Concept
Consignments Under Article 9
Is the consignor's interest a purchase-money security interest?
Consignments Under Article 9
A consignor's security interest in consigned goods is deemed a purchase-money security interest in inventory, but only a transaction that counts as a consignment under Article 9 can use that rule.1 The definition sits in § 9-102(a)(20) and works as a gate in front of the deeming rule.2 This section teaches only enough of the definition to show how the gate operates.
In a typical consignment, an owner leaves goods with a merchant to sell to third parties. If the goods sell, the merchant keeps a percentage of the price, say 20 percent, and remits the rest. If they do not sell, the consignor takes them back.3 The arrangement resembles a loan against inventory, because the consignor's capital lets the merchant display and sell goods it could not otherwise stock. It differs from a secured loan in one respect: the risk of no sale falls on the consignor, not on the merchant.4
Article 9 reaches these arrangements because a supplier could use them to avoid it. A retailer and its supplier may agree that title to the new inventory stays in the supplier while the retailer sells as the supplier's agent.5 That structure could circumvent Article 9, and it raises the same problems a secured transaction raises, so § 9-109(a)(4) brings consignment transactions within Article 9.6 The 1999 revision extended Article 9 to many true consignments for a practical reason: it is very difficult to tell a true consignment from a disguised security interest.7 The coverage is only as broad as the definition, however, and the definition excludes some transactions that a lay person would call consignments.8
Classification as a consignment fixes the parties' roles. The consignor becomes the secured party, the consignee the debtor, and the consigned goods the collateral.9 The consignor must therefore perfect its interest under Article 9 to protect itself against the consignee's bankruptcy trustee and against later perfected secured creditors.10 A consignor unsure how a court will classify the deal may file a financing statement that uses the terms consignor and consignee. The filing is not itself a factor in deciding whether the arrangement is intended as security, and if the deal proves to be a secured transaction for other reasons, the filing perfects the interest.11
An exam stem that says goods were delivered on consignment has not yet said whether the deeming rule is available, because the label and the Article 9 definition can come apart in two directions. Start with a transaction that passes the gate. A wholesaler delivers $50,000 of diamonds to a jeweler that sells under its own store name and is not an auctioneer or a dealer generally known to creditors as selling others' goods. The jeweler may sell the stones and remit the price less its percentage, or return unsold stones, and it owes nothing for stones it returns. This is a conventional commercial consignment, so the wholesaler holds a security interest in the diamonds with the jeweler as debtor.12
A transaction can also look like a consignment and fall outside Article 9 altogether. A homeowner who leaves used household goods at a second-hand store to be sold on commission, with unsold goods coming back, has made a consignment in ordinary speech. The goods were consumer goods immediately before delivery, so the arrangement falls outside the definition. It operates as a bailment, and law other than Article 9 governs it.13 No security interest exists, so no purchase-money question arises. Consignments of items worth less than $1,000, consignments to a person generally known by its creditors to be substantially engaged in selling the goods of others, and consignments to a consignee who acts in the consignor's name are also outside Article 9. Section 2-326(1) governs them.14
The third case reverses the label. A supplier delivers goods to a dealer under paperwork headed consignment, but the dealer must pay a fixed price whether or not the goods sell. The dealer's duty to pay is a debt that the goods secure, so the transaction creates a security interest that secures an obligation and falls outside the definition of consignment on that ground. It remains a security interest within Article 9, and the supplier must still perfect it.15 The practical differences are small, mainly that on default this supplier must comply with Part 6 of Article 9. For purchase-money status, though, the difference is real. The deeming rule speaks of the consignor's interest in a consignment, and this transaction is not a consignment as Article 9 defines the term.16 The supplier must therefore establish purchase-money status under the general definitions in § 9-103(a) and (b), the route described earlier in this chapter.
The first two questions screen out different transactions and lead to different places. A transaction that fails the second question leaves Article 9. A transaction that fails the first stays inside Article 9 and must prove purchase-money status through the general definitions. Only a transaction that clears both reaches the deeming rule taught next.