Concept
The Future Advances Rule
Future advances
Securing Future Advances
The Future Advances Rule
Commercial lending rarely ends with one loan. A bank that takes a security interest in a rancher's cattle to secure one loan often lends again months later, and the second loan raises a question the first did not: does the collateral already pledged stand behind the new money, or must the parties sign fresh paper? Article 9 answers in UCC § 9-204(c). A security agreement may provide that the collateral secures future advances or other value, whether or not the advances are made pursuant to commitment.1 A future advance is money lent after the security interest has attached under the original agreement.2 A clause covering that money makes a new security agreement unnecessary when the later loan is made, and it works regardless of whether the secured party is obliged to make the advances.3
The word "may" makes the rule permissive and contractual. The statute lets the parties agree that the security interest will reach later obligations, but it does not extend every security interest to them by default. The term therefore belongs in the authenticated security agreement, the document that creates the interest and takes effect according to its terms between the parties.4 A typical clause says the collateral secures every obligation the debtor owes the secured party, whether it exists now or arises later. The first question on any fact pattern is whether the agreement says anything like that.
Two borrowers show how much turns on the text. The first borrowed $25,000 on a promissory note and signed a security agreement covering all widgets in the debtor's possession. The agreement said the collateral secured the note's debt and any liabilities under the agreement or the note, including renewals or extensions of the note. When the debtor later borrowed another $25,000 on a second note, the widgets did not secure it. The agreement provided only for renewals or extensions of the original debt and said nothing about additional indebtedness.5
Beth's agreement looked forward instead. She borrowed $10,000 from Farmers' Bank and granted the bank a security interest in her cattle, and the agreement allowed the bank to advance more money with the cattle standing as security for the new advance as well as the first loan.6 When the bank lent her another $5,000, the cattle secured the full $15,000, and no second security agreement was needed.7 Both debtors borrowed twice, so the facts do not explain the different results. Renewal and extension language describes the same debt continuing, while a future-advances clause describes new money. The widget agreement looked back at the original obligation, and Beth's looked ahead to additional ones.
Article 9 validates these clauses because they facilitate the financing of inventory and accounts, where the collateral turns over. A secured party may make present and future advances, often called revolving credits, secured by both present and after-acquired inventory or accounts, and the result is what lenders call a floating lien.8
The rule took this permissive shape because Article 9 abandoned an older judicial attitude. Nineteenth-century courts disliked the floating charge. They felt that a commercial borrower should not encumber all assets, present and future, and that a cushion of free assets should remain for other creditors, and a comparable prejudice attached to future advance agreements at common law and under chattel mortgage statutes.10 Article 9 rejected that view because it was not effective under pre-Code law: field warehousing, trust receipts, and factor's liens already let lenders avoid it.11 A rule that careful lenders could defeat with the right device protected no one and trapped only lenders who used plain paper.
One caution remains. Whether the debtor's agreement reaches a later advance is a different question from how that advance ranks against other creditors claiming the same collateral. In priority disputes among Article 9 claimants, courts have divided over how explicit the clause must be. Some hold that a later advance is secured even though the agreement has no express future-advance clause, and others require an express clause before the later advance is secured by the original agreement.12 A lender who wants the coverage should therefore write the clause into the security agreement. The express-language requirement and the ranking rules come up later in this chapter.