Concept
Control-Based Buyer Rules
Priority over unperfected security interests (§ 9-317)
Control-Based Buyer Rules
A debtor can sell collateral that carries an attached but unperfected security interest, because attachment alone does not stop the debtor from transferring its rights in the collateral to others.1 Whether the buyer takes free of the security interest then turns on Section 9-317. Subsection (b) states the pattern: a buyer, other than a secured party, of goods, instruments, tangible documents, or a security certificate takes free of a security interest if the buyer gives value and receives delivery of the collateral without knowledge of the security interest and before it is perfected.2 The price the debtor receives is a separate matter: Article 9 calls it proceeds, defined as whatever is acquired upon the sale, lease, license, exchange, or other disposition of collateral.3 The rules in this unit decide what the buyer takes, not what the debtor receives.
Everything on subsection (b)'s list is something a buyer can pick up, which is why the rule speaks of delivery. Subsections (f) through (i) extend the pattern to chattel paper, electronic documents, controllable electronic records, and controllable accounts and payment intangibles, collateral that may have no physical form to hand over.4 Each keeps the three tests of subsection (b)—value, lack of knowledge, and action before perfection—and changes one thing, the act that stands in for delivery. For chattel paper that act is delivery of each authoritative tangible copy or, where each authoritative electronic copy can be subjected to control, control of each. For the other three it is control.
The rules demand delivery or control instead of a bare contract because the buyer's last required step supplies the date that is compared with perfection. A contract of sale, and even payment of the price, is a private act that nothing in the public record reveals, and it leaves the debtor positioned to deal with the asset. Taking the authoritative copy or obtaining control moves that position to the buyer, and a buyer can hasten the move by insisting on it when it pays. A buyer that pays now and takes control later leaves the secured party room to perfect in the interval and defeat the buyer's claim to take free.
Two differences among the four texts matter before the details. Chattel paper and controllable accounts and payment intangibles protect only a buyer “other than a secured party,” while the texts on electronic documents and controllable electronic records contain no such phrase.5 And the electronic document text makes control depend on whether each authoritative electronic copy can be subjected to control under Section 7-106, while the controllable electronic record text asks for control outright.6
Buyers of Chattel Paper
Section 9-317(f) gives a buyer of chattel paper the protection that subsection (b) gives a buyer of goods, adapted to a record. A buyer, other than a secured party, takes free of a security interest if, without knowledge of the security interest and before it is perfected, the buyer gives value and takes the step that fits the form of the record: delivery of each authoritative tangible copy, or, where each authoritative electronic copy can be subjected to control under Section 9-105, control of each authoritative electronic copy.7 A familiar source of chattel paper is the dealer that sells goods to a customer on credit. The customer signs a security agreement reserving a security interest in the goods for the unpaid price, and the dealer assigns that agreement—now called chattel paper—to a bank, by outright sale or to secure a loan.8
The opening words limit the rule to a buyer that is not a secured party. When a debtor's transfer creates a security interest in the transferee, Article 9 generally resolves the contest with an earlier secured party under its priority rules,9 and § 9-317(a)(1) points the same way by subordinating an unperfected security interest to a person entitled to priority under § 9-322.10 Subsection (f) therefore serves the buyer that acquires chattel paper in a transfer that is not itself a secured transaction. The source adds that a secured-party transferee may, in some circumstances, use other rules to establish its priority; the buyer rule's own text withholds its protection from that transferee.11 Sending secured-party buyers to the priority rules gives each contest one set of tests.
The step that replaces delivery of goods reflects what chattel paper is. A contract to buy it, or payment of the price, is a private act; holding the authoritative copy or controlling it is what moves the power to deal with the paper to the buyer. The text asks for delivery of each authoritative tangible copy and control of each authoritative electronic copy, and the two clauses are joined by and.12 A buyer that collects one authoritative copy while the debtor keeps another has not completed the step. The buyer must satisfy each clause that applies to the record before the secured party perfects.
The March 1 payment was complete and innocent, yet it did not stop the bank from perfecting four days later. Delivery on March 3 would have preceded perfection and let the purchaser take free, because the only date compared with the bank's perfection date is the buyer's last required step. Where each authoritative electronic copy can be subjected to control, control replaces possession: a buyer that has agreed and paid but has not yet obtained control under § 9-105 stands where the purchaser stood on March 1.
A different rule, § 9-330, also protects purchasers of chattel paper. It gives a purchaser priority over a prior secured party's security interest in the paper if the purchaser gives new value and takes possession in good faith, in the ordinary course of its business, and without knowledge that the purchase violates the secured party's right.13 The two rules ask different questions. Subsection (f) asks what the buyer knew, whether it gave value, and whether delivery or control came before perfection; § 9-330 asks about new value, good faith, and the ordinary course of the purchaser's business. Because subsection (f) works only when the buyer's last step beat the secured party to perfection, a buyer that arrives second must look to § 9-330, which this unit does not develop.
