Concept
When the Interest Attaches
After-acquired property
When the Interest Attaches
Section 9-204(a) allows a security agreement to “create or provide for” a security interest in after-acquired collateral, but signing the agreement gives the lender no lien on goods the debtor does not yet have.1 The clause records a present commitment: whatever property within the description the debtor acquires later will secure the debt. A lien on a particular item exists only once the interest attaches to that item, and attachment occurs only when every requirement has been met as to that collateral.2 One clause therefore produces many attachments, each on the date its own requirements are complete.
The requirements come from § 9-203(b), and a handy shorthand is value, agreement, and rights.3 Value comes from the lender's loan or from its binding commitment to extend credit, which counts whether or not the credit has yet been advanced.4 The requirement stops a debtor from making itself judgment-proof by granting security interests to friends and relatives who never lent a dollar, because each such interest would pull assets away from legitimate creditors.5 Agreement means that the debtor intended to create the interest and that the lender holds an authenticated security agreement or has taken possession or control.6 A lender taking a certificated security, for example, may take delivery under the debtor's agreement by acquiring the certificate or the possessor's acknowledgment that it holds the certificate for the lender.7 Rights requires that the debtor actually have rights in the collateral, or the power to transfer them, and the interest attaches to whatever rights the debtor does have; full title is unnecessary.8 This last requirement is the one the rest of this section keeps returning to, because for later-acquired property it usually arrives last.
Attachment occurs at the moment the last of the three is satisfied. For an item covered only by an after-acquired clause, that moment is usually the one at which the debtor acquires rights in the item. Suppose a debtor grants an interest in “all of its present and after-acquired inventory and present and after-acquired equipment.” The interest attaches immediately to the inventory and equipment the debtor owns today. A new truck bought next year falls within the description, yet nothing attaches until the debtor acquires an interest in that truck.9 Value can arrive last just as easily. A debtor that already owns its equipment signs a security agreement while the bank has made no commitment to lend, and the debtor has granted nothing enforceable. The interest attaches only when the bank agrees, a week later, to make the loan.10 The sound way to analyze any problem is therefore to ask, item by item, which requirement came last. The common mistake is to treat the signing date as the attachment date for everything the clause covers.
Crops, Young, and Pending Purchases
Agricultural lending shows the rights requirement most clearly, because lenders there routinely finance against things that do not yet exist. An after-acquired clause lets the security interest extend to property the debtor acquires after the loan is made, which is what makes such financing workable.11 Attachment, however, must still wait for the debtor's rights. Most courts therefore hold that a debtor has no rights in crops until they are planted or otherwise become growing crops, and none in the young of livestock until they are conceived.12 A security interest needs an object to attach to, and a clause that binds the debtor as a promise cannot supply an object that has not come into being.
The April attachment also needs no fresh advance of money. Value was given when the loan was made, so a clause of this kind may reach crops grown in the future even if the lender advances nothing to finance their planting.13
Purchases pose the same question with a wrinkle: when do the debtor's rights begin in goods it is still in the process of buying? The moment can be elusive. Suppose a secured party takes an interest in a specially equipped truck that the debtor plans to buy from a retailer, who must order it from the manufacturer. The debtor clearly has rights once the truck has been manufactured, shipped to the retailer, and delivered to the debtor, because title passes from retailer to debtor at that point, absent a specific agreement on when title passes.14 Earlier moments are harder to pin down. A lender financing such a purchase can count on delivery as the attachment date.
Goods Held Without Ownership
Holding goods is not the same as having rights in them, and the hard cases arise when a debtor holds goods that belong to someone else. A security interest attaches to whatever rights the debtor actually has, so a debtor with less than full title can still grant a lien on what it does have.15 A mere bailee, by contrast, has no sufficient interest for a security interest to attach. A bailment occurs when a bailor delivers goods to a bailee for a specific objective, with the goods to be returned when that objective is complete.16 A lender claiming through the bailee can reach only what the bailee has, and the bailee holds custody for a limited purpose, not ownership.
Production contracts, consignments, and feedlot grower contracts each leave a debtor in possession of goods that another party claims, and each can be argued to be only a bailment.17 Whether the debtor has rights therefore turns on the facts of the particular arrangement, and no rule sorts these cases automatically in one direction. The owner has its own protection to attend to. Under the revisions to Article 9, a party that delivers farm products to another for raising or fattening should perfect a security interest in them to guard against a challenge from the grower's secured creditors.18
Why the Attachment Date Matters
Other rights are keyed to the attachment date, so it deserves precision. Until the interest attaches, the secured party cannot enforce it against the debtor or a third party. Perfection is impossible before attachment, and sometimes priority is determined by the time of attachment.19 For a floating lien these consequences arise item by item. A lender whose clause covers inventory and accounts cannot foreclose on a new shipment before the debtor has rights in it, and cannot treat that shipment as part of a perfected interest until the interest has attached. The later sections on the bankruptcy cutoff and on perfection and priority build on this same date.