Concept
Unperfected Interests and Third Parties
Priority over unperfected security interests (§ 9-317)
Priority Over Unperfected Security Interests
Unperfected Interests and Third Parties
Suppose Northside Bank lends $50,000 to Ridge Printing and takes a security interest in Ridge's printing press. The interest attaches, but the bank never perfects it. Three people then want the press: a supplier holding only an unpaid invoice, a creditor that has obtained a lien on the press, and a buyer who pays Ridge for it without knowing about the bank. The bank beats the supplier, because a secured creditor has a superior claim to the collateral over an unsecured creditor who holds no lien. It usually loses to the lien creditor and to the buyer who gave value and took without knowledge.1
Section 9-317 turns that pattern into rules. Its lead-in provides that a security interest or agricultural lien "is subordinate to the rights of" the persons the subsection goes on to list.2 The section as a whole collects the interests that take priority over a security interest or take free of it.3 "Subordinate" is a word about rank, not validity. The bank's unperfected interest still exists and still binds Ridge, but it stands behind each listed competitor. Agricultural liens come under the same opening words, though this chapter concentrates on security interests.
An unperfected security interest usually loses to lien creditors and to buyers who give value and take without knowledge. It keeps its priority over unsecured creditors who hold no lien.
The contrast inside that rule is the one to hold onto. The supplier with only an invoice and the creditor with a lien are both creditors of Ridge, yet they land on opposite sides of the bank. The difference is the lien.
The subsections that follow take the competitors in turn: perfected secured parties, lien creditors, buyers of tangible collateral, lessees and other transferees, buyers and licensees of intangibles, buyers who rely on control, and the bankruptcy trustee. They also cover the purchase-money grace period and the buyers protected in ordinary course and in consumer-to-consumer sales. For each competitor, ask what it must have done, and by what point, to outrank an interest that has not been perfected.