Concept
Choosing the Filing Office
Perfection: filing and other required steps
Choosing the Filing Office
A security agreement gives a lender rights in the collateral against the borrower, but it tells no one else.1 The financing statement tells everyone else, and it speaks only through the index in which it sits. Financing statements are indexed under the debtor’s name, and searchers look for them there.2 A statement filed in the wrong place never reaches a searcher, and the Code treats it as no filing at all.3 Priority shows what is at stake. Among secured creditors, priority dates from the earlier of filing or perfection, and a secured party with a signed security agreement defeats a lien creditor if its financing statement was filed before the lien arose.4 A misplaced filing earns neither advantage.
Choosing the office takes two decisions in order: the state whose filing system governs, then the office within that state.5 The state question is the harder one, and a working rule will do for now. The Code generally looks to the debtor’s location, and a registered organization (a corporation, limited partnership, or limited liability company) is located in the state where it was organized.6 An Illinois corporation is therefore located in Illinois even if its principal office and all its business are in California.7 The state of organization works as a locator because a change of organization usually leaves a trail of public notices, while goods can cross a state line with no notice to anyone.8
Several kinds of collateral escape the debtor-location rule: goods covered by a certificate of title, deposit accounts, investment property, letter-of-credit rights, possessory security interests, fixture filings, timber to be cut, and as-extracted collateral.9 The last three matter in this unit because they also change the office. For fixture filings and timber to be cut, the law of the state where the collateral is located governs perfection.10
Once the state is fixed, Section 9-501 sends the filing to one of three places: the central filing office the state designates, which takes most filings; the office that records mortgages on land, for collateral tied to real property; or a single designated office for the collateral of a transmitting utility.11 The uniform text leaves each office blank, and each state’s enactment supplies the name.12 What carries from state to state is the structure of the rule, not the name on the door.
Central Filing Office
The central filing office is the default destination. Under § 9-501(a)(2), when the enacting state’s law governs perfection, a financing statement goes to the central office the state designates in every case other than the real-estate-related ones. That residue includes goods that are or will become fixtures when the statement is not filed as a fixture filing.13 Subsection (a) yields to subsection (b), which gives transmitting utilities their own office.14
The Code centralizes because filer and searcher must reliably end up in the same place. A lender deciding whether to lend knows the debtor’s name and often little about where the debtor’s property sits, so one statewide index under that name serves the searcher, and one filing serves the filer. Earlier versions of Article 9 let each state choose central filing, local filing, or a mixture. The third alternative sometimes required both a statewide and a local filing, and as state systems were computerized, electronic searching and filing removed the convenience of the courthouse and the justification for the cost of local filing.15 The revised Article calls for statewide filing with only three exceptions, and local filing survives for real-estate-related collateral.16
A machine bolted to a factory floor shows how far the residue reaches. The machine is a fixture, but it is also goods, and a lender can perfect in it with an ordinary financing statement, as with other goods.17 That central filing gives little protection against buyers and mortgagees of the land, and the fixture filing that does is the subject of the next subsection. For the ordinary financing statement, the central office is still the proper one.
One debtor class overrides even the fixture rules. A financing statement perfecting a security interest in a transmitting utility’s collateral, fixtures included, is filed in the office the state designates for that purpose, and it also operates as a fixture filing for any indicated collateral that is or will become fixtures.18 The Code defines the term in § 9-102(a)(80), and the revised Article sends these filings to a designated central location even when the collateral is fixtures.19
A central filing also survives a change of secured party. If a secured party assigns a perfected security interest, the assignee needs no new filing to continue the perfection.20
Locating the debtor decides which state’s central office applies, and § 9-307 sorts debtors into three kinds:
- A registered organization is located in its state of organization, wherever it does business.21
- An individual is located at the principal residence, and a sole proprietorship, having no separate legal existence, is located where its owner’s principal residence is.22
- Any other debtor is located at its place of business if it has only one, or at its chief executive office if it has more than one.23
The debtor’s location picks the filing state even for goods whose competing claims are ranked by the law of the place where the goods sit. A lender with a security interest in equipment located in Pennsylvania and owned by a debtor located in Illinois files in Illinois, while Pennsylvania law governs how that security interest ranks against a Pennsylvania execution lien.24 The split lets the lender file where the debtor’s location is least likely to change, and it leaves the state where the goods sit free to set priorities between Article 9 liens and other liens.25
A stem that recites incorporation in one state, headquarters in a second, and stores in both asks which of those facts selects the office. For a registered organization, only the state of organization does.
