Concept
Cutoff at Debtor's Possession
Including security interests arising under Article 2 (§ 9-110)
Cutoff at Debtor's Possession
Every relaxation in Section 9-110 expires on the same event. The section subjects a security interest arising under Section 2-401, 2-505, 2-711(3), or 2A-508(5) to Article 9, but the four special rules apply only "until the debtor obtains possession of the goods."1 One clause governs the whole list, so enforceability without an authenticated agreement, perfection without filing, default rights under Article 2 or 2A, and priority over the debtor's lenders all lapse together, the moment the debtor takes the goods. The interest itself survives. Section 9-109(a)(5) brought it into Article 9, and § 9-110 never took it out.2 The claimant loses only the favorable treatment, because Article 9 now applies in full, written security agreement included.3
Possession explains the cutoff. A debtor that holds goods appears to own them, and lenders and buyers may deal with it on that footing. While the goods remain with the seller or a carrier, the debtor can offer no such appearance, so an unrecorded interest can safely receive special effects. Once the debtor has the goods, the interest must meet the same requirements as every other creditor's.
Fact patterns usually test this cutoff by asking where the goods were when the dispute arose.
The same fact separates the two mills, namely who holds the goods. The first mill's missing paperwork matters because the cloth reached the debtor, and for the second mill it never mattered. The first mill's trouble also runs deeper than a missing financing statement. Once the exception ends, Article 9 requires a written security agreement, and a buyer that signed none leaves the mill with no enforceable interest at all.8 A seller that expects to deliver should therefore obtain the buyer's authenticated agreement and file before the goods leave its hands.
The analysis also requires asking whose possession ends the window, because the debtor is not the same party in every case. Under Sections 2-401 and 2-505 the debtor is the buyer, so the window closes when the buyer takes the goods. Goods still with a carrier have not reached the buyer, and commentary on stoppage in transit makes the same point: the buyer there has never had possession.9 Under Sections 2-711(3) and 2A-508(5) the debtor is the seller or lessor, so the window closes when that party regains possession of the rejected goods. The rejecting buyer's or lessee's own possession is the premise of its interest and ends nothing. If the seller or lessor does regain the goods, the buyer's or lessee's claim is then judged under the same rules as any other Article 9 creditor's.10