Concept
Labels That Reserve Title
Title to collateral immaterial (§ 9-202)
Labels That Reserve Title
A seller delivers a delivery truck to a buyer on credit. The sales contract says, in capital letters, that "title remains in Seller until the price is paid in full." The buyer takes the keys and drives the truck every day. Assume the arrangement exists to secure the buyer's obligation to pay the price. Can the title sentence take the seller outside Article 9?
Section 9-202 says it cannot. Except as otherwise provided for consignments and for sales of accounts, chattel paper, payment intangibles, and promissory notes, Article 9's provisions on rights and obligations apply whether title to the collateral is in the secured party or the debtor.1 The truck clause is a statement about ownership. Section 9-202 makes ownership irrelevant to the rights and obligations Article 9 governs.
The rule is neutral in both directions. If the title sentence says the seller owns the truck, the same provisions govern. If it says the buyer owns the truck, the same provisions govern. Because the result is identical either way, no drafting choice about who holds title can move the parties from one set of rules to another. A label can describe the deal, but the parties cannot use it to choose which Article 9 rights and obligations apply.
The section also has limits. It leaves room for different treatment of consignments and of sales of accounts, chattel paper, payment intangibles, and promissory notes. Later sections of this chapter take up those carve-outs. Outside them, the practical question about any title-retention clause is what the arrangement does for the parties' obligations, and the clause's statement of who owns the goods does not answer it.