Concept
Priority in Proceeds
Does the consignment have purchase-money priority?
Priority in Proceeds
Winning the contest over the goods does not end a consignor's dispute with the merchant's inventory lender, because the goods get sold and the sale produces something new. Section 9-324(b) anticipates that second contest in its opening clause. The clause gives a perfected purchase-money security interest in inventory priority over a conflicting security interest in the same inventory. It then extends that priority to specific proceeds, and it does so only on the conditions the subsection lists after its "if:" and subject to subsection (c) and, except as subsection (g) provides, to subsection (g). The proceeds it names are:
- chattel paper or an instrument that constitutes proceeds of the inventory, and proceeds of that chattel paper, "if so provided in Section 9-330";
- identifiable cash proceeds of the inventory, but only "to the extent" they are received on or before delivery of the inventory to a buyer, and except as otherwise provided in § 9-327.1
A hypothetical shows how the list works. Alpine ships ski jackets on consignment to Ridge Outfitters, and Alpine meets the conditions for purchase-money priority in the jackets. First Bank holds a security interest in all of Ridge's inventory under a revolving loan. Ridge sells three jackets. One customer pays cash at the register as the jacket is handed over. A second buys on an installment plan, and the sale leaves Ridge holding chattel paper. A third buys on open credit and owes Ridge a right to payment. Alpine's position differs for each.
The register cash is the clearest case. It is a cash proceed, and it arrived on or before delivery to the buyer, so the cash clause covers it, provided the cash is identifiable and § 9-327 does not displace the result. Cash that reached Ridge after delivery falls outside the timing limit the clause itself sets.
The installment paper is covered only to the extent § 9-330 says so, because the clause defers to that section for chattel paper and instruments. Alpine cannot treat the paper as automatically its own just because the jacket was.
The open-credit sale is the weakest. The clause names chattel paper, instruments, proceeds of chattel paper, and identifiable cash, and it does not mention a right to payment of this kind. Alpine therefore cannot point to § 9-324(b) for it.
Subsection (a) shows how deliberate that itemizing is. A perfected purchase-money security interest in goods other than inventory or livestock also has priority in "its identifiable proceeds," with no list of qualifying forms. The exceptions are § 9-327 and subsection (g), and the interest must be perfected when the debtor receives possession or within 20 days afterward.2 An answer that borrows that general proceeds rule for inventory claims more than the text of subsection (b) gives. For each form of proceeds, the question is whether subsection (b) names it and, if the proceeds are cash, whether they arrived on or before delivery.