Concept
Four Relaxed Rules
Including security interests arising under Article 2 (§ 9-110)
Four Relaxed Rules
Section 9-110 works in two steps. It first brings a security interest arising under Section 2-401, 2-505, 2-711(3), or 2A-508(5) inside Article 9, and it then relaxes four ordinary Article 9 rules for as long as the debtor lacks possession of the goods.1 Until the debtor obtains possession, four rules apply:
- The security interest is enforceable even if Section 9-203(b)(3) has not been satisfied.2
- Filing is not required to perfect the security interest.3
- The secured party's rights after the debtor's default are governed by Article 2 or 2A.4
- The security interest has priority over a conflicting security interest created by the debtor.5
Everything these rules leave untouched stays under Article 9.6
The four rules reach four different stages of a secured transaction. The first asks whether the interest binds the debtor, the second whether it is effective against third parties, the third how the secured party enforces after default, and the fourth who wins when another creditor claims the same goods. Because each rule governs its own stage, an exam question may turn on only one of them, and you should analyze them one at a time. The phrase "until the debtor obtains possession of the goods" governs all four, so a single fact, who holds the goods, marks the end of every relaxation.7
Two facts about these interests explain the relaxations. The interests arise by operation of law as a sale or lease unfolds, so there is often no consensual grant for a security agreement to document. And each interest exists at a moment when the debtor does not yet hold the goods.8 The first fact explains the dispensed agreement requirement. The second explains the filing and priority rules. A public filing warns people who might take a debtor's possession of goods as a sign that the debtor owns them, and a debtor that has not yet received the goods gives no such sign. A lender or buyer dealing with that debtor is therefore unlikely to be misled by an interest that appears on no public record.
The subsections that follow take the four rules in order, starting with enforceability. The cutoff itself, and what happens to the interest once the debtor takes the goods, receives separate treatment after the four rules.
Enforceable Without Agreement
Section 9-110(1) addresses attachment. Until the debtor obtains possession of the goods, an Article 2 or 2A security interest is enforceable even if Section 9-203(b)(3) has not been satisfied.9 The relaxation means something only against the ordinary test. A security interest is enforceable against the debtor and third parties only if value has been given, the debtor has rights in the collateral, and one of the alternatives in paragraph (3) is met.10 Section 9-110(1) excuses that third condition and nothing else.
The paragraph (3) alternatives all do one job: they show that the debtor agreed to grant the interest. Usually the proof is a written agreement, signed by the debtor, that describes the collateral. Nine times out of ten that is how an enforceable interest arises, and very little writing will do. A note on the back of an envelope granting the bank an interest in the debtor's cattle suffices if the bank lends and the debtor owns the cattle.11 In the rare case without a signed writing, the secured party must instead possess the collateral under the debtor's security agreement or, for some kinds of collateral, control it.12 Ordinarily, then, the bar is low but real, because some proof of the debtor's agreement must exist. An Article 2 or 2A secured party may do without even that proof while the debtor lacks the goods.
The excuse follows from where these interests come from. A seller who retains title, a seller who ships under reservation, and a buyer or lessee holding rejected goods each take an interest from the sales or lease article, not from a grant by the debtor.13 An authenticated-agreement requirement exists to show that a grant occurred, so applied to an interest the debtor never granted it would test for something that is not the source of the interest. A secured party who did everything the sales or lease article contemplated would lose for want of a document the transaction never called for. Outsiders risk little either way, because a debtor that does not yet have the goods has not used them to mislead other creditors or buyers.14
The relaxation reaches only paragraph (3), so the other two conditions remain, and the underlying sale or lease ordinarily supplies both. A seller that ships or delivers on credit has given value by doing so, and a buyer that prepaid the price before rejecting has given value as well. The debtor's rights in the goods come from the sale or lease itself. The writing excused is the debtor's, and the debtor is the buyer under Sections 2-401 and 2-505 but the seller or lessor under Sections 2-711(3) and 2A-508(5).
Possession is the hinge in that pair. Two errors recur on exams: reading § 9-110(1) as waiving attachment altogether, when it excuses a single condition, and asking whether the seller has a signed agreement before asking whether the debtor has the goods. Once the buyer has possession, Article 9 applies in full, and a written security agreement is necessary.15 The relaxation also excuses the secured party without forbidding anything, so a seller that expects to deliver on credit would do well to obtain the buyer's authenticated security agreement before the goods leave its hands. The next subsection asks what the same period of non-possession does to the filing requirement.
