Concept
Rights Between the Parties
Title to collateral immaterial (§ 9-202)
Rights Between the Parties
Section 9-202 provides that Article 9's provisions on rights and obligations apply whether title to the collateral is in the secured party or the debtor, subject to separate treatment for consignments and for sales of accounts, chattel paper, payment intangibles, and promissory notes.1 Earlier sections used that rule to show that a label reserving title does not take a transaction outside Article 9. Here it answers a different question. Once a security interest exists, what do lender and borrower owe each other, and what may each do?
Two layers answer it. The security agreement comes first, because between the parties it is generally effective according to its terms. Article 9 then adds rules of its own, some that yield to the agreement and some that do not. Both layers attach to the security interest. A secured party whose paper recites that it holds title therefore has the same rights as one whose paper is silent about title, and a debtor who keeps title has the same protections as one who does not. The Article can state each rule once instead of writing a version for every possible holder of title.
The debtor's default divides the relationship into two stages. Before default, the secured party may be holding the collateral, as a pledgee does, and the questions concern care, expense, and use. After default, the questions concern enforcement: what the secured party may do to collect, and what limits protect the debtor while it does. In both stages the analysis starts with the agreement and Article 9's additions, and it leaves any title recital out.
Duties Before Default
Section 9-202 does its most routine work between the making of the loan and any default.2 No one has asked a court to enforce anything; the parties are living under their deal. What each owes the other comes from two sources, taken in order: the agreement, which Article 9 generally enforces as written, and the rules Article 9 adds.
The starting point is § 9-201, under which, unless the Code provides otherwise, a security agreement is “effective according to its terms between the parties.”3 Agreements typically fix the debtor's obligation to pay and the terms of payment, who bears the risk of loss or damage to the collateral, the debtor's duties to insure, maintain, and repair it, the debtor's warranty of ownership, and whether the debtor may move it.4 The Code permits broad freedom of contract on such terms, and the drafters' comment states the baseline: except for procedure on default, freedom of contract prevails between the immediate parties.5
That freedom has three limits, and each protects someone in a different position. The Code's obligations of good faith, diligence, reasonableness, and care cannot be disclaimed by agreement, although the parties may set the standards for measuring them if those standards are not manifestly unreasonable.6 A clause disclaiming care would let a secured party in custody neglect the collateral without consequence, while a negotiated standard keeps the obligation alive. Procedure on default is the second exception: the parties cannot contract away the protections Part 6 gives the debtor, which the next subsection collects.7 The third limit protects outsiders, because a term waiving Article 9's priority rules does not bind affected third persons who have not assented.8 A contract reaches only those who agreed to it.
Beyond what the parties write, Article 9 supplies rules of its own, and they attach to the security interest whichever party holds title.13 The rules center on a secured party with possession or control of the collateral before default. That party is a kind of bailee, and the holder of a traditional pledge is the model.14 A bailee holds another's property for a limited purpose, and the label fits whether the paper puts title on one side of the deal or the other.
Section 9-207 gives such a secured party a short set of duties and permissions:
- The secured party must use reasonable care in the custody and preservation of the collateral in its possession.15
- It may charge reasonable expenses of custody and preservation to the debtor and secure them with the collateral.16
- It must keep the collateral identifiable, although fungible collateral may be commingled.17
- It may use or operate the collateral to preserve it or its value; other uses are governed by § 9-207(b)(4)(B) and (C) and Comment 4.18
- It may hold proceeds other than money or funds as additional security, and it must apply money or funds received from the collateral to reduce the secured obligation unless it remits them to the debtor.19
Each rule answers a distinct problem. The debtor stands to receive the collateral back on payment, so the debtor bears the reasonable cost of keeping it, and the collateral secures that cost so the secured party need not advance it unprotected. Identification matters because a secured party that mixed the debtor's goods with its own could not return them; fungible collateral is the exception because any unit is as good as another. The proceeds rules keep the secured party from treating the collateral's yield as its own, since money that must reduce the debt keeps the balance accurate.20
The duties above belong to a secured party that holds collateral as security for a debt. Article 9 also gives the label secured party to a buyer of accounts, chattel paper, payment intangibles, or promissory notes and to a consignor, and § 9-207(d) removes most of the section from them. The duty of reasonable care applies to such a party only if it is entitled to recourse against the debtor or a secondary obligor on account of uncollected collateral. The remaining provisions of § 9-207 do not apply, and other law controls those matters.21 The line follows what the duties protect. A buyer of accounts with no recourse against the seller has taken the collection risk, so the seller has no stake in how the buyer handles the records. A buyer entitled to recourse leaves the seller bearing part of any shortfall, and for that reason the duty of care reaches it.
A stem that tells you who holds title, whether through a recital in the pledge papers or through the name on the certificates, supplies a fact that decides none of these questions. The decisive fact is whether the transaction is a secured loan in which the secured party holds the collateral or one of the transactions Article 9 treats separately. Carve-Outs in the Text, below, takes up those transactions.
