Concept
Lessees and Other Transferees
Priority over unperfected security interests (§ 9-317)
Lessees and Other Transferees
A lessee of goods gets the same protection against an unperfected security interest that a buyer of goods gets. Under § 9-317(b), a buyer other than a secured party takes free of a security interest in goods, instruments, tangible documents, or a security certificate if the buyer gives value and receives delivery of the collateral without knowledge of the security interest and before it is perfected.1 Subsection (c) gives priority to a lessee that receives delivery of collateral subject to an unperfected security interest.2 It uses the buyer's test: value, delivery, and no knowledge, all before perfection.3
Suppose Lender holds an unperfected security interest in a mulcher owned by Redwood Landscaping. Cal leases the mulcher from Redwood, pays the first month's rent, hauls the machine to his job site, and has never heard of Lender. A week later, Lender files its financing statement. Cal's leasehold has priority over Lender's security interest, because Cal gave value, received delivery, and lacked knowledge, and he did all three before Lender perfected. Change any one fact and Cal can no longer rely on subsection (c). If Cal signs the lease but the mulcher stays on Redwood's lot, he has not received delivery. If a Redwood employee tells Cal about Lender's loan before Cal takes the machine, he has knowledge. If Lender files before Cal takes the machine, perfection came first.
The neighboring subsections protect other transferees on the same terms, adjusted to the collateral. The 1999 Code gives priority to a licensee of a general intangible, and to a buyer of accounts, general intangibles, electronic chattel paper, or investment property other than certificated securities, if the licensee or buyer gives value without knowledge of the security interest and before it is perfected.4 No delivery step appears there. Delivery matters for tangible collateral and for intangible collateral represented by an indispensable "res" like an instrument.5 A transferee of an account or a license has nothing to take delivery of, so only value, knowledge, and timing remain. The next section takes up those transferees in detail.
Treat the subsection letters with care. The lettering above is the 1999 Code's, which puts tangible chattel paper in the buyer rule of subsection (b) and electronic chattel paper in subsection (d).6 The sections below take up chattel paper, electronic documents, and controllable electronic assets under control-based rules, so check the current text of § 9-317 before relying on the 1999 letters for those assets.
Subsection (e) can override all of this. Subsection (b) itself opens with the words "except as otherwise provided in subsection (e)."7 Subsection (e) gives a purchase-money security interest priority over the rights of a buyer, lessee, or lien creditor that arise between attachment and filing, if the secured party files before or within 20 days after the debtor receives delivery of the collateral.8 Sections 9-320 and 9-321 qualify that rule in turn. Now change the hypothetical. Lender financed Redwood's purchase of the mulcher, and its security interest attached on March 1, when Redwood received the machine. Cal took delivery under his lease on March 5, and Lender files on March 15. Lender filed within 20 days, and Cal's rights arose between attachment and filing, so Lender's security interest takes priority over them. Cal loses even though he satisfied every element of subsection (c).