a name and no organic record, so Section 9-503 gives enacting states a choice between two alternatives: Alternative A, known as the “only if” rule, and Alternative B, the “safe harbor” rule.18 Both turn on the driver's license, because an individual who seeks secured financing usually holds a license to offer as identification, and a rule keyed to that document gives filers a predictable name and searchers a place to begin.19 Under Alternative A, a debtor who holds an unexpired license issued by the filing state can be named only as the license shows, and a debtor without one may be named by the individual name or by the surname and first personal name. Under Alternative B, the license name, the individual name, and the surname and first personal name are each acceptable, so a filer who copies the license is safe, and a filer who uses another listed form also complies.
A sole proprietorship has no separate legal existence, so the owner is the debtor, the individual-name rules apply to the owner, and the filing belongs in the state of the owner's principal residence.20 An organization that is not a registered organization is named by its own name if it has one. If it has none, the statement must provide the names of the partners, members, associates, or other persons who make up the debtor, each stated in a form that would suffice if that person were the debtor.21 Decedents' estates and trusts that are not registered organizations carry additional information requirements of their own, and the seriously misleading test applies to that information as well.22
A trade name, the label under which a business presents itself to customers, is not the debtor's name. Section 9-503(c) adopts the position that trade names are not enough.23 An owner may operate under several labels, and the index is built from legal names, so a record entered under a label lands where a search of the debtor's legal name never looks. An exam stem that says the borrower operates as a brand is therefore asking the student to find the legal name behind the brand.
The consequence of a wrong name comes from Section 9-506. A financing statement that substantially satisfies the filing requirements is effective despite minor errors or omissions unless they make it seriously misleading.24 For the debtor's name, the Code removes the room for judgment: a statement that fails to provide the name as Section 9-503(a) requires is seriously misleading per se.25 The bright line spares courts from deciding how badly a given spelling would have misled a given searcher, and it gives the filer a fixed target. A lender that finances David Davis but files against Douglas Davis has made the error the rule exists to catch.26 Unless a search under the correct name would still disclose the filing, the error is seriously misleading and the filing is ineffective.
One exception softens the per se rule. If a search of the filing office's records under the debtor's correct name, run with the office's standard search logic, would disclose the statement, the incorrect name does not make the statement seriously misleading.27 The search that counts is run under the correct name, and a record that surfaces only when someone types the lender's own misspelling gives later parties no notice. The exception exists because the name rule protects searchers, and a searcher who runs the proper search and is handed the record has received the notice the filing was meant to give. The test is also objective: it asks what the filing office's index returns, not how misleading a judge thinks the error was.
The exception can even rescue a filing under a trade name. Harry Platt, a sole proprietor, does business as Platt Fur Company, and a creditor files under the trade name. If a search under Platt, Harry turns up the Platt Fur Co. filing, Section 9-506(c) directs that the mistake in the name does not make the statement seriously misleading, and the creditor is not unperfected despite the rule against trade names.28 Because the test depends on the filing office's own software, the same erroneous statement may be effective in a state with sophisticated search programs and ineffective in a state whose software matches names more rigidly, and an office that upgrades its software can save a filing that would earlier have failed.29
The safe harbor is a rescue and not a plan. A lender that relies on it must show that a search under the correct name returns the record, and it cannot know that result in advance. A creditor anxious about its filing should have someone who did not make the filing find the debtor's correct name and search under it; if the search does not turn up the filing, something further needs to be done.30 The exact name remains the first line of defense.
Secured Party's Name
Section 9-502(a)(2) makes the secured party's name the second required item: the record must provide the name of the secured party or a representative of the secured party.34 Like the debtor's name, this item is a condition of sufficiency, so a record that lacks it cannot perfect. The two names nevertheless carry different tolerances for error, and the reason lies in what each name does inside the filing system.
The debtor's name is the key to the index, so a statement that names Douglas Davis for a loan to David Davis sits where no search for the real debtor will reach it.35 The secured party's name plays no part in finding the record. It matters only after the searcher has found the statement, when it tells the searcher whom to ask. A misspelled or incomplete secured-party name therefore leaves the record as findable as before, and Comment 2 to Section 9-506 states flatly that an error in the name of the secured party or its representative will not be seriously misleading.36 A debtor-name error is treated the opposite way: it is seriously misleading per se unless a search under the correct name would still turn up the record.37
The statute lets the statement name “a representative of the secured party” in place of the secured party itself. When one bank acts for several lenders, naming the agent bank still gives the searcher a party to ask, which is all the secured-party item exists to supply.
