Concept
Lenders Other Than the Bank
Does the secured party have control?
Lenders Other Than the Bank
The depositary bank gets control without taking any extra step, because the first condition in § 9-104(a) is met when the secured party is the bank with which the deposit account is maintained.1 That condition names one institution, so it does nothing for any other lender, including a bank whose borrower keeps its account somewhere else. Security interests granted to creditors other than the depositary bank are the less common case, and those creditors must reach control through the remaining conditions in § 9-104(a), each of which ties the lender to the depositary bank or to someone who already has control.2
For an outside lender, attachment and control are separate questions. Attachment makes the interest enforceable against the debtor, and it requires, among other things, that the debtor authenticate a security agreement describing the collateral, unless the secured party has control under a security agreement instead.3 That agreement is a contract between the lender and the debtor, and the bank is not a party to it. Control is a separate question, and for an outside lender it depends on what the bank has agreed to.
Pioneer has no control. The security agreement binds Marlow, and the letter records only what Pioneer claims; neither records an agreement by the bank. Control by agreement requires that the debtor, the secured party, and the bank agree in a signed record that the bank will comply with the secured party's instructions without further consent by the debtor.4 Pioneer is also not the bank with which the account is maintained and not Hillside's customer, so none of the conditions is met. Its interest has attached but is unperfected, because a direct security interest in a deposit account can be perfected only by control.5
Now suppose that Pioneer, Marlow, and Hillside all sign a record in which Hillside agrees to comply with Pioneer's instructions directing disposition of the funds without further consent by Marlow. Pioneer has control. In both versions Pioneer is an outsider to the account and Marlow signed the same security agreement. What changed the result is the bank's commitment.
Section 9-104(a) offers three routes besides depositary-bank status, and each runs through the bank or through someone who already has control:
- A control agreement, in which the debtor, the secured party, and the bank agree in a signed record that the bank will comply with the secured party's instructions directing disposition of the funds without further consent by the debtor.6
- Customer status, in which the secured party becomes the bank's customer with respect to the deposit account.7
- Control held for the secured party by another person, who either already has control of the account and acknowledges that it has control on behalf of the secured party, or obtains control after acknowledging that it will obtain control on the secured party's behalf.8
In the first route the bank itself commits, in the second the lender becomes a party to the account relationship, and in the third someone else's control is held for the lender. The common thread is a connection to the institution that holds the funds, which the depositary bank has automatically.
A bank has no reason to sign these agreements on faith. If the lender instructs the bank to close the account and pay over the funds, and the bank delays because of a mistake or uncertainty about the lender's rights, the depositor may withdraw the money in the meantime, and the bank probably faces liability to the lender. For bearing that exposure the bank gets nothing unless it bargains for it.9 An outside lender therefore has to bargain for the bank's cooperation.
An agreement that rests on one account at one bank does not follow the funds. If the debtor moves the account to another bank, or is no longer the customer on the account, an existing control agreement stops being effective.10
Regulation of consumer financial services is a separate and unsettled subject. Title X of the Dodd-Frank Act created the Bureau of Consumer Financial Protection to enforce most existing and many potential consumer financial services laws, and the ultimate effect on specific issues remains uncertain.11 That subject lies outside this chapter's Article 9 analysis.
A stem that recites a security agreement, a financing statement, or a letter to the bank describes steps that need no agreement from the bank. Ask first whether the lender is the bank with which the account is maintained, and if it is not, whether the lender has taken one of the further steps that involve the bank. Where an exam fixes the space for each answer, shorthand is expected and brevity is rewarded: not depositary bank; no control agreement; not customer; no control.12
What a Financing Statement Does
Article 9 defines a financing statement as a record or records composed of an initial financing statement and any filed record relating to the initial financing statement.14 Its function is notice. It is filed in a particular state office, such as the Secretary of State, and it tells anyone who looks that a named secured party may have a security interest in the stated debtor's collateral.15 The word may carries the point. The filing announces a possibility and proves nothing, so it has to be kept apart from two things the discussion of control has already put in play: the security agreement and attachment that create a security interest, and the control that connects a secured party to the bank.
