Concept
Federal Overlays on Floating Liens
After-acquired property
Federal Overlays on Floating Liens
Section 9-204(a) answers the state-law question: except as otherwise provided in subsection (b), a security agreement "may create or provide for a security interest in after-acquired collateral."1 The section is permissive. It lets the parties write a clause that reaches property the debtor does not yet own, and the earlier parts of this chapter asked what follows from that permission: whether the clause covers a given item, when the interest attaches, how it is perfected, and where it ranks. A valid clause does not end the analysis, because federal law sits above the Code and can restrict a lien that state law has validated.
Two federal regimes deserve a lender's attention here: the Bankruptcy Code, treated in the cutoff sections above, and the federal tax lien. A floating lien invites scrutiny because it grows one item at a time. The agreement may have been signed years ago, but each new acquisition enlarges the lender's collateral on a later date. A federal rule that turns on timing, such as the date a bankruptcy case is filed or the date a tax lien notice is recorded, may therefore treat different items in the same collateral pool differently.
Consider a lender whose security agreement covers all inventory the debtor now owns or later acquires. The lender can show that the clause satisfies § 9-204(a), that the interest attached to the newest shipment, that it is perfected, and that it ranks first under state law. That showing answers every state-law question. It does not answer the federal one, which asks how a regime outside Article 9 views the date that particular shipment entered the lien.
The lesson is a sequence of questions. Ask the state-law questions first, because they decide whether the lien exists and how it ranks. Then ask whether a federal rule gives the date of each acquisition a significance that state law does not. Each federal regime has its own detailed rules, covered in the course units devoted to it. This unit's point is narrower: when a floating lien is valid, attached, perfected, and first in line under the UCC, it is not yet safe from federal law.