Concept
Inventory Cross-Collateral Rule
Is the consignor's interest a purchase-money security interest?
Inventory Cross-Collateral Rule
A floor-plan lender rarely wants each unit of inventory to secure only its own price. It wants every financed unit to secure the whole line, so the financing agreement carries a cross-collateral clause: each unit secures its own price and the price of every other unit the lender finances. That clause strains the general definition of a purchase-money security interest, which measures status one unit at a time. A unit's own price is purchase-money debt for that unit. The prices of the other units are debt for other goods, now attached to the same lien.
Section 9-103(b)(2) repairs the strain for inventory. When a security interest is in inventory that is or was purchase-money collateral, it is also a purchase-money security interest to the extent that it secures a purchase-money obligation incurred with respect to other inventory in which the secured party holds or held a purchase-money security interest.1 The provision imposes two conditions. The goods encumbered must be inventory that is or was purchase-money collateral. The debt secured must be a purchase-money obligation for other inventory in which the lender holds or held a purchase-money interest. The past-tense words was and held matter, because they keep the extension working after one unit's own financing has run its course.
The argument fails. The first tractor is inventory that was purchase-money collateral, and the debt it still secures is a purchase-money obligation incurred with respect to other inventory, the other nine tractors, in which the bank holds a purchase-money security interest. To that extent, the bank's interest in the first tractor remains purchase-money.2 First-in, first-out is a bookkeeping convention, and it says nothing about whether the bank's credit brought the remaining tractors to the dealer.
Exam stems often announce the accounting entry in a sentence of its own, which invites the conclusion that the first unit is paid off and its lien now ordinary. The text of the provision forecloses that conclusion.
The rule also removes a tracing contest. Inventory is financed in a revolving pattern: units are bought, sold, and replaced, and the lender cross-secures the whole line. Without the extension, every sale and payment would invite the argument that the oldest unit's lien had shed its purchase-money character, and the lender would have to prove which dollars paid for which unit. Under § 9-103(b)(2), the question is whether the cross-secured debt is itself a purchase-money obligation for other inventory, so the lender's status does not turn on how the accounting happens to fall.
What keeps the extension from sweeping in every debt a dealer owes the lender? The second condition does that work, because the cross-secured debt must itself be a purchase-money obligation for other inventory. Status is therefore measured by portion, debt by debt.
The extension reaches only cross-secured debt that is itself purchase-money for other inventory.3
Equipment receives no comparable extension, because the text of the provision speaks only of inventory.4 The inventory rule answers the churn of a revolving line, and a company that buys equipment once and keeps it presents no such churn.
The bank's interest in the first two tractors is not purchase-money to the extent it secures the price of the other eight. The price of those two tractors has been paid, so the general definition no longer supports purchase-money status, and the extension that would rescue it covers inventory only. On the other eight tractors, the lien is purchase-money to the extent it secures a tractor's own price and ordinary to the extent it secures the prices of the others. The later sections on dual status and the allocation of payments explain how the two pieces are separated.
Losing purchase-money status does not mean losing the lien. The slice securing the other tractors' prices is an ordinary security interest. Section 9-317 subordinates an unperfected security interest to a lien creditor that arrives before perfection and, by negative implication, lets a perfected interest prevail, so a bank that perfected keeps that protection for the ordinary slice.5 What the ordinary slice lacks is the added advantage that purchase-money status brings.