The same tolerance reaches a lender whose name has changed since the filing. A creditor that files under its own name has, on the better view, perfected the interest of its successor, so a filing as “Nations Bank” perfects an interest held by its successor “Bank of America,” and the commentators who address the point see no reason for another outcome.38 A trustee may contest a filing that still carries the old name, and the point is not free from doubt, but the old name suffices because anyone searching can work out who the secured party was from it.39
The leniency covers a wrong or incomplete name, and it stops at an absent one. A record with the correct debtor name and a proper indication of collateral but a blank secured-party field lacks one of the three required items, and acceptance by the filing office does not supply it.40 A record that omits only the debtor's mailing address stands differently, because that address is a Section 9-516(b) item: the office should refuse the record, but once it accepts the record, the record is effective for most purposes.41 A stem that pairs a blank secured-party field with a misspelled one is testing whether the student can tell a record that is missing a required item from a record that merely misstates one.
Indication of Collateral
The third required item is an indication of the collateral: under Section 9-502(a)(3), the record must indicate the collateral covered by the financing statement.44 The verb is looser than the one Article 9 uses for the security agreement, which must describe the collateral, and the difference is deliberate. A financing statement warns a searcher that the named debtor may have encumbered certain property, and a warning can be given in broad terms because the searcher must ask the parties for details in any event.45 The security agreement is the written agreement in which the borrower gives the lender legal rights in the collateral if the loan is not repaid.46 It settles what the lender can actually take, so it must be precise enough to resolve a later dispute over what the debtor put up.
Section 9-504 supplies two routes to a sufficient indication. The first accepts any description that would suffice in a security agreement under Section 9-108, which asks only whether the description reasonably identifies the collateral, whether by specific listing, category, a type of collateral the Code defines, quantity, a computational or allocational formula, or any other method that makes the collateral's identity objectively determinable.47 The filer need not use the Code's vocabulary; listing a hardware store's stock as “hardware goods” would surely be adequate.48 A lender financing a dealer's automobiles held for sale likewise files a financing statement covering the inventory of automobiles, because a notation on the certificates of title does not perfect that inventory interest.49
The second route reverses the rule for the security agreement. A financing statement may indicate that it covers “all assets” or “all personal property,” a super-generic phrase that names no particular item, and the Code authorizes that phrase on the financing statement only.50 The identical words are therefore sufficient in one document and inadequate in the other.
The two documents differ because they do different work. The security agreement is the debtor's grant, and in a dispute between the parties it decides which property the secured party may take; a grant of “all assets” compressed into one phrase gives a court too little to work with. The financing statement grants nothing. An all-assets indication gives the widest warning available, so no searcher is misled by it, but the width of a warning never enlarges the interest it warns about. What the lender holds is fixed by the agreement under which the interest attached, and perfection requires both attachment and a completed perfection method.51 Attachment in turn requires the debtor's agreement, value, and the debtor's rights in the collateral.52 A filing cannot perfect an interest that never attached.53
The opposite error leaves the lender short, because a statement perfects by filing only the collateral it indicates.
A correct office and a correct name cannot repair that gap, because the indication of collateral is its own condition of sufficiency. The two examples show how the documents relate: a financing statement may claim more than the agreement grants without harm, since the agreement limits what the lender holds, but it cannot claim less without losing perfection in whatever it leaves out.
A financing statement need not mention future advances or after-acquired property, because neither is among the three items on which sufficiency depends.54 Both belong to the bargain between the parties. Beth's security agreement, for example, let Farmers' Bank advance additional money with her cattle standing as security for the new advance as well as the first $10,000.55 If the bank lends her another $5,000, its security interest in the cattle totals $15,000.56 A statement that indicates cattle serves for the whole stream of advances. The same reasoning covers after-acquired collateral, with one limit that follows from the duty to indicate the collateral: later-acquired property is covered only when it falls within a category the statement indicates, so a statement indicating inventory reaches inventory the debtor acquires next year but not equipment bought the same day. Proceeds receive separate treatment later in this chapter.
Errors in the indication are measured against the general standard of Section 9-506(a): a statement with minor errors or omissions is effective unless they make it seriously misleading.57 The debtor's name carries a per se rule, and the collateral indication has none, so the question is whether the indication still puts a searcher on notice of what the secured party claims.
