Concept
Equipment
Classification of goods (§ 9-102)
Equipment
Equipment is the class that Article 9 never describes. Section 9-102(a)(33) defines it as goods other than inventory, farm products, or consumer goods.1 Each of the other three classes names a use: an individual's personal, family, or household purposes, a farming debtor's work on the farm, a business's selling, leasing, furnishing, or consuming. Equipment names none. A good lands in the class only by failing all three tests, so a lawyer who begins by asking whether goods are equipment has nothing in the goods to look for. Test the other three classes first, and what survives them is equipment. That is why this class comes last in the chapter's order of exclusions. The thing being tested must also be a good to begin with, which means a thing that is movable at the time the security interest attaches.2
A residual definition serves the statute's aim of completeness. Article 9 is meant to give a simple and unified structure to the immense variety of secured-financing transactions, and the comment to former § 9-101 calls it a comprehensive scheme for security interests in personal property and fixtures.3 A list of durable assets would have to anticipate every lathe, scanner, and cash register a debtor might own, and any item the list omitted would sit in no class at all. Defining equipment as whatever the other three classes leave behind closes that gap, because each good then ends up in exactly one principal class.
The label matters most when a security agreement describes its collateral. The description controls what the secured party gets: if the security interest covers only accounts, the secured party has no interest in the debtor's equipment or chattel paper.4 A grant of all of the debtor's equipment likewise reaches only the goods that survive the three exclusions, which leaves a dealer's stock of identical machines outside it.5
Most goods that survive the exclusions are the durable working assets of an enterprise. A business's automobile used by a salesperson is equipment, and so are the business's trucks, cash registers, tools, bulldozers, and cranes.6 So is the machinery in a manufacturer's factory.7 These examples describe how the holder uses the goods, and the type of goods settles nothing: heavy-duty equipment that a John Deere dealer holds for sale is inventory, not equipment.8 The same machine bought by a contractor to work its own jobs is equipment. Because the class follows the use, goods can fall into different classes at different times.9
A description built on business use is a guide to the class and not the test for it. Wyoming State Farm Loan Bd. v. Farm Credit Sys. Capital Corp. quotes an older definition of equipment that ran along two routes: goods used or bought for use primarily in business (including farming or a profession) or by a nonprofit or governmental debtor, or goods outside the definitions of inventory, farm products, and consumer goods.10 The current text keeps only the second route.11 Business use still predicts the answer in most problems, because the leftovers are usually business assets. Where the guide and the statute part company, the statute controls.
The scanner is equipment because the definition asks one question: does inventory, farm products, or consumer goods claim it?12 The older text named nonprofit and governmental debtors expressly, and the current text reaches the scanner by exclusion alone.13
A farming debtor still owns equipment. The farm products definition applies only when the debtor is engaged in a farming operation and the goods also fall within one of the definition's listed groups: crops, livestock, supplies used in farming, and unmanufactured products. Farming alone does not sweep in everything on the farm.14 A rancher's tractor is neither a crop nor an animal nor a product of either, and the supplies group is illustrated by consumables such as feed and seed.15 The tractor therefore falls to the residual class, while the herd it serves is farm products.
Goods that serve both business and personal ends sit at the boundary with consumer goods. A physician's car or a farmer's truck might be either consumer goods or equipment, and the principal use to which the property is put decides the class.16 The borderline problems later in this chapter work through those cases.