The record is deliberately skeletal. A financing statement is sufficient if it provides the debtor's name, provides the name of the secured party or its representative, and indicates the collateral.16 It need not be signed, and it contains no language showing that the debtor intends to grant a security interest.17 The thinness is by design. Article 9 adopted a notice-filing system, and the filed document carries little information, meant only to put third parties on notice that the debtor may have given a security interest in the described property.18 The Code's first innovation here was to file a separate skeletal document in place of recording the parties' actual contract, as with a chattel mortgage, and its second was to move most filing into a single statewide registry.19 A searcher who finds the filing learns that the named creditor may claim the collateral and learns nothing more, so the parties' private terms stay out of the public record.
The three questions have separate sources, and a yes to one does not supply the others. Attachment rests on the debtor's agreement or on control, and a financing statement supplies neither.20 A document that merely meets the requirements of a financing statement lacks the language showing an intent to grant, so a creditor that does nothing more than file has no security interest in the described property.21 Control is the secured party's position with respect to the bank, and for intangible property it is analogous to possession.22 A record sitting in a government office does not change what the bank will do when the debtor gives an instruction, so a filing cannot supply control.
Timing confirms the separation. A financing statement may be filed before the security interest attaches, so it can sit on the public record before any loan is made or any agreement is signed.23 The existence of a filing therefore says nothing reliable about whether a security interest exists. The filing gives notice, attachment binds the debtor, and perfection, which protects the secured party against other creditors and a trustee in bankruptcy, depends on a method the Code permits for the collateral at issue.24
The financing statement is sufficient and the security interest has attached, but the lender has no control. It is not the bank with which the account is maintained, and it has taken no step involving that bank.25 Two of the three questions come out yes, and the one that decides the matter for a deposit account comes out no. The next subsection explains why the filing cannot make up the difference: a direct security interest in a deposit account can be perfected only by control.26 The same record does its full work where control is not the test. A lender with an attached security interest in a retailer's inventory that files a financing statement naming the retailer and the lender and indicating the inventory has used a standard method of perfecting a security interest in goods.27
Filing Cannot Perfect Deposit Accounts
Filing a financing statement is the dominant method of perfection, and unless Article 9 provides an exception it is the only acceptable method.29 Deposit accounts fall on the other side of that line. Section 9-312(b)(1) bars filing as a method of perfecting a security interest in a deposit account, and the same bar covers letter-of-credit rights and money, except when those assets are proceeds.30 When the debtor pledges the account itself, so that the account is the original collateral, control is the only route to perfection.31
The bar concerns the method of perfection and has nothing to do with how well the filing is drafted. A financing statement that names the debtor, names the secured party, and indicates the collateral is sufficient as a record, and it still perfects nothing when the collateral is a deposit account taken as original collateral.32 The same record filed by the same lender would perfect a security interest in the debtor's inventory. The form is adequate in both cases, and the type of collateral changes the result.
Two systems are at work, and each answers a different question. A filing speaks to searchers of the public record, telling them that a creditor may hold an interest in described property, and the notice-filing system is built for that purpose.33 Control speaks to the institution that holds the funds, and for intangible property it is analogous to possession.34 For a deposit account, Article 9 asks for the second.
A lender that stops at filing therefore holds an interest that has attached but is unperfected. Attachment makes the interest enforceable against the debtor.35 Perfection is what protects the secured party against the debtor's other creditors and transferees and, in particular, against a representative of creditors in insolvency proceedings, such as a trustee in bankruptcy.36 The unperfected lender is exposed to exactly that representative if the debtor files for bankruptcy. Contests between competing secured parties raise separate priority questions, which the section on control versus filing takes up.
Two similar terms need to be kept apart in the next example. An account is a right to payment, such as a customer receivable, and it is intangible collateral.37 A deposit account is a bank balance, and the two follow different perfection rules.
The receivables are accounts, and filing is the general means of perfecting a security interest in accounts, so the financing statement perfects the lender's interest there.38 The balance is a deposit account taken as original collateral, so the same filing does nothing for it. The lender is not Harbor Bank and holds no other position with the bank, so it lacks control and its interest in the balance is unperfected.39 The trustee in bankruptcy can reach the balance and cannot reach the receivables. One loan, one agreement, and one filing produce two results, and the type of collateral explains the difference.
