Concept
Charges for Responses
Request for accounting (§ 9-210)
Charges for Responses
Section 9-210(b) sets the secured party's baseline duty: within 14 days after receipt of a request, sign and send the debtor an accounting in answer to a request for an accounting, and an approval or correction in answer to a request regarding a list of collateral or a statement of account.1 The subsection begins, however, with the words “subject to subsections (c), (d), (e), and (f).”2 Those four subsections qualify the baseline, and this unit takes them in turn. Subsection (f) fixes who pays for responses. Subsection (c) lets a secured party that claims every item of a type answer a list request with one short statement. Subsections (d) and (e) tell a person that once claimed an interest, and no longer does, how to answer.
Subsection (f) allocates the cost of answering. A debtor is entitled without charge to one response to a request under the section during any six-month period, and the secured party may require payment of a charge not exceeding $25 for each additional response.3 Every response costs the secured party effort, since someone must pull the loan records, compare them with the debtor's draft or assemble an accounting, and prepare a signed record. The rule divides that cost in two. The free response keeps the cost from standing between the debtor and its first look at the secured party's records, and the fee for later responses keeps a debtor from loading the secured party with unlimited free work. The $25 ceiling completes the design, because a fee that could grow without limit might deter a debtor with a good reason to ask again, such as one who needs an updated figure after several payments.
The words not exceeding make $25 a ceiling, so a secured party may charge less, or nothing, for an additional response. The ceiling applies to each additional response separately. A debtor that receives one free response and then two more in the same period may be charged up to $25 for each of the two. A secured party that demands $60 for the second response asks for more than § 9-210(f) allows.4
The phrase any six-month period means the free allotment renews.5 A debtor that has received no response in the preceding six months is entitled to one without charge, so the right does not expire after a single use. Balances fall, new lenders appear, and a figure that was accurate last winter may be stale by autumn. A renewing allotment gives the debtor a fresh free response when its circumstances have plausibly changed, and it limits the secured party to one free response in any six months.
Exam questions on this subsection usually supply a sequence of dates and ask what the secured party may charge at each point.
The free allotment attaches to the period and not to the type of request. The statute gives the debtor one free response to a request under the section, and each of the three request types is a request for this purpose.6
Blanket Collateral Statement
A secured party that claims a security interest in all of a particular type of collateral owned by the debtor may answer a request regarding a list of collateral with a short statement of that fact: a signed record, sent to the debtor within 14 days after receipt, that includes a statement to that effect.8 The ordinary answer to a list request is a signed approval or correction of the debtor's draft, which obliges the secured party to check the debtor's items against its own records.9 Subsection (c) offers a second way to discharge the same duty, and the opening words of § 9-210(b) are what let it stand in for the first.10 The statute says may, so the shortcut is an option. A lender with a lien on all of a debtor's inventory can still approve or correct an itemized list if it prefers.
The shortcut fits collateral that turns over. A debtor who asks for a list wants to know which assets the secured party claims. When the collateral is a fixed set, such as three machines, an itemized answer is easy to give and stays accurate. Inventory behaves differently, because goods leave the shelves when they are sold and new goods arrive to replace them. A list compiled on Monday may name goods sold by Friday and omit goods that arrived on Wednesday, so approving or correcting it means an inventory count that yields a document out of date almost as soon as it is signed. A statement that the secured party claims all of the debtor's inventory stays true while the individual items turn over, and it gives the debtor and any prospective lender the fact that matters: the whole category is encumbered. A signed record containing that statement is a sufficient answer.11
Step two does the real work, because the statement represents the extent of the secured party's claim, and the debtor will rely on it. A prospective lender who reads that the secured party claims all of the debtor's inventory will conclude that none of it is available as collateral. That conclusion holds only if the claim covers every item of the type that the debtor owns, so a lien on part of a type does not qualify. Were the shortcut open to a secured party claiming less, the debtor could no longer show a new lender which assets are free of the lien.
A frequent exam pattern tests step two by giving the secured party a claim to less than a whole type and having it use the blanket wording anyway.
Step one confines the shortcut to list requests, because an all-of-a-type statement answers only the question of what collateral the secured party claims. A request regarding a statement of account asks the secured party to approve or correct a dollar figure, and a request for an accounting asks it to prepare the figure itself, so a claim to all inventory supplies neither. A lender with a lien on all of a debtor's inventory that receives either request must still answer under subsection (b), by signing and sending an accounting in the one case and an approval or a correction in the other.12 The shortcut also leaves the response period untouched, because the 14 days run from receipt whichever form of answer the secured party chooses.
Disclaiming an Interest in Collateral
Subsection (c) serves a recipient that claims every item of a type of collateral, and subsection (d) serves one that claims nothing. A person that receives a request regarding a list of collateral, claims no interest in the collateral when it receives the request, and claimed an interest in it at an earlier time must send the debtor a signed record within 14 days after receipt.14 Section 9-210(b) makes the general duty subject to subsection (d), so a former claimant is not held to the ordinary answer to a list request, a signed approval or correction of the debtor's list.15 That ordinary answer is a statement about what the recipient claims, and a recipient that claims nothing has no claim to confirm or amend. Subsection (d) therefore substitutes a different signed record, one that says the interest is gone and points the debtor onward.
