Concept
Competing Purchase-Money Interests
Does the consignment have purchase-money priority?
Competing Purchase-Money Interests
Two purchase-money claimants can end up contesting the same goods: a seller and the bank that financed part of the price, or two lenders that each paid part of it. UCC § 9-324(g) governs that contest. When more than one security interest qualifies for priority in the same collateral under subsection (a), (b), (d), or (f), subsection (g) ranks them.1
The grants in subsections (a) and (b) show why the ranking is needed. Each lifts a purchase-money interest above a conflicting security interest in the same collateral, and each yields to subsection (g).2 Once two purchase-money claimants stand over the same goods, each is a conflicting security interest from the other's side, so both grants favor both claimants and neither can break the tie. Subsection (g) breaks it.
Ranking starts only after each claimant qualifies. A claimant qualifies by meeting the conditions of the subsection that governs its own collateral. For inventory, those conditions are perfection by the time the debtor receives the goods and notice to the other secured parties of record, the requirements the earlier sections applied to the consignor.3 A claimant that misses one has no purchase-money priority to rank, so it never enters the subsection (g) contest. Its position then depends on the ordinary rules and on the grant of any rival that does qualify, which lifts that rival above a conflicting security interest in the same inventory.4
Three questions, asked in order, resolve the contest. Does each claimant qualify? Does one secure the price while another secures an enabling loan? If neither answer settles the ranking, whose filing or perfection came first? The two subsections below take up the second and third questions.
Price Obligation Over Enabling Loan
When two purchase-money interests both qualify, § 9-324(g)(1) ranks first the one that secures the price. A security interest securing an obligation incurred as all or part of the price of the collateral has priority over a security interest securing an obligation incurred for value given to enable the debtor to acquire rights in or the use of the collateral.5 The usual contest pits a seller against a third-party lender.6 The seller delivered the goods and kept an interest for the unpaid price, and the lender advanced money the debtor used to buy goods. If both qualify, the seller ranks first, and the order of filing never enters the comparison.
Both claimants hold purchase-money interests, so that label cannot separate them. A security interest in goods is purchase-money when it secures value given to enable the debtor to acquire rights in the goods, and the value must in fact serve that purpose.7 A seller qualifies because credit for the price lets the buyer take the goods, and a lender qualifies when its loan pays for them.8 Subsection (g)(1) therefore draws its line inside the category, between the claimant whose obligation is the price and the claimant whose obligation is a loan that helped the debtor pay it.
The order tracks where each claim comes from. The seller's claim arises from the goods: it parted with them and kept an interest for what the buyer still owes. The lender's claim exists because its money let the debtor buy from someone else. The seller is thus the more direct source of the debtor's rights in the inventory.
The preference helps only a claimant that has qualified. In one secondary-source problem, Lumber, Inc. claimed a purchase-money interest in inventory but failed to perfect on time and failed to give notice. A purchase-money interest in inventory prevails only if it is perfected before the debtor obtains possession and notice has gone to the other secured parties of record. Lumber, Inc. therefore was not entitled to the preference, and its interest was treated as a non-PMSI.9 The 20 days that subsection (a) allows for goods other than inventory or livestock do not help an inventory claimant.10 A claimant in Lumber's position has no purchase-money priority to rank, so no label on its obligation can rescue it in a contest under (g).
A consignor supplies goods rather than money, so it stands close to the seller. The statute deems a consignor's security interest in consigned goods a purchase-money security interest in inventory, which brings the consignor into the purchase-money framework.11 Entry is only the first step. The consignor must still satisfy the conditions of § 9-324(b) before its interest is one of the qualifying interests that subsection (g) ranks.12 Subsection (g)(1) never mentions consignors, so an answer about a consignor facing an enabling lender should state the seller-over-lender rule, explain that the consignor supplies goods as a seller does, and apply the words of (g)(1) to the facts rather than assert a settled outcome.
The preference also follows the goods into proceeds. Where two or more secured parties qualify for purchase-money priority in goods, software, or proceeds, a seller's perfected purchase-money interest in goods or software, and in the proceeds in which it has priority, outranks a non-seller's perfected purchase-money interest in the same proceeds. A later section develops the point.13
Ties Resolved by Filing Order
Subsection (g)(2) governs every contest that (g)(1) leaves open: in all other cases, § 9-322(a) applies to the qualifying security interests.15 The frame is the one set by the opening clause of subsection (g), which applies whenever more than one security interest qualifies for priority in the same collateral under subsection (a), (b), (d), or (f).16 The standard example is two lenders whose money paid for the same goods. Neither obligation is the price, so (g)(1) has nothing to prefer, and apart from the seller's preference the first-to-file-or-perfect rule governs.17
Qualifying and ranking answer different questions, and mixing them up is the commonest error in this area. Qualifying comes first. Each claimant must satisfy the conditions of the subsection that governs its collateral, which for inventory include perfection by the time the debtor receives the goods and notice to the other secured parties of record.18 An interest that misses one never reaches subsection (g). Ranking comes second, and (g)(2) assigns it to § 9-322(a). Priority dates from the earlier of filing or perfection, the basic rule in competition between secured creditors.19 The notification date, which mattered at the first stage, sets no rank at the second. Notice decides whether an interest receives purchase-money treatment, and once the interest has it, the notice date does no further work.
Filing may take place even before the security interest attaches, and so before it is perfected, which means a lender's ranking date can precede the day its interest attaches. The rule also recognizes that perfection may take place in one way and then in another, as where a secured party in possession releases the collateral to the debtor, has temporary perfection, and then files.20
Two enabling lenders stand alike: each supplied money for the same goods, and neither supplied the goods themselves. With no purchase-money reason to prefer one, the Code turns to the one date each lender can check in advance. A filing date appears in the public record, while a notification reaches only the secured party it is sent to.
Add a distributor that sold part of the shipment on credit and kept a qualifying interest for the unpaid balance. Its interest secures the price, so (g)(1) places it ahead of either lender whichever filed first, and filing order is never consulted between them.21 With a seller and two lenders all qualifying, the seller outranks each lender under (g)(1), and (g)(2) orders the two lenders against each other. A consignor faces the same gate: its deemed purchase-money interest in inventory is ranked only if it first satisfies § 9-324(b), and if (g)(1) does not settle its contest, (g)(2) does.22
Step three alone is subsection (g)(2). Steps one and two are the gate and the preference that come before it.