Concept
Carve-Outs in the Text
Title to collateral immaterial (§ 9-202)
Carve-Outs in the Text
Section 9-202 states the title-neutral rule with a reservation in its first words: "Except as otherwise provided with respect to consignments or sales of accounts, chattel paper, payment intangibles, or promissory notes," Article 9's provisions on rights and obligations apply whether title to the collateral is in the secured party or the debtor.1 The earlier sections of this chapter set that reservation to one side. It names five kinds of transaction: one involving goods held for sale and four involving rights to payment or the paper that records them. In each, the title-neutral instruction yields wherever separate provisions say otherwise, so a reader who takes § 9-202 as a flat command that title never matters has skipped the first thing the section says.
Article 9 brings these transactions in through its vocabulary. It calls the seller of accounts, chattel paper, payment intangibles, or promissory notes a "debtor" and gives a consignee of goods the same label, while the buyer of those assets and the consignor become the matching "secured parties."2 Revised Article 9 also moved most of the law of consignment sales out of Article 2 and into Article 9.3 None of these transferees is a lender in the ordinary sense; one vocabulary simply lets one set of rules reach every deal. A transferee who could stay outside the Article by calling itself a buyer or an owner would leave the transferor's other creditors facing the unannounced claim that title language produced before the Code. The law kept answering that claim by reimposing a filing requirement for those who needed notice of the debtor's true financial condition.4
The labels carry a limit. A consignor owns the goods it delivered, and a buyer of receivables owns what it bought, so rules written for a lender holding collateral against a debt fit them badly. The Code trims those rules accordingly. Section 9-207, which governs a secured party in possession of collateral, largely drops away for a buyer of these assets and for a consignor.5 Two subsections follow, one on consignments, in which an owner delivers goods to a dealer to sell, and one on outright sales of receivables and notes. Each asks why Article 9 reaches the transaction and what adjustment follows from the transferee's position as an owner.
True Consignments
A consignment earns its own exception in § 9-202 because it looks nothing like a loan: an owner hands goods to a dealer to sell.6 Article 9 reaches the arrangement through labels. The consignor, who owns and delivers the goods, is a secured party, and the consignee, who receives them to sell, is a debtor, though neither has lent or borrowed anything.7 Because revised Article 9 moved most consignment law out of Article 2, a consignment is now analyzed as a secured transaction and no longer as a question of sales law.8
Intent to create a security interest plays no part in the classification. A retailer accepts diamonds on consignment, agreeing to sell them for the owner and to pay the owner the sales proceeds once they are sold. No one expresses any intent to create a security interest, yet the transaction is a secured transaction governed by Article 9, and the consignor is deemed to hold a security interest in the goods.9
The reason runs through this whole chapter. A retailer with a case full of diamonds looks like their owner, and the retailer's other creditors will extend credit on that appearance. If the consignor's ownership could stay hidden, the arrangement would revive the unannounced claim that title language produced before the Code, which the law met each time by reimposing a filing requirement for those who needed to know the debtor's true financial condition.10 Treating the consignor as a secured party makes its claim announce itself like any other claim on a debtor's goods. Calling the arrangement a consignment therefore does not take the owner outside Article 9.
Once the consignor is inside Article 9, the Code must decide which of the Article's lender-oriented rules fit it, and most do not. A consignor parted with its goods so that the dealer could sell them; it holds no collateral against a debt. Section 9-207 shows the adjustment. Its duty of reasonable care does not apply to a consignor unless the consignor is entitled to recourse against the debtor or a secondary obligor on account of uncollected collateral, and the remaining provisions of § 9-207 do not apply to a consignor at all.11 Other law controls those questions.
The same reasoning governs default. Generally, a secured party whose security interest arises from a true consignment is not subject to the duties that Part 6 of Article 9 imposes.12 Those duties protect a debtor whose collateral a creditor sells to collect a debt, and a consignor reclaiming its own goods is not that kind of creditor.
The bank's duties follow its role as a lender, and the consignor's exemptions follow its role as an owner. A reader who casts the consignor as a lender owing the dealer an accounting has applied the wrong half of the Article.