Real Estate-Related Collateral
Section 9-502(b) adds to the three items every financing statement needs. A statement that covers as-extracted collateral or timber to be cut, or that is filed as a fixture filing covering goods that are or are to become fixtures, must satisfy subsection (a) and also supply four further items.61 The choice of filing office, taken up in the preceding section, points these categories to the real property records, and the added content follows from that destination.62
The extra content serves a different searcher. A financing statement for ordinary goods is found through the debtor's name in a central index, but a buyer or mortgagee of land looks in the land records. A regular financing statement filed in the central office gives fixtures little protection: it is totally ineffective against purchasers of the real property and mortgagees, and protection against them requires a fixture filing, whose contents and location both differ from other filings.63 The debtor's name alone may not lead a land searcher anywhere, because the debtor may be a tenant or contract buyer who appears nowhere in the chain of title.
The four added items fall into two pairs. The first pair labels the record. The statement must say what kind of collateral it covers and that it is to be filed in the real property records, because the land records hold deeds, mortgages, and liens, among which a claim to personal property must announce itself. The second recital also shows whether a record covering fixtures is a fixture filing or an ordinary financing statement meant for the central office.
The second pair ties the record to the land. The description of the real property is sufficient if it complies with the real property filing rules of the jurisdiction, so the standard is the one the local recording system already applies to mortgages.68 Without a description, a record in a county index could relate to any tract in the county. The owner's name has a narrower trigger. When the debtor holds an interest of record, the debtor's own name leads a searcher to the parcel. When the debtor is a tenant or an installment buyer whose rights appear nowhere in the records, the statement must also provide the name of a record owner, because a searcher examines the land under the names in its chain of title.
An exam stem that describes a careful lender, a correct debtor name, and a filing in the right county office is usually leading up to the omission of one added item.
A fixture statement with the same omission is not a fixture filing, because a fixture filing satisfies both subsections (a) and (b). Because fixtures are also goods, the lender's interest can still be perfected by an ordinary financing statement in the central office, though that filing gives little protection against purchasers and mortgagees of the real property.69
The description requirement has a boundary. It applies to timber to be cut, as-extracted collateral, and fixture filings, and it does not apply to growing crops. The troublesome requirement of a real estate description for a statement covering growing crops is gone, and a security interest in growing crops is now perfected by a plain financing statement with no mention of real estate.70 A student who reasons that anything growing on land needs a land description is extending the rule past its text.
Subsection (c) offers a shortcut when a mortgage already exists. A record of a mortgage is effective, from the date of recording, as a fixture filing or as a financing statement covering as-extracted collateral or timber to be cut, but only if it meets statutory conditions.71 The conditions make the mortgage do the work a separate statement would do: it must indicate the goods or accounts it covers, relate to the land it describes, satisfy the content requirements for a financing statement, and be recorded. It need not recite that it is to be filed in the real property records, since mortgages are recorded there in any event. A mortgage that describes only the land and says nothing about goods is therefore only a mortgage, because nothing in it signals a claim to the goods.
Filing Before Attachment
Section 9-502(d) permits a financing statement to be filed before a security agreement is made or a security interest otherwise attaches.74 The permission rests on the timing sentence in the definition of perfection: a security interest is perfected when it attaches if the applicable perfection requirements were satisfied before it attached.75 The same sentence governs agricultural liens, which are perfected when they become effective if the perfection requirements were satisfied earlier.76 A lender can therefore take the perfection step first, let the interest attach later, and be perfected at the moment of attachment without a further act. The early filing must be one the debtor has authorized, as the problems below assume; with that authority, the filing need not be timed to the closing of the loan, and the closing need not wait for the filing.
An early filing does not perfect anything by itself, because perfection requires attachment as well as a completed perfection method.77 Where filing is premature, perfection does not take place until the security interest attaches.78 A lender that files in March and funds the loan in April is therefore perfected in April, and the March filing marks no change in its status. What the early filing supplies is a date.
When all the competing security interests are perfected and none is a purchase-money interest, the first secured party to either file or perfect has priority, so a secured party gets the benefit of the earlier of its filing or its perfection.79 The reason for measuring from filing is practical. Negotiating a significant loan takes days or weeks, and a rule that credited only the date of funding would force the lender either to lend without knowing its position or to leave its place in line open to anyone who moved faster. Filing is a public act whose time can be proved from the record, so it is the most certain point from which to measure.
A lender can use the rule to learn its position before it lends: it files with the debtor's authority, searches under the debtor's name, and funds only if the search shows no earlier filing covering the same collateral.
The early date also protects the lender against a creditor who levies in the gap between filing and funding. If the debtor has signed a security agreement and the lender's financing statement is on file, the lender ranks ahead of a lien creditor whose lien arises before the lender gives value.81 Delay produces the opposite result. Article 9 sets no deadline for filing after the debtor receives the collateral, but delayed filing may subordinate the lender to a third party who acts in the meantime, and a filing made within 90 days of the debtor's bankruptcy might be set aside as a preferential transfer.82