Concept
The Reasonable Care Standard
Duty of care for collateral in the secured party's possession (§ 9-207(a))
The Reasonable Care Standard
Section 9-207(a) states the duty in one sentence: a secured party "shall use reasonable care in the custody and preservation of collateral in the secured party's possession."1 The subsection yields to subsection (d), which the section on buyers and consignors takes up, so what follows concerns the ordinary secured party holding collateral. Reasonableness is the measure because collateral ranges from a diamond ring to a warehouse of perishable goods, and no fixed list of precautions could fit both. The statute asks what a careful holder of that kind of property would do and lets the facts supply the details.
The standard's two nouns cover different ground. Custody means safekeeping: the holder keeps the collateral from being lost, stolen, or damaged. Preservation protects value, and it includes taking reasonable steps to lessen depreciation.2 For a diamond ring, a locked safe satisfies both, because it protects the ring and its worth together. For machinery that corrodes outdoors or goods that spoil, custody is not enough, because value drains away while the collateral sits in secure hands. Preservation is therefore the half of the standard that can require a holder to act.
Reasonable care protects collateral from the holder's own neglect; it does not guarantee the collateral's price. Debtor F pledged shares of Y Corporation to G. The shares fell sharply in value while G held them, and G did not sell. G was not responsible for the decline, particularly because F had the same opportunity as G to follow the stock's value.3 A rule requiring a sale at every price drop would turn a standard of conduct into insurance against the market.
Liability attaches instead to loss that the holder's own failure produces. A pledgee is liable for any loss caused by failure to exercise due care.4 The test is causal, and silence can cause loss as surely as carelessness can.
The same duty governs collateral taken after default. Upon default the secured party has a right to possession, and when the collateral is goods it may take them without a breach of the peace or by court action.5 Possession triggers the duty, not the route to it, so repossessed goods carry the same obligation to use reasonable care in custody and preservation, including reasonable steps to lessen depreciation.6 A holder that takes goods whose value falls quickly and leaves them exposed for months has not met that duty.
Reasonable care does not make the secured party an insurer. The debtor still owns the collateral, so the risk of accidental loss or damage stays with the debtor to the extent of a deficiency in any insurance coverage.7 The statute protects the debtor against what the holder's possession adds to the collateral's exposure. It does not shift to the holder the ordinary risks of ownership that the debtor carried before delivery.
Section 9-207 also gives the general standard concrete content without replacing it. The secured party must keep the collateral identifiable, though fungible collateral may be commingled.8 That rule serves safekeeping, because goods that cannot be traced to the debtor cannot be returned to the debtor when the debt is paid. Use or operation of the collateral is allowed only in limited circumstances, and preserving the collateral or its value is one of them.9 That rule serves preservation, since some property holds its value only when it is kept in working order. For chattel paper and instruments, reasonable care also includes taking the steps necessary to preserve rights against prior parties unless the parties agree otherwise, a point the next section develops.10 Because these specific rules illustrate careful custody and leave the general duty in place, a holder that follows each of them can still breach subsection (a) by neglecting a reasonable step that none of them mentions.