No Filing to Perfect
Section 9-110(2) supplies the second adjustment, and it is the shortest: until the debtor obtains possession of the goods, filing is not required to perfect an Article 2 or 2A security interest.17 Perfection makes a security interest effective against third parties, such as the debtor's other creditors, and for most collateral it comes from filing a financing statement or from the secured party's possession.18 A financing statement is a short public record that tells searchers a secured party may have a claim on the debtor's property. Section 9-110(2) removes that step for the four interests in this chapter, so a seller, buyer, or lessee holding one is protected against outsiders without visiting the filing office.
Section 9-309 reaches the same result by another route. It lists security interests that are perfected automatically on attachment, without filing and without a shift of possession or control, and item (6) is an interest arising under Section 2-401, 2-505, 2-711(3), or 2A-508(5), until the debtor obtains possession of the collateral.19 The two provisions work as a pair. Section 9-110(2) says filing is not required, and § 9-309(6) supplies the affirmative result that the interest is perfected once it attaches. The same list covers other interests that lie far from ordinary financing, such as a collecting bank's security interest and the interest of a letter-of-credit issuer or nominated party, but the full list belongs to the perfection lesson.20 For these four interests, remember that both the exemption and the automatic perfection are temporary and end when the debtor takes possession.
Notice explains the exemption. A filing warns people who deal with a debtor that assets the debtor appears to own may already be encumbered. A lender deciding whether to extend credit, or a buyer deciding whether to purchase, looks at what the debtor holds and searches the public record for claims against it. Goods that have not reached the debtor are not part of what it appears to own, so no lender or buyer relies on them, and a financing statement would warn no one. An unfiled Article 2 or 2A interest is therefore unlikely to prejudice third parties while the debtor lacks the goods.21
History supports the notice rationale but does less work. Each of these interests comes from a single sale or lease transaction rather than from an ongoing financing relationship, and interests of that kind lie far from traditional lending and have long operated without a filing requirement.22 That explains why they sit comfortably on the automatic-perfection list. Notice explains why filing would accomplish nothing, and an exam answer should lead with it.
The protection ends when the goods arrive. A seller that delivers the equipment into the buyer's warehouse and never files stands in a different position, because the protection of § 9-110 is gone and the seller's claim is then an ordinary Article 9 claim.23 That seller is unperfected and exposed to the buyer's other creditors. The equipment now sits among the assets the buyer appears to own, where lenders and lien creditors will treat it as the buyer's. The notice function of filing is back in play, and the missing filing now costs the seller something.
The identity of the debtor decides whose possession ends the exemption. Under Sections 2-401 and 2-505 the debtor is the buyer. Under Sections 2-711(3) and 2A-508(5) the debtor is the seller or lessor, because the buyer or lessee is the secured party holding the rejected goods. A rejecting buyer's unfiled interest therefore stays perfected while the seller lacks the goods, and the buyer's own possession is what the interest rests on, not what ends the exemption. The relaxation excuses filing without forbidding it, so a secured party who can foresee the debtor taking possession has reason to take the ordinary perfection steps in advance.
Default Rights Under Article 2
Section 9-110(3) moves from attachment and perfection to enforcement. Until the debtor obtains possession of the goods, the secured party's rights after the debtor's default are governed by Article 2 or 2A.25 Default means the debtor's failure to perform the obligation the interest secures, such as a buyer's failure to pay for goods shipped under reservation or a seller's failure to refund a price after rightful rejection. In an ordinary secured transaction, default sends the secured party to Part 6 of Article 9. For these four interests, § 9-110(3) sends the secured party to the sales or lease article instead while the debtor lacks the goods, and the interest stays under Article 9 in every other respect.26
Part 6 is the machinery that the redirection sets aside. After default, an ordinary secured party may dispose of the collateral by sale or lease under § 9-610(a), or it may propose to accept the collateral in satisfaction of the debt, a strict foreclosure. Disposition becomes mandatory when the proposal draws no consent or draws an objection, and in certain consumer-goods situations.27 Those remedies are built for the ordinary case, in which the debtor holds the collateral and the secured party must deal with it.
