Concept
Why Classification Matters
Is the security interest a purchase-money security interest?
Why Classification Matters
Purchase-money status matters because it rewrites the ranking rules in the situations where a late-filing financier would otherwise lose. The baseline is first to file or perfect: conflicting perfected security interests rank by the earlier of the date a filing covering the collateral is first made and the date the interest is first perfected, so long as no later period passes with neither filing nor perfection.1 Two companion rules complete it. A perfected interest outranks an unperfected one, and when both are unperfected the interest that attached first prevails.2 Section 9-324 departs from the baseline for the purchase-money financier, giving it what the sources call super priority even when its own perfection comes later.3
Which rule applies depends on the opponent. Section 9-317 ranks secured creditors against lien creditors, buyers, and lessees; § 9-322 ranks secured creditors against one another; § 9-324 ranks purchase-money secured creditors against other secured creditors; and § 9-334 governs fixtures and crops.4 A secured party that wants first priority in fixtures files a fixture financing statement in the real estate recording office, a subject the next section develops.5
Every contest presupposes a security interest, and the purchase-money label turns on what the secured party's value did. A security agreement is the written agreement in which a borrower gives a lender the right to take described property if the loan is not repaid.6 A security interest in goods is purchase-money when it secures value that enabled the debtor to acquire rights in the goods, when it secures value that enabled the debtor to acquire software for use in those goods in the same transaction, or when it is in inventory and secures value that enabled the debtor to acquire other inventory in which the same secured party holds a purchase-money interest. In each case the debtor must actually use the value to acquire the goods or software.7
Purchase-money status never decides a contest alone, because the conditions that turn it into a winning position change with the collateral and the opponent. The three subsections below take the opponents in turn: lien creditors and buyers, earlier secured parties, and the bankruptcy trustee.
Lien Creditors and Buyers
A lien creditor defeats a secured party whose interest is attached but unperfected when the lien arises, unless the secured party holds a purchase-money interest and files in time. A lien creditor is a creditor that has obtained a lien on the debtor's personal property by execution, attachment, or levy; the term also covers an assignee for the benefit of creditors, an equity receiver, and a trustee in bankruptcy.8 Subject to two exceptions, a security interest that is attached but unperfected at the moment the creditor becomes a lien creditor is subordinate to the lien.9 A later filing does not repair that position, because a filing made after attachment perfects only from the time it is made, and the Code gives no relation back or general grace period.10
The principal exception is the purchase-money grace period in § 9-317(e). The holder of a purchase-money security interest has 20 days after the debtor receives delivery of the collateral in which to file, and a filing within that period takes priority over a lien creditor whose lien attaches between the time the security interest arose and the time of the filing.11 The same period cuts off the interests of intervening buyers, lessees, and lien creditors, and no one else.12 It runs from the day the debtor obtains possession, not from the day the parties create the security interest.13
The ordinary lender receives no such period. When a debtor grants a nonpurchase-money security interest in widgets on April 1 and the secured party files on April 10, the filing is ineffective against every claimant described in § 9-317(a) whose rights in the widgets arose before April 10.14 Had the interest been purchase-money and the debtor received the widgets on April 1, the same filing would have prevailed against the same claimants. The difference lies in what the value did: a purchase-money advance put the goods in the debtor's hands, while an advance that enabled no acquisition earns no grace period.15
Buyers and lessees follow the same pattern. Attachment alone does not stop the debtor from transferring the collateral, and when the debtor does, Article 9 governs the secured party's rights against the transferee.16 A lessee that takes possession while the security interest is unperfected still takes the goods subject to a purchase-money interest if the secured party files within 20 days after the debtor received delivery.17 A buyer that does take subject to an earlier interest has a separate protection against later lending. The secured party may keep making advances for 45 days after the sale, and the buyer takes subject to them; after the 45 days, the buyer is not subject to the interest for future advances.18 A lessee not in the ordinary course takes free of the interest securing a later advance if the secured party made the advance with knowledge of the lease or 45 days or more after the lease contract becomes enforceable.19
A buyer in ordinary course of business stands apart. That buyer takes free of a security interest created by the buyer's seller, even if the interest is perfected and the buyer knows of it.20 Qualification is a mixed question of fact, and a merchant purchaser meets a higher standard on imputed knowledge, but disqualifying a purchaser generally requires knowledge that the sale violates a third party's ownership rights, not mere knowledge that a third party has some interest.21 A purchase-money financier of a retailer's stock therefore cannot follow the goods into the hands of the retailer's ordinary customers.
