Concept
Purchase-Money Building Blocks
Is the consignor's interest a purchase-money security interest?
Purchase-Money Building Blocks
Article 9 mostly ignores the form a secured transaction takes. It makes exceptions for a secured party in possession of the collateral (a pledge), a secured party with control, and a transaction whose form produces a purchase-money security interest.1 Section 9-103 defines that last exception through three terms, each built on the one before. The purchase-money obligation is an obligation incurred as all or part of the price of the collateral, or for value given to enable the debtor to acquire rights in or the use of the collateral, if the value is in fact so used.2 Purchase-money collateral is goods or software that secures a purchase-money obligation incurred with respect to that collateral.3 And a security interest in goods is a purchase-money security interest to the extent that the goods are purchase-money collateral with respect to that security interest.4
The labels matter because a creditor that cannot claim them is left with the ordinary priority rules. Section 9-317, for instance, subordinates an unperfected secured creditor to a lien creditor and, by negative implication, lets a perfected one prevail.5 A bank that takes a security interest in a debtor's equipment but neither files a financing statement nor takes possession is exposed to an unsecured creditor who levies on the equipment and procures a judicial lien.6
Because each definition borrows the one before it, read every problem from the first link forward. Goods become purchase-money collateral only through the debt they secure, so the collateral definition has nothing to work on until the obligation qualifies. The security-interest rule then takes its status from the collateral, and its words “to the extent” make that status a matter of measurement, goods by goods and portion by portion, instead of a label for a whole transaction. A debt that fails the first link, because the value was not in fact used to acquire the goods, leaves the goods without collateral status and the security interest without purchase-money status, however the loan documents describe the deal.
The questions follow the same order: what was the debt incurred for, which goods does it secure, and how much of the security interest do those goods support? The first subsection takes up the debt.
Purchase-Money Obligation
Section 9-103(a)(2) recognizes two kinds of purchase-money creditor. One is a seller who extends credit for the price of the collateral. The other is a lender whose money lets the debtor acquire the collateral from someone else.7 The definition covers both: an obligation incurred as all or part of the price of the collateral, or for value given to enable the debtor to acquire rights in or the use of the collateral, if the value is in fact so used.8 That last condition attaches to the enabling-value route, and it makes a lender's status depend on what the debtor actually did with the money.
A seller's claim is the simpler one, because the debt the seller holds is the price itself. If a seller keeps an interest in the goods sold to secure payment of some or all of the price, the seller has a purchase-money security interest.9 A buyer who pays part of the price down and promises installments for the rest, while the seller keeps a security interest in the goods, has given the seller exactly that. Nothing needs to be traced, because the unpaid balance is what the collateral secures.
A lender can hold a purchase-money obligation without ever owning the goods. Suppose a buyer needs $1,200 for widgets, borrows $1,100 from a lender, and adds $100 of her own money to pay the seller. If the lender takes the widgets as collateral, its advance was value given to enable the buyer to acquire them and was in fact so used. Whether the lender paid the seller directly or handed the money to the buyer to pass along matters less than whether the money went into the purchase.10 The lender's position differs from the seller's in one respect. The seller's link to the goods is the sale itself, while the lender's link runs through what the debtor did with the advance, so the lender must show that its money was in fact used to acquire an interest in the collateral.11
Had the bank's $40,000 gone to the supplier, directly or through the retailer, to pay for the shipment, the same dollars would have qualified, because they would then have enabled the purchase and been used for it. The difference lies in timing and use, not in who the lender is.
The idea beneath these results is a close tie between the credit and the acquisition. As re Mancini puts it, the concept “requires a close nexus between the acquisition of collateral and the secured obligation.” A security interest therefore does not qualify when the debtor acquires property on unsecured credit and later creates the security interest to secure the purchase price.12 The same reasoning reaches a lender who advances money against goods the debtor already owns. That loan enabled the debtor to acquire nothing, so it produces no purchase-money obligation.13
The price of the collateral, and the value given to enable its acquisition, include more than the sticker amount. According to the official comment, they cover expenses incurred in connection with acquiring rights in the collateral, sales taxes, duties, finance charges, interest, freight charges, costs of storage in transit, demurrage (charges for holding freight equipment past the time allowed), administrative charges, expenses of collection and enforcement, attorney's fees, and other similar obligations.14 When those costs are part of the acquisition, the full obligation can be purchase-money.