A bank in the lender's position holds the account on different terms. When a bank lends to its own depositor and takes a security interest in the account it maintains, it files nothing and is perfected by control, because the depositary bank automatically has control. Because it has control, its security agreement need not even be authenticated by the debtor.40 An outside lender that wants the same protection must take one of the other routes in § 9-104(a): a signed control agreement with the debtor and the bank,41 or customer status on the account.42 A lender that is itself a bank gets the depositary-bank rule if the debtor moves the account to it. A lender that finds the gap can close it by taking one of these steps, and until then its interest is unperfected.43
A fact pattern that recites a signed security agreement, a complete financing statement, and a collateral description naming deposit accounts describes a lender that has done everything except the one step that perfects. Classify the collateral first and then name the method: a deposit account taken as original collateral is perfected by control. Before reaching for the proceeds exception, check whether the balance came from other collateral in which the lender is already perfected, because the exception is unavailable without that fact. If the exam gives a fixed answer space, brevity is rewarded: deposit account, original collateral; filing ineffective; no control; unperfected.44
Identifiable Cash Proceeds Exception
Article 9 defines cash proceeds as proceeds that are money, checks, deposit accounts, or the like.46 Because deposit accounts appear on that list, one bank balance can play two roles. It can be original collateral that the debtor pledged directly, which the preceding subsection showed can be perfected only by control. Or it can be the place where the money from a sale of other collateral landed. A security interest in the original collateral gives the secured party rights in its proceeds under § 9-315,47 and the second role is the one exception to the rule that a filing cannot perfect a deposit account.48
Section 9-315(c) supplies the link: a security interest in proceeds is perfected if the security interest in the original collateral was perfected.49 For identifiable cash proceeds the protection has no expiration. The secured creditor is indefinitely perfected as to them, which means it has a continuously perfected security interest in the debtor's bank account, at least if it can identify the proceeds portion of that account.50 The bad news for the lender is that money and checks are seldom long in the hands of a troubled debtor, so the account may hold little by the time the lender needs it.51
Three conditions limit the exception. The lender must be perfected in the original collateral, because perfection in proceeds depends on it. The receipts must be cash proceeds, and a deposit account qualifies. And the proceeds must be identifiable, a question of fact that turns on tracing the proceeds of other collateral into the account.52
National Bank is perfected in part of the account without control. Its security interest in the inventory was perfected, the sale money is cash proceeds, the account that received it is itself cash proceeds, and the money is identifiable to the extent it can be traced. Under the lowest intermediate balance rule the identifiable proceeds in the account are $2,000, so National Bank is perfected in $2,000 and in nothing more.53 The rule treats the lowest balance the account reached after the proceeds were deposited as the most that can still be proceeds: once the balance fell to $2,000, no more than that much of the sale money could remain, and the later $8,000 came from other sources. The rule measures proof, meaning how much of the account can be shown to come from other collateral, and it is separate from whether the lender has any relationship with the bank.54
A stem like this invites the mistake of treating the exception as if the whole $10,000 became National Bank's collateral. The other $8,000 cannot be traced to National Bank's inventory, and a filing is a permitted method of perfecting as to a deposit account only to the extent of identifiable proceeds.55 The exception also has a front door that must be open. A lender never perfected in the inventory has nothing to carry over, because perfection in proceeds exists only if perfection in the original collateral did.56
State Bank's position rests on something else. As the bank with which the account is maintained, State Bank has control with no filing and no tracing.57 When the claims meet, control decides: State Bank's security interest has priority in all of the funds under § 9-327, National Bank ranks second as to the $2,000, and State Bank alone holds an interest in the other $8,000.58
The ranking follows from what each claimant holds. State Bank has a position with the institution that releases the funds, and that position covers every dollar whatever its source. National Bank holds perfection earned through the inventory, which follows the traceable money and no further. The exception protects National Bank against the debtor's other creditors as to $2,000 and leaves it behind any secured party that has control. The next section sets out those priority rules.