Consumer goods change the analysis, because a purchase-money interest in consumer goods is perfected automatically when it attaches, with no filing and no possession.22 The reason is cost. Filing on every sale of a chair, stove, or washing machine would fill the filing offices for little benefit, because creditors have long known to be on guard against such interests and, other than purchase-money lenders, seldom rely on goods that cost little and depreciate quickly.23 The rule does little work in commercial lending, since the largest commercial purchase-money loans are not in consumer goods. A secured party with a purchase-money interest in collateral other than inventory must still perfect, and it has 20 days in which to do so to keep priority over intervening lien creditors.24 Registered motor vehicles are a carve-out even among consumer goods: a security interest in a vehicle purchased for personal or family use is perfected only by filing or by complying with the state certificate of title law.25
Automatic perfection costs the secured party in one setting, a sale between consumers. Under § 9-320(b), a buyer of goods from a person who used or bought them primarily for personal, family, or household purposes takes free of a security interest, even a perfected one, if the buyer meets the section's conditions.26 The automatic interest is perfected on attachment, yet a buyer who meets those conditions still takes free of it. Once the purchase-money secured party files, however, any buyer takes the consumer goods subject to the interest.27 A seller that wants protection against resale therefore files even though the Code does not require it.
Competing Secured Parties
Contests between secured parties fall under §§ 9-322 and 9-324 rather than § 9-317, and the starting rule remains first to file or perfect.29 For goods other than inventory and livestock, § 9-324(a) departs from that rule: a purchase-money security interest has priority over a conflicting security interest in the same goods if it is perfected when the debtor receives possession of the collateral or within 20 days afterward.30 The perfecting step is filing for equipment and happens automatically for certain consumer goods.31
Three features of the 20-day window decide most equipment problems. The clock runs from the day the debtor receives possession, not from the creation of the security interest.32 The financier need not be without notice or knowledge of the earlier interest; it takes priority although it knows of the other interest or that interest has been filed.33 And a financier that misses the window loses the exception, so priority falls back to the first-to-file-or-perfect rule of § 9-322(a).34 The exception follows from what the purchase-money value did: without the financier's credit, the debtor would not own the goods at all.
Inventory carries stricter conditions. A purchase-money interest in inventory outranks a conflicting interest in the same inventory only if all three of the following hold.35
- The purchase-money interest is perfected when the debtor receives possession of the inventory; no 20-day grace period applies to inventory.36
- The purchase-money secured party sends an authenticated notice to the holder of the conflicting security interest.
- The holder receives that notice within five years before the debtor receives possession of the inventory.
The notice must state that the sender has or expects to acquire a purchase-money security interest in the debtor's inventory and must describe the inventory.37 The requirement protects an earlier inventory lender. That lender does regular floor checks, and without notice it might count everything it sees as its own, unaware that another creditor financed part of it.38
Notice cannot cure missing perfection. State Bank gave National Bank timely and proper notice, intending to claim inventory priority under § 9-324(b), but filed its financing statement in the wrong state, so its security interest was attached but unperfected.39 Automatic perfection reaches only purchase-money interests in consumer goods, so it offers no fallback for business inventory or equipment.40
Where automatic perfection does apply, no filing is needed. In one worked example, V held a purchase-money interest in a debtor's computer. Treated as equipment, the computer required V to file, and V's filing on April 1, within 20 days after the debtor took possession, met the timing rule.41 Treated as consumer goods, the same interest was perfected automatically, and V had priority over a competing creditor without any filing.42
Steps three and four are where answers diverge. The usual error is to give an inventory financier the 20-day window that an equipment financier receives, or to treat notice as a substitute for perfection when the inventory rule demands both.
Bankruptcy and Preferences
A bankruptcy trustee has two principal tools against a secured party whose interest arose shortly before the petition, and the purchase-money label answers each tool on a different clock. As a hypothetical lien creditor, the trustee meets a 20-day rule. As a preference plaintiff, the trustee meets a 30-day rule.