That picture does not describe an Article 2 or 2A interest while the debtor lacks the goods. When a seller ships under reservation, the goods ordinarily sit with a carrier under a bill of lading the seller controls. When a buyer or lessee holds rejected goods under § 2-711(3) or § 2A-508(5), the secured party already has the goods. In neither setting is there anything to take back from the debtor, and the Part 6 remedies lose their footing. The claim also sits inside a sale or lease whose own article already says what an unpaid seller, or a rejecting buyer or lessee, may do when the other side fails to perform. The sales or lease article is therefore the natural source of the secured party's rights after default. The content of those remedies belongs to the study of Article 2 and 2A, and what matters here is where the rules come from and when Part 6 takes over.
The tempting inference is that every interest inside Article 9 is enforced under Part 6, and the possession test shows why that inference fails. A seller that shipped under reservation holds the goods through the bill of lading. If the buyer repudiates before taking delivery, the seller's rights come from Article 2, because the buyer has not obtained possession.28 The rejected-goods interests, with the roles reversed, give the same answer.
The answer changes when the debtor has the goods. A seller that delivered on credit, watched the buyer take possession, and then met a default holds an ordinary Article 9 interest, and Article 9 applies in full, Part 6 included.29 The same fit that sent the earlier scenes to Article 2 sends this one to Part 6. With the goods in the debtor's hands, the secured party has to go and get them, and Part 6 is the system built for that task.
An exam answer therefore starts with two questions. Which party is the debtor? The buyer is the debtor under Sections 2-401 and 2-505, and the seller or lessor is the debtor under Sections 2-711(3) and 2A-508(5). Has that party obtained possession of the goods? The possession that matters is the debtor's, so a rejecting buyer's own possession is the premise of its interest and never the event that brings Part 6 into play. The later section on the cutoff takes up what counts as obtaining possession and how the switch to Part 6 operates.
Priority Over Debtor's Lenders
Section 9-110(4) supplies the last of the four relaxed rules: until the debtor obtains possession of the goods, a security interest arising under Section 2-401, 2-505, 2-711(3), or 2A-508(5) has priority over a conflicting security interest created by the debtor.31 A conflicting security interest is a competing claim on the same goods, and the debtor's own lender supplies the standard example, such as a bank holding a security interest in all of a retailer's inventory. The first rule makes the interest enforceable, the second makes it effective without filing, and the third points the secured party to Article 2 or 2A after default. Only the fourth ranks the interest against the people who lend to the debtor, and that ranking decides whether the interest is worth anything when someone else claims the goods.
The paragraph displaces the ordinary priority rule, under which conflicting security interests in the same collateral generally rank by the order in which each was filed or perfected (Section 9-322). An early financing statement gives its holder an early place in line. A bank that filed against a borrower's inventory, with a clause covering after-acquired property (goods the borrower comes to own after the loan), keeps that place for every new shipment the borrower receives. Article 9 handles the Article 2 and 2A interests separately, in § 9-110.32
An express rule is needed because the ordinary rule would favor the bank. While the debtor lacks the goods, filing is not required to perfect the seller's interest, so the seller ordinarily files nothing and has no filing date to set against the bank's.33 On first-to-file alone, the seller would rank behind the bank even though its claim secures the price of those very goods. Paragraph (4) removes that result by ranking the Article 2 interest first on its own terms.
The bank gives up very little under this ordering. A lender that takes an after-acquired property clause relies on the goods its borrower actually comes to hold, because possession is what makes goods look like the borrower's inventory and a source of repayment. Goods the debtor has never had in hand were never part of what the bank could see and count on. A bank is therefore unlikely to be misled or prejudiced even though the seller never filed anything.34
Possession is the hinge between those two scenes, the same fact that ends every relaxation in § 9-110. The identity of the debtor decides whose lender sits on the other side. Under Sections 2-401 and 2-505 the debtor is the buyer, so the contest is with the buyer's lender. Under Sections 2-711(3) and 2A-508(5) the debtor is the seller or lessor, so the contest is with the seller's or lessor's lender. A print shop that rightfully rejected a digital press therefore outranks a bank holding an earlier-filed interest in the seller's inventory for as long as the seller has not regained possession of the press.35
The words created by the debtor limit the paragraph. It ranks the Article 2 or 2A interest against security interests the debtor itself granted, and it says nothing about other claimants. The limits section at the end of this chapter takes up the seller's rights to withhold delivery, to stop goods in transit, and to reclaim goods, which present their own conflicts. On an exam, an earlier-filed bank and a seller who never filed tempt students to answer for the bank. Ask first whether the debtor has obtained possession. If it has not, paragraph (4) gives the seller or rejecting buyer priority, and the missing financing statement is no defect because of paragraph (2). If it has, the ordinary Article 9 rules decide the contest.