Ace is a registered organization, so it is located in Idaho, headquarters in Washington notwithstanding, and Idaho’s central office receives every filing against it.26 National Bank filed in the right office. State Bank filed in a genuine central filing office but in the wrong state, so its interest has attached but is unperfected, however proper its notice to National Bank.27 The instinct to file where the goods are, borrowed from real estate, is exactly what the debtor-location rule overrides. A lender unsure where its debtor is located can file in more than one state as a precaution.28
Agricultural liens choose their state differently. A supplier’s agricultural lien must be created by a statute outside Article 9, and the law of the jurisdiction where the farm products are located governs its perfection and priority.29 The supplier files a financing statement covering the collateral in that jurisdiction, in the office designated under that state’s § 9-501.30 The security interest follows the debtor; the agricultural lien follows the crop.
Each filing is in the right place for its own claim, because a registered organization is located in its state of organization and a lien on farm products is perfected where the products are. The two claims sit in different states’ indexes, so a later lender who searches Nebraska under the corporation’s name will find the bank and not the supplier.
Real Property Records
Local filing survives for collateral tied to land. Section 9-501(a)(1) sends a financing statement to the office designated for filing or recording a mortgage on the related real property in two situations: the collateral is as-extracted collateral or timber to be cut, or the financing statement is filed as a fixture filing and the collateral is goods that are or are to become fixtures.35 That answers the second question, which office within the state, with the land records.36
Each category touches land. As-extracted collateral is oil, gas, and other minerals, and a security interest in them attaches upon extraction. Timber to be cut is standing timber, and a fixture is a good so affixed to realty that it has the characteristics of both personal and real property.37
Choosing the state also works differently here, because the debtor’s location does not decide it. The law of the state where the collateral is located governs a fixture filing and timber to be cut, and a security interest in minerals is perfected at the wellhead or minehead, as are accounts resulting from the sale of those minerals there.38 Land cannot move, and the searcher goes to the place where the land lies, wherever its owner lives or was organized.
The gas is as-extracted collateral, so the law of the state of the wellhead governs, and the proper office is the Oklahoma office where a mortgage on that land would be recorded. The Delaware filing sits in an index that no one searching Oklahoma’s land records will consult, so it is no filing as to the gas.
Growing crops are tied to land too, yet they stay outside this rule. The old requirement of a real estate description for a financing statement covering growing crops is gone, and a plain financing statement with no mention of real estate perfects the interest.39 Of the things that grow on or come out of land, only timber to be cut and as-extracted collateral go to the land records, so crops go to the central office like ordinary goods.
Fixtures differ from the other two categories because they leave the lender a choice. A fixture is also goods, so the lender may file an ordinary financing statement centrally. But that filing gives little protection and is totally ineffective against purchasers of the real property and mortgagees. To protect against people who hold interests in the land, the lender must make a fixture filing, whose contents and location both differ from an ordinary filing.40 A fixture filing must satisfy the ordinary content requirements and also the added requirements the Code sets for real-estate-related statements.41
A stem about a financed furnace or boiler asks whom the lender must reach. A central filing perfects the lender’s interest in the goods; if the lender also needs protection against purchasers and mortgagees of the building, only a fixture filing in the land records will do.
One debtor changes the destination even for fixtures. When the debtor is a transmitting utility, a filing covering its collateral, fixtures included, goes to the single office the state designates for utilities and does the work of a fixture filing as well.42