Concept
Choosing the Inventory Rule
Does the consignment have purchase-money priority?
Consignment Purchase-Money Priority
Choosing the Inventory Rule
A consignor who ships goods to a merchant for resale usually arrives second. The merchant's bank has already filed a financing statement covering all of the merchant's present and after-acquired inventory, and the consigned goods fall within that description once they reach the shop floor. Under the ordinary rule, the bank wins: among perfected interests, priority dates from the earlier of filing or perfection, and the creditor who filed first prevails.1 UCC § 9-324(b) is the exception that lets a latecomer jump ahead. It gives a perfected purchase-money security interest in inventory priority over a conflicting security interest in the same inventory, provided the subsection's conditions are met.2 The following sections work through those conditions. This section settles a threshold question: which priority rule applies to a consignor at all?
Two classifications supply the answer. A consignment within Article 9 counts as a security interest, so the consignor must perfect it like any other secured party.3 And § 9-103(d) provides that the security interest of a consignor in consigned goods is a purchase-money security interest in inventory; for that reason § 9-324 also decides the consignor's priority against a security interest the consignee has created in the goods.4 Purchase-money financing need not come from the seller alone. In one commentary illustration, a lender pays the seller the price of widgets the debtor bought, and the debtor has granted the lender a security interest in those widgets to cover that loan.5 For the consignor, the word that selects the rule is inventory: it routes the consignor to subsection (b) and away from the subsection for other goods.
The two rules look alike, since each rewards the party that financed the specific goods, but their entry requirements differ sharply. Subsection (a) covers goods other than inventory or livestock. It gives a perfected purchase-money security interest priority over a conflicting interest in the same goods if the purchase-money interest is perfected when the debtor receives possession or within 20 days afterward.6 That grace period lets a purchase-money holder deliver first and file later.7
Subsection (b) offers no such leeway. For inventory, the purchase-money interest must be perfected at the time the debtor receives possession, and the holder of the earlier security interest must be notified; there is no 20-day rule for inventory financing.8 The notification must be signed (the statute's older term was authenticated), must say that the sender has or expects to acquire a purchase-money security interest in the debtor's inventory, and must describe the inventory.9 A consignor meets both conditions by filing before the consignee receives possession and giving written notification to any other secured party who has filed.10
Commentary says the notice requirement rests on sensible reasons,11 and the usual one is practical, a difference in how the two kinds of collateral get financed. Equipment tends to be financed by a loan against a single item that the debtor pays down, so a 20-day window to file costs an earlier lender little. Inventory tends to be financed through a revolving line, with periodic advances as new goods arrive and with the goods on the floor treated as the lender's collateral. That lender needs to learn, before the new goods arrive, that someone else claims priority in them; otherwise it may keep advancing against goods it can never reach. Perfection at delivery and prior notice supply that warning.
Consider a consignor who delivers pottery to a gallery on Monday and files a financing statement on Friday, while Big Bank holds an earlier-filed lien on all of the gallery's inventory. The consignor's interest is a purchase-money interest in inventory, so subsection (b) governs, and the consignor was not perfected when the gallery received the pottery. The special priority is lost, however promptly the consignor filed afterward and however clear any notice it sent. The consignor falls back to the basic rule, priority from the earlier of filing or perfection, and the bank, which filed first, wins.12 Had the owner filed before delivery and notified the bank, the result would have been reversed.
Change the goods, and the result changes too. On March 1, a debtor bought a new computer for use in its business, giving the seller a security interest to secure the price in installments. The computer was delivered March 15, and the seller perfected by filing on April 1.13 Suppose a lender had earlier filed against all of the debtor's equipment. A computer used in the business is equipment, and April 1 falls seventeen days after delivery, inside the 20-day window of subsection (a). The seller wins without having notified the lender.14 Run the same seventeen days on inventory and the seller loses. An exam taker who sees the words purchase-money and reaches for the 20-day window has answered an equipment question; the consignor's interest is a purchase-money interest in inventory, and inventory has no window.