Negative equity tests the limits of that breadth. It arises when a buyer trades in a vehicle worth less than the debt it secures and the new lender rolls the shortfall into the loan secured by the new vehicle. Whether the rolled-in amount counts as price, or as value given to enable the acquisition, is contested. The comment's list of incidental costs does not mention negative equity, so the list does not settle the question. Courts that include negative equity in the purchase-money amount of a new vehicle purchase often rely, at least as a secondary justification, on the canon that related statutory provisions should be read together (in pari materia).15 The opposing argument starts from the comment's nexus language: the rolled-in shortfall is leftover debt on the old vehicle, and securing it with the new one looks more like securing earlier credit after the fact than financing the new vehicle's price. On an exam, name the split, apply the nexus language to the rolled-in amount, and commit to a reasoned result without treating either view as settled.
Purchase-Money Collateral
Section 9-103(a)(1) supplies the second link: purchase-money collateral is goods or software that secures a purchase-money obligation incurred with respect to that collateral.17 The definition borrows the obligation from the last subsection and adds two conditions of its own. The first limits the kind of property. The second ties the debt to the particular property, so that status attaches asset by asset rather than to everything a loan happens to cover.
The first condition is that the collateral be goods or software. Accounts and other intangibles are neither, so they cannot be purchase-money collateral, however the loan was used. A lender that wants purchase-money status must take its security in goods or software.
A lender that finances a $90,000 press and takes a security interest in the press itself meets the definition fully. The press is goods, and the debt was incurred with respect to the press. The two lenders differ in one respect, the property each chose as security, which shows that the kind of collateral can defeat purchase-money status even when the credit really did fund an acquisition.
The second condition is that the obligation have been incurred with respect to that collateral. The obligation discussion applied the comment's close nexus between the acquisition of the collateral and the secured obligation to the debt, by asking whether the value was used to acquire the goods.18 Here the same idea applies to the asset. A particular item is purchase-money collateral only if the debt it secures was incurred to acquire that item, so an item the loan did nothing to help the debtor acquire does not qualify, whatever else the loan documents say about it.
The lathe fails because the loan did not bring it to the debtor. Whether its presence affects the lender's interest in the press is a question for the later sections on keeping purchase-money status. For now, the point is that the definition sorts a debtor's assets one at a time. That sorting feeds the next link, because a security interest in goods is purchase-money only to the extent that the goods are purchase-money collateral for that interest.
Purchase-Money Security Interest in Goods
Section 9-103(b) applies the two earlier definitions to the security interest itself: a security interest in goods is a purchase-money security interest to the extent that the goods are purchase-money collateral with respect to that security interest.20 The earlier links supply the inputs. A debt must have been incurred for the price of the goods or to enable the debtor to acquire them, and those goods must secure that debt, before the creditor's interest carries the label. This unit stays with the ordinary financing of particular goods; the sections on inventory and software come later.
The words “to the extent” make status a matter of measurement. One security interest can be purchase-money for part of the debt it secures and ordinary for the rest, because the test asks how much of the secured debt was incurred to bring these goods to the debtor. The part that financed the goods earns the status. The part that financed something else, such as an old balance or a fresh cash loan, earns nothing.
Had the agreement secured only the $80,000 price, together with the incidental acquisition costs the comment counts as part of the price, the entire interest would be purchase-money. The $15,000 is old unsecured credit unrelated to this equipment, so it falls outside the close nexus the comment requires.21 How the two pieces coexist, whether the non-purchase piece affects the purchase-money piece, and how payments are applied between them, are questions for the later sections on mixed debt and allocation.
The label the parties choose does not decide the answer. A seller who delivers goods and keeps title until the price is paid has reserved only a security interest, because Article 2 limits any retention of title by the seller in goods shipped or delivered to that effect.22 Whether the contract is called a conditional sale, a bailment lease, or something else, a court looks at the substance and asks whether the transaction satisfies the purchase-money definition.23 The creditor's role does not change the method. A bank that lends the price of a boat and takes a security interest in the boat holds a purchase-money security interest,24 so long as its advance was in fact used to buy the boat.25
The substance test cuts both ways. A caption cannot create purchase-money status for credit that financed nothing about the goods, and a different caption cannot erase it for credit that did.