A second adjustment runs the other way and helps the dealer's own lender. A consignee does not own the goods it holds, yet a consignee in an Article 9 consignment may transfer greater rights than it has to its secured party.13 That power cannot come from title, so it comes from a provision written for this situation, § 9-319. How the consignor and the dealer's lender rank against each other is a priority question this section leaves open; Where Title Still Matters, below, returns to consignments.
Sales of Receivables and Notes
Sales of accounts, chattel paper, payment intangibles, and promissory notes form the second group that the opening clause of § 9-202 sets apart from its title-neutral instruction.16 Each of these assets is a right to be paid money, or the paper that records one. An account is what a customer owes a seller for goods bought on open account. A promissory note is a written promise to pay. Chattel paper pairs a payment obligation with a security interest in goods, as when a buyer signs a note and a security agreement covering the widgets purchased.17 A business short of cash can sell such assets to a financer instead of borrowing against them, and Article 9 must decide whether the sale belongs inside it.
Most of these sales do belong inside it, and the usual gateway question about intent does not control. For an ordinary secured transaction the basic test is whether the parties intended a security interest, and without that intention Article 9 normally does not apply. Sales of these four kinds of assets are the exception: Article 9 applies to most of them without regard to intent.18 The Article borrows its labels so that one set of rules can cover transactions that are not loans. The seller is a "debtor," and the buyer is a "secured party."19 Nothing visible changes when a business sells its receivables; the customers, the invoices, and the office stay where they were. If a sale could escape Article 9 by being called a sale, the seller's other creditors would never learn that an asset had left the seller's hands, the same lack of notice the filing requirement exists to prevent.20
The label "secured party" is a convenience. The buyer paid for the asset and owns it, so rules written for a lender holding collateral against a debt fit its position badly, and the Code trims them as it did for the consignor. A buyer of these assets owes the duty of reasonable care in § 9-207 only if it is entitled to recourse against the debtor or a secondary obligor on account of uncollected collateral, and the rest of § 9-207 does not apply to it.21 Part 6 likewise generally imposes no default duties on such a buyer.22 What the buyer owes the seller when collections come in above or below the price turns on one fact: whether the buyer took the credit risk.
Recourse is the seller's obligation to make good on an account the customer fails to pay, and a charge-back right lets the buyer return an uncollected account and recover its price. When the assignee keeps either, the assignor's surplus or deficiency depends on how well the accounts are collected, so the assignee must liquidate them in a commercially reasonable manner.23 The assignor has money riding on the collection: a good one enlarges a surplus it can claim, and a poor one enlarges a deficiency it must cover. An assignee free to dump the accounts cheaply could inflate the deficiency and push the cost onto the assignor and its other creditors. With recourse, the transaction behaves like a loan, and lender-style duties come with it.
Where the transaction is a sale of accounts or chattel paper with no right of recourse or charge-back, the buyer assumes the credit risk completely.24 Unless the security agreement provides otherwise, the seller is then entitled to no surplus and is liable for no deficiency, as § 9-608(b) states.25 The seller has already received the price and parted with the asset, so nothing it owns or owes depends on what the customers eventually pay. The buyer paid for the chance to collect more than it paid and accepted the risk of collecting less. A surplus for the seller would pay it twice, and a deficiency charged to it would hand back a risk the buyer already took. Either result would treat the buyer as a lender, yet the buyer paid for the assets and owns them.
Both scenes fall inside Article 9, and in both the party that parts with the accounts is the debtor. Recourse alone moves the result. Calling the deal a sale does not take it outside Article 9, because the Article reaches the sale whatever the parties intended. Labeling the seller a debtor, in turn, does not entitle it to a surplus or expose it to a deficiency; that depends on whether the buyer kept recourse or a charge-back right.
The buyer's position as an owner has one more consequence. A buyer of accounts, chattel paper, promissory notes, or payment intangibles may in some circumstances obtain greater rights than its seller had, and specific provisions, among them §§ 9-318, 9-330, and 9-331, supply that power.26 This chapter does not unpack them; Where Title Still Matters, below, returns to both groups of carve-outs.