Concept
Lien Creditors
Priority over unperfected security interests (§ 9-317)
Lien Creditors
A creditor whose lien on the collateral arises before the secured party perfects ranks ahead of the secured party. Section 9-317(a)(2) produces that result by making a security interest subordinate to the rights of a person that “becomes a lien creditor before the earlier of the time” that either of two events occurs.1 The first event is perfection of the security interest. The second is the meeting of one of the § 9-203(b)(3) conditions (usually a signed security agreement) together with the filing of a financing statement that covers the collateral.2 Section 9-317(a) lists the persons to whom a security interest is subordinate,3 and commentators regard paragraph (2), the lien creditor rule, as the most important part of the section.4
The subsection opens with the words “except as otherwise provided in subsection (e),” and subsection (e) is the purchase-money exception: the holder of a purchase-money security interest has 20 days after the debtor receives delivery of the collateral in which to file.5 A financing statement filed within that window takes priority over a lien creditor whose rights arose between attachment and filing.6 That exception has its own section later in this chapter, and this unit concentrates on the ordinary rule.
The ordinary rule is a comparison of two dates. The lien creditor wins if its lien arose first, and the secured party wins if it perfected first, or reached the filing-and-agreement alternative first. Because the rule runs on timing alone, it never asks what the lien creditor knew. The buyer rules are different: a buyer takes free only if it gives value and receives delivery without knowledge of the security interest and before perfection,7 and the neighboring rules for lessees and licensees likewise require value and, for tangible collateral, delivery, all without knowledge.8 Paragraph (a)(2), as quoted above, contains none of those conditions.
The first subsection below defines who counts as a lien creditor. The second works through the timing comparison. The bankruptcy trustee is also a lien creditor under the definition, and the trustee has a section of its own further on.
Who Is a Lien Creditor
A lien creditor is a creditor that has obtained a lien on the debtor's personal property by execution, attachment, or levy, and the definition also covers an assignee for the benefit of creditors, an equity receiver, and the trustee in bankruptcy.9 Such a creditor outranks an unperfected secured party but loses to a secured party that had already perfected when the lien arose.10
The word lien carries the weight in that definition. A creditor that wins a lawsuit holds a judgment, and a judgment is not yet a lien on any of the debtor's property; the lien comes from the enforcement step. One standard illustration has a creditor obtain a judgment on one day and “a lien by execution on the next day.”11 A creditor holding only an unpaid invoice, or only a judgment it has not yet enforced, has not obtained a lien by execution, attachment, or levy and is not yet a lien creditor.12
Because § 9-317(a)(2) measures priority from the moment the lien arises, the date of the lien has to be fixed, and state law fixes it. The key to every such dispute is the precise point at which each contestant's rights are deemed to arise; whoever is first in time wins.13 For an execution lien creditor, the majority rule fixes that point at the moment the sheriff levies on the debtor's property. In a minority of states the creditor's rights date back to delivery of the writ of execution to the sheriff, on condition that a levy is timely made.14 In most states, then, the question is whether the judgment creditor obtained a levy before the secured party perfected.
The bank that files between writ delivery and levy therefore wins in one state and loses in the other, so a good answer names the date on which the lien arose before comparing it with the date of perfection.
Article 9 also gives lien creditor status to representatives of creditors that never levy on anything. An assignment for the benefit of creditors is a state-law alternative to a chapter 7 liquidation: the debtor voluntarily transfers all of its nonexempt assets to an assignee in trust, to be liquidated and distributed to creditors pro rata, and the creditors need not consent.15 The assignee is a lien creditor from the time of the assignment, and a receiver in equity is a lien creditor from the time of appointment, even though the creditors they represent are general creditors and not lien creditors.16 Each therefore has priority over a security interest that is unperfected when the status arises, while a security interest already perfected at that moment keeps priority over the representative's later lien.17
Perfection is not a complete shield in every case. A perfected security interest can still be attacked as a fraudulent transfer under state law where the value of the collateral is substantially disproportionate to the debt secured, or where other facts show the interest was taken in fraud of other creditors.18 The third representative named in the definition, the bankruptcy trustee, has a section of its own below.
Perfection Before the Lien
Clause (A) of § 9-317(a)(2) sets up a race between two dates. The lien creditor runs from the date its lien arose, and the secured party runs to the date its interest was perfected.20 If the secured party files or otherwise perfects before the creditor obtains a lien, the secured party has priority; if the creditor obtains its lien first, the creditor has priority.21
The Code never states directly that a perfected secured party beats a later lien creditor. The rule is implied: § 9-317(a)(2) subordinates an interest that is still unperfected when someone becomes a lien creditor, so an interest perfected earlier falls outside that subordination and keeps its priority.22
Perfection is a status with requirements, and the date of perfection is the date the last of them was met. Perfection means that the security interest has attached and the secured party has taken the applicable perfection step, such as filing a financing statement or taking possession.23 Attachment comes first: there is no attachment until the debtor has rights in the collateral, and there can be no perfection until there is attachment.24 A financing statement filed in January for equipment the debtor does not acquire until March therefore perfects nothing until March, however early the filing was.
Clause (B) gives the secured party a second way to stop the clock. Once a financing statement covering the collateral is filed and one of the § 9-203(b)(3) conditions is met (usually a signed security agreement), that moment counts even if perfection itself comes later, so the secured party gets the earlier of the two times.25
A credit sale shows the same comparison from the winning side. A debtor buys equipment from S on April 1 and gives S a security interest to secure the price, and the goods are delivered on April 5. On May 1, L obtains a judgment against the debtor and obtains a lien by execution the next day. S prevails if it filed, and so perfected, in time to precede L's lien; otherwise L's lien has priority.27 Only the date L's lien arose counts on L's side of the comparison, so what L knew about S, and when L's own debt was incurred, play no part.28
The purchase-money grace period is the one route by which a filing made after the lien arose can still win. Outside it, a secured party that perfects after the lien arises gets no help from its earlier agreement or advance.