Concept
Buyers of Intangibles and Licensees
Priority over unperfected security interests (§ 9-317)
Buyers of Intangibles and Licensees
Section 9-317(d) gives intangible property its own transferee rule. A licensee of a general intangible, or a buyer (other than a secured party) of collateral other than electronic money, goods, instruments, tangible documents, or a certificated security, takes free of a security interest if it gives value without knowledge of the security interest and before the interest is perfected.1 A general intangible is the residual category of personal property, such as trademark rights, patents, and software. A licensee pays for permission to use that property without becoming its owner.
Compare subsection (b), which protects a buyer of goods, instruments, tangible documents, or a security certificate that gives value and receives delivery without knowledge and before perfection.2 Subsection (d) drops the delivery requirement. A trademark or a software right has no physical object to hand over, so possession cannot mark the moment a transferee commits itself. Three elements remain: value, no knowledge, and timing before perfection.
The protection rests on the same reliance that supports the buyer rule. An unperfected security interest gives the public no notice, so a company that searches the records before paying for a license sees an unencumbered asset and commits its money on that appearance. The lender could have perfected on any day before the license, and it is the party able to end the risk. Value keeps the broad meaning developed earlier in this chapter, and knowledge means actual awareness of the security interest, not whatever a search might have revealed. The common mistake is to look for delivery and deny the licensee protection because nothing was handed over. The text asks for no such step.
Both of the licensee's steps came before perfection, and nothing physical had to change hands, so the bank's later filing cannot reach back and cut the license off.3
Change one fact and the result reverses.
The two licensees differ in a single fact, awareness of the interest when each paid, and the licensee that knew loses.4 Its position is also worse than that of a buyer or lessee of goods in one further respect. A licensee of general intangibles outside the ordinary course of business that takes subject to the security interest has no protection against future advances secured by that interest.5 A licensee that pays after the lender has filed loses for a different reason. It did not act before perfection, so its knowledge never becomes relevant.
The buyer half of subsection (d) is much narrower, because it protects only a buyer “other than a secured party.”6 A sale of accounts or payment intangibles that falls within Article 9 gives the buyer a security interest, which makes the buyer a secured party. Its contest with an earlier secured party therefore goes to § 9-322, which ranks competing interests by filing and perfection and does not ask about knowledge. Section 9-317(a)(1) makes the connection: a security interest is subordinate to the rights of a person entitled to priority under § 9-322.7 The exclusion keeps each contest under a single test.
Priority between the two follows the first-to-file-or-perfect ordering of § 9-322, so the finance company's innocence earns it nothing.8 The usual error is to see value and a lack of knowledge, conclude that the buyer is protected, and never ask whether the buyer is a secured party. A buyer whose purchase falls outside Article 9 is not a secured party and can use the rule.
Subsection (d) opens with the words “Subject to subsections (f) through (i),” so it yields to the control-based buyer rules that the next section covers.9 It governs as the general rule for an ordinary intangible that no later subsection claims. A problem involving chattel paper or an electronic asset should go to those rules before subsection (d) is applied.
Subsection (e) supplies the last limit. A purchase-money lender that files before or within 20 days after the debtor receives the collateral takes priority over a buyer, lessee, or lien creditor whose rights arise between attachment and filing.10 The list names no licensee, so a licensee of software does not take subject to a later perfected purchase-money security interest.11 The contrast with goods is sharp. A buyer or lessee of goods that took delivery without knowledge while the purchase-money interest was unperfected still loses if the lender files in time. A licensee that paid in the same gap keeps its license even though the lender perfects within the 20 days.
The buyer in ordinary course of goods does better than any transferee under subsection (d). A buyer in ordinary course of business of goods (other than farm products) from a seller that created the security interest takes free of a perfected security interest even if it knows the interest exists, and it also takes free of an unperfected one.12 Subsection (d) offers nothing like that. It protects only a transferee that acts before perfection and without knowledge. The ordinary-course buyer has its own section later in this chapter.