Concept
Attachment and Enforceability
Enforceability (§ 9-203)
Attachment and Enforceability
Until a security interest attaches, it does not exist. Section 9-203(a) defines the term: a security interest attaches to collateral when it becomes enforceable against the debtor with respect to the collateral, unless an agreement expressly postpones the time of attachment.1 Attachment is, in effect, creation. Without it there is no security interest whatever; with it the secured party may enforce the interest and realize on the collateral, at least against the debtor.2 Creation occurs when the debtor agrees to the security, receives value from the secured party, and obtains rights in the collateral.3
Subsection (b) sets the conditions. Except as subsections (c) through (i) provide otherwise, a security interest is enforceable against the debtor and third parties with respect to the collateral "only if" the listed conditions are met.4 Those two words make the conditions cumulative: each is necessary, and none suffices alone. Students compress them into the acronym VAR. Value has been given, the debtor has agreed to grant the interest, and the debtor has rights in the collateral.5 Another formulation counts four requirements. It splits the agreement element in two: the debtor's intent to create a security interest, and the secured party's possession, control, or authenticated security agreement. Value and the debtor's rights in the collateral (or power to transfer rights in it) make up the other two. When all four occur, the interest attaches.6 The sections that follow take the conditions one at a time.
The conditions usually line up. In many, if not most, transactions the secured party gives value and the debtor has rights in the collateral when the security agreement is signed or around that time.7 Nothing requires that coincidence, however, and the interest attaches only when the last condition is met. Suppose a debtor signs a security agreement covering equipment it already owns, but the bank makes no commitment to lend. A week later the bank agrees to make the loan. For that week no value has been given, so the interest has not attached and cannot be enforced even against the debtor. It attaches when the bank commits.8 Value arrived last, and its arrival fixed the date.
The postponement clause in subsection (a) moves the date of attachment and leaves the conditions of subsection (b) in place. Parties may agree to a later time, but an interest that lacks value, agreement, or rights remains unenforceable.
The moment of attachment matters because three consequences follow from it. First, once the interest has attached and the debtor defaults, the secured party may foreclose or otherwise realize on the collateral.9 Second, perfection becomes possible. A financing statement filed prematurely perfects nothing until the interest attaches.10 Third, priority in some contests runs from the time of attachment. Before attachment, by contrast, the secured party can enforce the interest against neither the debtor nor a third party.11
Attachment makes the interest enforceable against third parties as well as the debtor, but the exceptions are important: many third parties defeat an attached but unperfected interest.12 A lien creditor, such as someone who won a judgment and had a sheriff seize the debtor's property, beats an unperfected secured creditor. So does a secured creditor whose interest attached later but who perfected first. The most common lien creditor is the trustee in bankruptcy, whom federal law treats as holding a judicial lien on all of the debtor's assets on the date the petition is filed. Every creditor who has not properly perfected is therefore treated as unsecured in its debtor's bankruptcy.13 A secured party that ignores the default procedures of Part 6 may lose its rights even against the debtor.14 Attachment creates the interest; perfection is the separate step that protects it against these competitors.
The value condition shows why the gate is strict. Secured creditors can always beat unsecured creditors and usually a trustee in bankruptcy. A debtor who could grant valid security interests without receiving value could therefore make itself judgment-proof by granting them to friends and family members who never lent anything. The collateral would then be unavailable to legitimate creditors.15
When a condition fails, the creditor has no enforceable interest even against the debtor. Suppose the debtor inadvertently fails to sign a written security agreement and the secured party does not hold the collateral. Section 9-203 then makes the interest unenforceable against the debtor. The bankruptcy trustee, who takes the debtor's property rights under section 541 and the debtor's defenses against third parties under section 558, may assert the same failure to defeat the creditor.16 Attachment, even when it succeeds, does not make the secured party liable in contract or tort for the debtor's acts or omissions.17
The rest of the chapter follows the statute. It takes up the conditions of subsection (b) in turn: value, the debtor's rights in the collateral, and the security agreement, including the alternatives to a signed record. Because subsection (b) is expressly subject to subsections (c) through (i), the chapter then covers interests that attach without a debtor-made agreement and the rules that extend attachment automatically to proceeds, supporting obligations, and other related property.