Concept
Express Words and Implied Coverage
After-acquired property
Express Words and Implied Coverage
Suppose a security agreement grants the lender a security interest in "all of the debtor's inventory" and says nothing about the future. Months later the debtor buys new inventory. The agreement has no words of time and no "hereafter acquired," so the question is whether the description alone carries the lien forward to goods the debtor did not own at signing.
Section 9-204(a) does not answer it. The statute provides that a security agreement may "create or provide for" a security interest in after-acquired collateral, which authorizes the clause but says nothing about what happens when the parties never wrote one.1 The drafters also declined to supply a rule elsewhere. Comment 3 to § 9-108 observes that much litigation has arisen over whether a description in a security agreement includes after-acquired collateral when the agreement does not explicitly say so. It calls that question one of contract interpretation, not susceptible to a statutory rule, and for that reason the section makes no reference to descriptions of after-acquired collateral.2 A description is sufficient if it reasonably identifies what is described, and the same standard governs the description in a financing statement.3 Whether a bare description such as "inventory" reaches later-acquired inventory is therefore a question of what this agreement, read as a contract, covers.
Courts have not answered that question uniformly, and the type of collateral has mattered. Some courts accept the argument that the description covers later-acquired property when the collateral turns over frequently, as inventory and accounts do. Those same courts reject it for collateral that does not turn over quickly, such as equipment.4 The practical lesson follows directly. A lender that expects its security interest to attach to collateral acquired after signing, but leaves the after-acquired property clause out of the agreement, has invited litigation.5
The next part of the chapter turns from what the parties may agree to the statutory limits on what such a clause can reach.