Concept
Classifying the Collateral
Does the secured party have control?
Classifying the Collateral
Perfection starts with a classification question: what kind of collateral did the debtor pledge? Article 9 sorts collateral into defined categories, and two of them sound so alike that lenders confuse them. The deposit account and the Article 9 “account” both involve money owed to the debtor, yet the statute keeps them apart. The definition of account ends with a list of assets it does not include, and deposit accounts are on that list.1 A checking balance and a customer’s obligation to pay for delivered goods are therefore different assets, however natural it feels to call both of them accounts.
The distinction matters because the perfection step depends on the category. In the large majority of cases, the secured party perfects by filing a financing statement, the “UCC-1,” in the government office the state designates for that purpose.2 A deposit account is the notable exception. As original collateral, it can be perfected only by the secured party’s taking control.3 Control is the intangible-property analogue of possession.4 Whichever step applies, a security interest is perfected only when it has attached and every applicable perfection requirement has been met.5 A lender who misclassifies the collateral takes the wrong step, and the security interest stays unperfected.
The lawyer’s premise fails at the first step. A savings balance is a deposit account, and the definition of account excludes deposit accounts.6 Control is the only route to perfection in the balance, and the filing gives the lender none, so the lender’s interest is unperfected.7 Run the same analysis on a customer’s promise to pay for goods the debtor sold, and the answer changes, because that right to payment is an Article 9 account.8
The two subsections below take each definition in turn. Classify first; the question of control comes after.
Deposit Account Defined
Article 9 defines a deposit account as a demand, time, savings, passbook, or similar account maintained with a bank, and it carves out investment property and accounts evidenced by an instrument.9 That one sentence yields three checks: the kind of account, the institution that maintains it, and the two exclusions. An asset must pass all three.
The first check is the kind of account. The statute names demand, time, savings, and passbook accounts and closes with “similar” accounts, so the list is illustrative. An ordinary checking balance is a demand account, and a savings balance is a savings account. A product sold under a new name still qualifies if it resembles those accounts and a bank maintains it.
The second check is the institution. Article 9 defines a bank as an organization engaged in the business of banking, and the definition expressly includes savings banks, savings and loan associations, credit unions, and trust companies.10 A member’s savings account at a credit union is therefore a deposit account, even though members rarely think of a credit union as a bank.
The third check is the exclusions. A brokerage’s securities account fails the definition twice: a securities firm is not engaged in the business of banking, and the definition excludes investment property.11 Investment property follows its own control rules. A securities intermediary’s agreement to comply with entitlement orders originated by the secured party, without further consent from the entitlement holder, gives that party control. When an entitlement holder grants an interest to its own securities intermediary, the intermediary has control.12 The second exclusion removes an account evidenced by an instrument, and the definition of Article 9 account removes rights to payment evidenced by an instrument as well. The older definition of deposit account made a comparable cut, excluding an account evidenced by a certificate of deposit.13
Older Article 9 treated deposit accounts quite differently. It excluded transfers of interests in deposit accounts from its coverage, apart from proceeds claims under old § 9–306, and lenders relied on a common-law pledge as a widely recognized substitute.14 Current Article 9 covers a security interest in a deposit account as original collateral and makes control the way to perfect it.15
The savings account is a deposit account, because savings is a listed kind of account and a commercial bank is plainly a bank.16 The securities account is not, because the shares in it are investment property and the firm that holds them is not a bank. The lender needs control of the savings account as a deposit account, and it must satisfy the separate investment-property rules for the securities account.
One scope limit calls for a short caution. Article 9 does not apply to an assignment of an interest in a deposit account in a consumer transaction, unless the deposit account is proceeds of other collateral in which there is a security interest.17 A consumer transaction has three features: an individual incurs an obligation primarily for personal, family, or household purposes, a security interest secures the obligation, and the collateral is held or acquired primarily for those purposes.18 Article 9’s rules, including its control requirement, therefore stop governing such a pledge, and other law decides whether the lender’s interest is effective.
Both debtors pledge the same kind of account, and each is an individual, so neither fact separates them. The purpose of the loan does. Ortega borrows for business, so the transaction is not a consumer transaction, and his pledge falls within Article 9, where control is the route to perfection. Weiss borrows for personal purposes and holds the collateral for personal purposes, so her pledge is a consumer transaction outside Article 9.
Article 9 Account Defined
An Article 9 account is a right to payment of a monetary obligation, whether or not the debtor has yet earned it by performing. The right can arise from property sold, leased, or licensed, from services rendered, from the use of a credit or charge card, or from several other listed sources.20 The picture to hold is the ordinary receivable. The debtor delivers goods or does the work, a customer owes the price, and the debtor’s right to collect that price is the collateral.
The definition ends with a list of assets it does not include. The list names chattel paper, commercial tort claims, deposit accounts, investment property, letter-of-credit rights, and rights to payment evidenced by an instrument, among others.21 The exclusion of deposit accounts is necessary because the opening words alone would reach a bank balance. A balance is a right to payment of a monetary obligation, since the bank owes the depositor the funds on deposit. Someone who stopped reading after the first sentence of the definition could conclude that every checking account is an Article 9 account. The carve-out blocks that conclusion and keeps the two categories apart, the same boundary the deposit-account definition draws from the other side.
Both assets are claims to be paid, so the quickest way to classify one is to ask who owes the debtor. When a customer owes the debtor for goods bought or services performed, the asset is an Article 9 account. When the bank holding the debtor’s funds owes them back, the asset is a deposit account.22 An account is money owed by a third party to the debtor, and a deposit account is Article 9’s name for a bank account. Asking who owes the debtor sorts most collateral descriptions in seconds.
The chain’s promise is a right to payment for property sold, so the $25,000 receivable is an Article 9 account.23 The $60,000 balance is also a right to be paid, but the bank is the obligor, and the definition of account expressly excludes deposit accounts. The balance is a deposit account. The two assets have the same owner and secure the same loan, and the only fact that separates them is who owes the wholesaler the money.
That classification decides the lender’s next step, because the two assets are perfected differently and foreclosed upon differently.24 Perfection, as distinct from creation of the security interest by agreement, typically involves filing notice of the interest.25 That is the usual route for the receivable.26 A deposit account taken as original collateral can be perfected only by control.27 Enforcement diverges in the same way. A secured party with control of a deposit account has a simple remedy on default: it withdraws the money and applies it to the debt.28 The lender in the savings-balance scene treated a bank balance as an account and filed, and that misclassification left it unperfected. With the collateral classified correctly, the question that remains is control: who holds it, and how.