The trustee's first tool is lien-creditor status. A trustee in bankruptcy is a lien creditor as of the time the petition is filed.44 The trustee therefore obtains the rights of a hypothetical lien creditor as of that date, and a secured party that is unperfected on the petition date loses to the trustee as it would lose to any lien creditor under § 9-317(a)(2).45 A purchase-money interest perfected within 20 days after the debtor receives delivery defeats a lien creditor whose lien arises in the gap, and a trustee holds no greater rights, so the trustee cannot invalidate such an interest.46 The petition itself may arrive before the filing. If the debtor receives the collateral on May 1 and files a petition on May 6, the secured party may still file effectively on or before May 20, even knowing of the bankruptcy, in a state that enacts the uniform 20-day grace period.47 The Bankruptcy Code allows that filing because it excepts a perfection step of this kind from the automatic stay.48
The second tool is preference avoidance. The trustee may avoid a transfer of the debtor's property made to or for the benefit of a creditor on account of an antecedent debt, while the debtor was insolvent, within 90 days before the petition (one year if the creditor is an insider), if the transfer lets the creditor obtain more than it would in a Chapter 7 liquidation.49 Timing drives the analysis. A transfer is made when it takes effect between the debtor and the creditor if the creditor perfects within 30 days afterward; a transfer perfected later is made at the time of perfection, and one that remains unperfected at the petition and beyond the 30 days is treated as made at the petition.50 A lender that advances money on March 1 and perfects on April 15 therefore looks like a creditor that took collateral on April 15 for a debt incurred earlier, the pattern preference law targets.51 The rule has a public-notice rationale: a creditor that does not perfect leaves others unaware that the debtor's property is encumbered, and they may extend credit in reliance on the mistaken belief that the property is free of liens.52
Section 547(c)(3) shields the purchase-money financier from that result. A transfer that creates a purchase-money security interest is not avoidable if the interest secures new value given at or after the signing of the security agreement, the value was given to enable the debtor to acquire the property, the debtor in fact used it for that purpose, and the interest is perfected on or before 30 days after the debtor receives possession. The first three requirements repeat the value-enabling-acquisition test from earlier in this chapter. The fourth supplies the timing. The exception rests on the same fact as the Article 9 priority: the lender's value produced the asset, so no other creditor ever had it to rely on.
The 20-day and 30-day periods answer different attacks, and answering a lien-creditor claim with the 30-day period is the usual mistake. The 20 days protect against the trustee as lien creditor. The 30 days protect against the trustee as preference plaintiff. A secured party can satisfy one period and miss the other.
Losing purchase-money status does not always expose a perfected lender to the trustee. In one source illustration, a construction company owed $1 million in principal on ten tractors under a purchase-money loan, and the security agreement contained a cross-collateral clause. After a $200,000 payment, a first-in, first-out clause would treat the first two tractors as paid off, but the cross-collateral clause kept those two tractors subject to the security interest for the price of the other eight. That interest is not purchase-money and lacks the super priority of § 9-324, yet it remains perfected and defeats a trustee in bankruptcy.53
The label also affects a debtor who stays in bankruptcy and tries to keep the goods. An individual debtor may redeem exempt tangible personal property held for personal, family, or household use by paying the creditor the collateral's value in a lump sum, without the creditor's consent; any shortfall becomes an unsecured claim.54 Unlike § 522(f), the redemption right in § 722 reaches purchase-money interests in a debtor's personal cars and other consumer goods.55 In Chapter 13, a debtor can ordinarily strip a secured debt down to the value of the collateral, but the 2005 amendments bar stripdown of a purchase-money interest in a motor vehicle acquired for the debtor's personal use within 910 days before filing, and of a purchase-money interest in other collateral, such as household goods, securing a debt incurred within one year.56 The truck loan in Till v. SCS Credit Corp. shows the kind of debt these rules reach. The Tills bought a used truck for $6,395 plus $330.75 in fees and taxes, paid $300 down, and financed the balance through a retail installment contract, assigned to SCS Credit Corporation, secured by a purchase-money security interest in the truck.57 A Chapter 13 debtor who filed within 910 days of buying a vehicle for personal use on such terms could not strip the loan down to the vehicle's value.