Concept
Limits of the Rule
Use or disposition of collateral by debtor (§ 9-205)
Limits of the Rule
Section 9-205(a) answers one question: may the debtor's other creditors strike down a security interest because the debtor was free to deal with the collateral? The answer is no, but only on the grounds the section lists. A security interest "is not invalid or fraudulent against creditors solely because" of what follows, and the word solely confines the protection to that single ground of attack.1 The listed facts are the debtor's right or ability to use, commingle, or dispose of collateral, including returned or repossessed goods, and the secured party's failure to require the debtor to account for proceeds or replace collateral.2 The section removes each of these as a ground for invalidity and goes no further.
Four neighboring questions sit close enough to § 9-205 to tempt a student into over-reading it. Each belongs to a different rule:
- What the debtor may do with the collateral as against the secured party.
- Whether a buyer who acquires collateral from the debtor takes it free of the lien.
- Whether a lender that grants the debtor liberty becomes answerable for what the debtor does with it.
- Whether the lien can be attacked on some ground independent of the debtor's freedom.
A short hypothetical shows the line between the first question and the section itself. A lender takes a security interest in a debtor's equipment, and the security agreement forbids any sale. The debtor sells a machine anyway, and the lender never asks where the money went. A trade creditor then argues that the lien is invalid because the debtor could sell the machine and the lender never policed the proceeds. Section 9-205(a) defeats that argument, since freedom to dispose and failure to account are not grounds for invalidity against creditors. The same section does not tell the lender whether the debtor breached the agreement by selling, and it does not tell the buyer whether she holds the machine free of the lien. Other rules answer those questions.
The four questions involve different parties with different stakes, which is why the Code assigns them to different rules. Read as authority for whatever the debtor does, § 9-205 would override the security agreement the lender negotiated. Read as a rule about buyers, it would bless or condemn an unauthorized sale without ever mentioning a buyer. Read as a shield against every challenge, it would let a lien tainted by fraud survive whenever the debtor also happened to be free to sell, and the word solely exists to prevent that result. Each rule works as written when it is kept to its own question.
The subsections that follow take up the four questions in the order listed. They begin with the one the preceding sections already touched: the validity rule says nothing about what the debtor may do as against the lender.