Remedies After Default
The title-neutral rule governs the relationship from the day of the loan through the day the debtor stops performing, and the drafters' comment extends it to remedies: rights, obligations, and remedies under the Article do not depend on the location of title.25 After default, the secured party's rights are found in Part 6 of Article 9, §§ 9-601 through 9-628, and in the security agreement, and those rights are what distinguish the secured lender from the unsecured one.26 Because the remedies belong to the holder of a security interest, a secured party needs no ownership to use them. A creditor whose paper recites title has the same remedies as one whose paper leaves title with the debtor, and the debtor has the same protections against either. This subsection maps that territory; the mechanics of Part 6 belong to later chapters.
Remedies cannot follow title, and the reason shows in what would happen if they did. A creditor that held title could treat default as the end of the debtor's interest and keep a machine worth far more than the unpaid balance. Part 6 blocks that result by requiring an accounting for, and payment of, surplus proceeds under §§ 9-608(a) and 9-615(d), and a security agreement cannot waive that right before default.27 If title controlled, a creditor could claim an owner's rights when the goods were worth more than the debt and a lender's rights when they were worth less. The Article removes that choice by making the remedy depend on the security interest alone.
Remedies presuppose a default, and the security agreement sets the events that count.28 Many agreements also contain an acceleration clause, which makes the unpaid balance due on an event of default, and some permit acceleration at will or whenever the secured party deems itself insecure.29 Part 6 then regulates what the secured party may do once the trigger has been pulled.
A secured party may not take default action without an event of default set forth in the security agreement, and doing so may subject it to liability to the debtor.30 In the standard illustration, a debtor gave a creditor a security interest in inventory to secure monthly payments, made a payment, and died immediately afterward. No payment was in arrears, and the agreement did not make the debtor's death an event of default. The creditor's immediate repossession was improper, and the creditor could be held liable to the debtor's executor, administrator, or heirs for the resulting losses.31 The rule protects the agreement's own definition of default. If a secured party could act on its own belief that the debtor's situation had changed, that definition would mean nothing. The same repossession after a missed installment that the agreement treats as a default would fall within Part 6, subject to its limits, and in neither case does the secured party's title enter the analysis.
Even after a default, a secured party cannot enforce if it has waived the right to do so. Waiver occurs when the secured party knowingly relinquishes its right to enforce the security interest.32 According to some case law, a debtor's repeated failure to pay on time, contrary to the agreement, can support a finding of waiver when the secured party has knowingly gone along with the pattern.33 A secured party that tolerates a pattern tells the debtor, by its conduct, that the pattern is acceptable.
Once an unwaived event of default exists, the secured party chooses among several routes and may combine them:34
- The secured party may reduce its claim to judgment, foreclose or otherwise enforce the security interest by any available judicial procedure, or, if the collateral is documents, proceed as to the documents or as to the goods they cover.35
- It may repossess the collateral under § 9-609 and collect directly from account debtors and obligors on instruments, taking control of proceeds to which it is entitled, under §§ 9-607 and 9-608.36
- It may dispose of the collateral, by sale or lease, under § 9-610(a); disposition is required in certain consumer-goods situations and when the debtor does not consent to, or objects to, a proposal to accept the collateral in satisfaction of the obligation.37
- It may propose to take the collateral in satisfaction of the debt (strict foreclosure), within the limits of §§ 9-620 through 9-622 and 9-624.38
Section 9-601 makes these rights cumulative: electing one course does not bar the secured party from another.39 A secured party may obtain a judgment for the full debt and then collect through execution on the debtor's other property or by garnishment, and doing so does not prevent it from realizing on the collateral under Part 6.40 The structure fits a practical problem. A secured creditor has two sources of repayment, the debtor's promise and the collateral, and at default it often cannot tell which will yield full payment. Where one security agreement covers both real and personal property, § 9-604 lets the secured party proceed under Article 9 for the personal property or exclusively under real estate law for both.41 No route requires the secured party to hold title.42
The secured party's freedom to choose among these routes operates inside a set of debtor protections that the security agreement cannot remove. Section 9-602 lists rights of the debtor that cannot be waived or varied by agreement, except as § 9-624 permits, and they include:43
- the duty to take possession without breach of the peace when the secured party repossesses without judicial process (§ 9-609);44
- the rules for disposing of collateral (§§ 9-610(b), 9-611, 9-613, and 9-614);45
- the accounting for, and payment of, surplus proceeds (§§ 9-608(a) and 9-615(d));46
- the rules on acceptance of collateral in satisfaction of the obligation (§§ 9-620, 9-621, and 9-622);47
- the secured party's liability for failing to comply with Article 9 (§§ 9-625 and 9-626).48
Timing is the point of the rule. The Code permits a few waivers, but only in an agreement entered into and authenticated after default: the right to notification of a disposition under § 9-611, the right to require disposition under § 9-620(e), and, except in consumer transactions, the right to redeem under § 9-623.49 By then the debtor knows which default has occurred and what it is surrendering.
A secured party that holds the collateral after default keeps the custody rules of § 9-207, but the relationship has changed, so agreements permitted under that section cannot waive or modify certain debtor rights following default.50 And because these protections attach to the security interest, a recital that title rests with the secured party does not reduce them. A lender that holds title on paper must still repossess without breaching the peace, dispose of the collateral under the Article's rules, and account for any surplus, exactly as a lender that never mentioned title must.51
Step two is where fact patterns usually plant their difficulty. A stem that describes a repossession will often leave out whether the agreement made the triggering event a default or whether the secured party had accepted late payments before. Step five then removes the title language the stem may emphasize.