Concept
Preserving Rights on Paper
Duty of care for collateral in the secured party's possession (§ 9-207(a))
Preserving Rights on Paper
A promissory note can sit in a locked safe and still lose its value. The note is worth what the people liable on it can be made to pay, and those claims can die while the paper itself stays perfectly safe. The second sentence of § 9-207(a) addresses that risk: "In the case of chattel paper or an instrument, reasonable care includes taking necessary steps to preserve rights against prior parties unless otherwise agreed."1
The sentence creates no second duty. It says what the general duty of reasonable care in the custody and preservation of collateral requires when the collateral in the secured party's possession is this kind of paper. A secured party holding a promissory note must therefore do two things: keep the note safe, and take the steps needed to keep the note's claims alive.2 (The whole subsection yields to the exception in subsection (d), which a later section covers.)
Pledges of paper are old and common. A borrower can hand over a promissory note, a bond, or a negotiable document and do without it while the loan is outstanding.3 Once the borrower delivers the paper, the secured party holds it and is the one positioned to act on it. That explains why the statute treats keeping the claims alive as part of caring for the collateral. The "prior parties" are the people whose liability stands behind the paper, such as an indorser. The statute asks for the necessary steps to preserve rights against them, whatever those steps turn out to be for the paper in hand.
The closing phrase, "unless otherwise agreed," governs what happens when the security agreement hands those steps to someone else.4
A debtor that already collects on its own paper may sensibly keep doing so, and the phrase lets the parties arrange it that way. The qualifier works in one direction only. It removes the secured party's responsibility for these steps when the parties actually agree to move them, and where the security agreement is silent, the steps stay with the secured party in possession. The phrase also belongs to this one sentence and answers only who performs the paper-preserving steps. How far the parties may reshape the general duty of reasonable care is a separate question for a later section.
The special sentence reaches chattel paper and instruments and stops there. A pledged diamond ring or a warehouse of inventory is goods, so the holder owes the general standard of safekeeping and preservation and has no claims against prior parties to protect. Pledged stock is the tempting mistake, because a stock certificate looks like paper. But the commentary sorts investment property into its own category, apart from instruments, with its own methods of perfection, filing or control.5 The second sentence does not name it. The pledgee of stock still owes the general duty, and that duty has teeth. In the commentary's example, a pledgee knew that rights to buy additional shares would expire on a stated date and failed to tell the pledgor. It was liable for the resulting loss because it had failed to use due care.6