Older descriptions of chattel paper do not match the amended Code. The source's bracketed revision note eliminates the separate definitions of “electronic chattel paper” and “tangible chattel paper” and revises “chattel paper” to address bundled transactions, particularly leases in which the value of the non-goods component, such as services, exceeds the value of the goods. Chattel paper is created only in a transaction whose predominant purpose is to give the lessee the right to possess and use the leased goods.14 Materials that route electronic chattel paper to § 9-317(d) describe the former text. The tangible-versus-electronic distinction survives in the two clauses of subsection (f), which speak of authoritative tangible and electronic copies, so classification comes first: a record from a transaction outside the revised definition is not chattel paper, and subsection (f) does not govern it.
Buyers of Electronic Documents
Section 9-317(g) completes a pair with subsection (b). Where subsection (b) protects a buyer of a tangible document who gives value and receives delivery without knowledge and before perfection,16 subsection (g) protects a buyer of an electronic document who, without knowledge of the security interest and before it is perfected, gives value and, if each authoritative electronic copy of the document can be subjected to control under Section 7-106, obtains control of each authoritative electronic copy.17 An electronic document has nothing to hand over, so control does the work that delivery does for its tangible counterpart.
The control requirement is conditional. It applies when each authoritative electronic copy can be subjected to control under Section 7-106, and it then demands control of each copy, not some of them.18 Article 7 supplies the meaning of control; this chapter relies only on the cross-reference. A buyer that controls one authoritative copy while the debtor keeps another has not taken the step the text requires. Unlike subsection (b), the text of subsection (g) does not say “other than a secured party,” so the elements to test are the ones it states: value, lack of knowledge, control where required, and timing before perfection.
The firm's Monday payment was complete and innocent, yet it protected nothing until control followed. Had control of each authoritative copy passed on Monday afternoon, ahead of the Tuesday filing, value, lack of knowledge, and control would all have preceded perfection, and the firm would have taken the receipt free. The usual error is to compare the payment date or the contract date with the filing date. The only buyer date compared with perfection is the date of the last required step, here the date of control.
Controllable Electronic Records
Section 9-317(h) is the simplest of the four rules. A buyer of a controllable electronic record takes free of a security interest if, “without knowledge of the security interest and before it is perfected,” the buyer “gives value and obtains control of the controllable electronic record.”20 The text names one substitute for delivery, control, and it sets no condition about authoritative copies and no demand for control of “each” copy. Control is therefore the event a problem must date. Payment, a signed purchase contract, and the debtor's promise to transfer control later are different acts, and none of them is control.
A record of this kind has no paper to deliver, so control does the work that possession does for goods. A buyer that pays first and obtains control later stands exposed in the interval: if the secured party perfects before control passes, the buyer does not take free. Exam stems on this rule usually give a payment date and a control date and ask which one is compared with the lender's date of perfection. Only the control date is.
The two buyers paid the same way and knew equally little. Control fell on opposite sides of perfection, and that single date decided both outcomes. The payments company cannot repair its loss by appealing to a lighter test of value and lack of knowledge: if those two elements sufficed, the control requirement would do no work.
Controllable Accounts and Payment Intangibles
Section 9-317(i) applies the same substitution to a controllable account or a controllable payment intangible. A buyer, other than a secured party, of either takes free of a security interest if, “without knowledge of the security interest and before it is perfected,” the buyer gives value and obtains control of the collateral.22 This chapter takes the classification as controllable as given and asks only what a buyer must do once the collateral has it. An account is purely intangible collateral: a right to payment not evidenced by an indispensable writing, and under Revised Article 9 no longer limited to payments for goods sold or leased or services rendered.23 Because an account has no indispensable writing, nothing exists for the buyer to take into its hands, and the rule asks for control instead. As in the preceding sections, a contract or payment alone does not supply it.
The Monday payment protected nothing until control followed. Control on Tuesday, a day before the filing, would have put value, lack of knowledge, and control all ahead of perfection, and the purchaser would have taken free. As in the preceding sections, the only buyer date compared with the filing date is the date of control.
The opening words of subsection (i) also limit who may use the rule, because they exclude a buyer that is a secured party.24 A finance company that buys a manufacturer's controllable accounts in a transfer that creates a security interest is a secured party. Even if it pays full value, obtains control, and knows nothing of an earlier lender's unperfected interest, it cannot use subsection (i), and its contest with the earlier lender goes to the priority rules for competing secured parties.25 For that reason subsection (i) matters mainly to a buyer whose purchase is not a secured transaction.