Concept
Describing Real Estate
Including sufficiency of description (§ 9-108)
Describing Real Estate
The Code applies no special yardstick to land. Section 9-108(a) speaks of a description of "personal or real property" and calls it sufficient, whether or not it is specific, if it reasonably identifies what is described.1 The only real question is when a security agreement must describe land at all, and the occasion is narrow: the collateral is timber to be cut. In that case the authenticated security agreement must contain an adequate description of the collateral and also a description of the land that contains the timber.2 The rule, as the Code states it, singles out timber to be cut. It does not make a land description a general feature of security agreements.
The purpose of the formal requirements for creating a security interest explains why timber is treated this way. The official commentary, as one court quoted it, says those requirements exist to minimize "the possibility of future dispute as to the terms of a security agreement and as to what property stands as collateral for the obligation secured."3 Standing trees carry no identifying marks of their own, so the land is what tells a reader which trees the parties meant. The same purpose explains why a court enforcing the agreement as written will not let a creditor use parol evidence to alter its unambiguous language, a limit the chapter takes up below.4
Because the land description has that identifying job, reasonable identification is all it must achieve. The Code does not require a description to be specific or detailed, so a deed-style survey is not needed.5 If a reader can locate the tract from the words, the agreement has done what it exists to do.
The cost of omitting the land appears in C & H Farm Serv. v. Farmer's Sav. Bank, 449 N.W.2d 867 (Iowa 1989), which the treatise cites for the rule that a security agreement with no description of the real estate is ineffective.6 A court will not treat the missing description as a technicality to be overlooked.
One escape route exists. Under the composite-document rule, the requirement that the land be identified is met when the land description is absent from the security agreement but appears in the financing statement.7 When the debtor's authentication, the grant, and the collateral description are not all in one record, courts may read several records together to see whether they show an intent of the debtor and the secured party to grant a security interest in the described collateral.8 The rescue is uncertain, because a secured party should not count on a court applying the doctrine to save its attempt to attach a security interest.9 It also makes the agreement's sufficiency depend on a second document that answers to its own rules. A financing statement that fails sufficiently to provide the debtor's name under § 9-503(a) is seriously misleading, unless a search of the filing record under the debtor's correct name would still disclose it.10 The safer drafting course is to put the land description in the security agreement itself.
Two errors recur on exams. One is to demand deed-level precision, when the land need only be reasonably identified. The other is to treat a land description as a general requirement for any collateral connected to land, when the rule names timber to be cut.