The record has two parts, and each answers a separate problem. The first is a disclaimer of any interest in the collateral.16 Lenders routinely sell loans and transfer the liens that secure them, and a debtor who dealt with the original lender will often keep writing to it, unaware that anyone else holds the interest. If the original lender could ignore the request, the debtor could not tell whether silence meant refusal, a lost letter, or a lien that had moved elsewhere. A signed disclaimer ends that doubt on the one point the recipient can speak to with authority, since it is the party that last held the interest. The second part supplies the next step: if the recipient knows of an assignee of or successor to its interest, the record must give that person's name and mailing address.17 The disclaimer alone would tell the debtor only that it wrote to the wrong party. The name and address tell the debtor where to send the request next.
The knowledge qualifier in the second part matters when the recipient has nothing to report. A lender whose loan was repaid and whose lien was released claimed an interest earlier and claims none now, so subsection (d) reaches it, but there is no assignee or successor to name, and the signed disclaimer by itself is a complete response. The same is true of a lender that sold its loan through an intermediary and never learned who the final buyer was. The statute asks the recipient to pass along what it knows and does not ask it to investigate.18
A debtor's list request sometimes reaches a recipient that never had anything to do with the collateral, and the exam question is whether subsection (d) then demands a disclaimer.
The earlier claim is the only fact that separates Lakeshore from the manufacturer, since both claim nothing on the day the request arrives. Lakeshore once held the lien, so it holds the debtor's only lead to the current holder, and the manufacturer holds no lead at all. The present claim separates Lakeshore from the bank in the same way, because a recipient that still claims an interest answers under § 9-210(b)(2).19
The sorting works because each step looks at what the recipient claims on a specific day. A recipient that still claims an interest at receipt falls outside subsection (d), and a disclaimer from it would misdescribe its position to a debtor who will pass the record along to prospective lenders. The statute also requires a signed record sent to the debtor within 14 days after receipt, so a former lender's helpful telephone call saying that the loan was sold does not comply.20 Subsection (d) governs only the request regarding a list of collateral. The parallel rule for a former holder of the debt, which answers a request for an accounting or a request regarding a statement of account, turns on the obligations and not on the collateral, and the next section takes it up.
Disclaiming an Interest in Obligations
Subsection (e) completes the former-claimant rules by turning from the assets to the debt. A person that receives a request for an accounting or a request regarding a statement of account, claims no interest in the obligations when it receives the request, and claimed an interest in the obligations at an earlier time must send the debtor a signed record within 14 days after receipt.22 Subsection (d) applied the same design to a list request, where the question concerns the collateral. Subsection (e) takes the other two request types, the ones that ask the recipient to speak about the unpaid obligations, and it asks the same two things of a former claimant: a disclaimer and, when known, a pointer to whoever took its place.
The reason for a separate rule begins with what the ordinary answers assume. A secured party that receives a request for an accounting signs and sends an accounting, and one that receives a request regarding a statement of account signs and sends an approval or correction of the debtor's figure.23 Each answer presupposes a recipient that is still owed money, because a person can state what is owed only on a debt it holds. The opening words of § 9-210(b) make those duties subject to subsection (e), which moves a former holder out of the baseline and into its own rule.24 A lender that sold the loan last spring has no current balance to report and cannot vouch for a figure the debtor drafted, since the balance is now a matter between the debtor and the buyer. Meanwhile the debtor, who may never have been told of the sale, will usually write to the lender it signed with, and silence from that lender would leave the debtor unable to tell a refusal from a lost letter from a transferred debt. A signed disclaimer removes the doubt, and the successor's name and address tell the debtor where to send the request next. The former lender is spared the task of producing an accounting for an obligation it no longer owns, and the response costs it little because it already knows where the debt went.
The signed record has two parts. The first is a disclaimer of any interest in the obligations.25 The second depends on what the recipient knows: the record must provide the name and mailing address of any assignee of or successor to the recipient's interest in the obligations.26 An assignee is a person to whom the recipient transferred its rights, and a successor is anyone else who has stepped into its position. The knowledge qualifier keeps the burden small, since the recipient passes along what it knows and need not investigate. A lender whose loan the debtor repaid in full also claimed an interest earlier and claims none now, so subsection (e) reaches it too, and with no assignee to name, the signed disclaimer alone is a complete response.
The lender that kept the loan sits at the other end of the range. It claims an interest in the obligation when the request arrives, so a disclaimer would misdescribe its position to a debtor who will pass the record along. It must sign and send an accounting in answer to a request for an accounting.27 The same is true of a lender that sold only part of the loan, because on the day of the request it still claims an interest in the obligations.
Students most often skip the first step of the checklist, because a lender that has sold everything stands in the same position under both subsections while the subject it disclaims changes with the request.
Had the restaurant sent a list of its equipment instead, Northgate would have answered under subsection (d) with a signed disclaimer of any interest in the collateral. The two signed records look much alike, but each disclaims the subject the request asks about, so the type of request fixes which subsection applies and what the former claimant must disclaim. A recipient that never held an interest in the obligations, such as a bank that only holds the debtor's checking account, is reached by neither subsection, since it has no lien to disclaim and no successor to identify. What happens when a recipient that owes a response stays silent is a question for the enforcement sections later in this chapter.