Concept
The Purchase-Money Test
Is the security interest a purchase-money security interest?
The Purchase-Money Test
A purchase-money security interest is an ordinary security interest that has earned a label from the way it was financed. Article 9 generally cares little about how a secured transaction is structured, but it makes an exception for a structure that produces a purchase-money security interest.1 The label matters whenever someone other than the secured party claims the same collateral. Such priorities problems arise, for example, when the debtor sells the collateral and the question becomes whether the secured party can enforce its interest against the buyer.2 Ordinary rules settle some of those contests on a clock: a secured party can keep lending for 45 days without regard to a sale of the collateral, but after the 45 days the buyer is not subject to the security interest for future advances.3
Purchase-money status adds protection of a different kind. Subject to two exceptions, an attached but unperfected security interest loses to a lien creditor, a term that covers a creditor who has obtained a lien by execution, attachment, or levy, and also an assignee for the benefit of creditors, an equity receiver, and a trustee in bankruptcy.4 An exception to that rule serves purchase-money claims: the holder has 20 days after the debtor receives delivery of the collateral in which to file, and a security interest filed within that period takes priority over a lien creditor whose rights arise between attachment and filing.5 Buyers and lessees whose rights arise in the same gap lose as well.6 In inventory, priority over an earlier lender carries further conditions. The purchase-money interest must be perfected when the debtor receives possession, and the purchase-money secured party must send an authenticated notice that the earlier lender receives within five years before the debtor takes possession.7 Later sections develop these rules. This unit asks only which security interests qualify.
Section 9–103 sets the test in layers, and the layers organize what follows. For goods, a security interest qualifies in any of three situations:
- it secures value given to enable the debtor to acquire rights in the goods;
- it secures value given to enable the debtor to acquire rights in software, when the debtor acquired the software in the same transaction as the goods and the software is for use in the goods; or
- it is a security interest in inventory and secures value given to enable the debtor to acquire other items of inventory in which the secured party also holds a purchase-money security interest.8
Subsection (c) separately tests a security interest in software itself, and subsection (d) deems a consignor’s interest purchase-money in inventory.9 Nothing outside goods and software qualifies.10 One requirement runs through every situation: the value given must actually be used by the debtor to acquire rights in the goods, or in software for use in the goods.11 The subsections below take the situations in order, beginning with the plain case of a seller or lender that finances the debtor’s purchase of goods.
Value Enabling Acquisition
A security interest in goods is purchase-money when it secures value given to enable the debtor to acquire rights in those goods.12 Section 9–103(a)(2) divides that test in two. The creditor must make advances or incur an obligation “to enable the debtor to acquire rights in or the use of the collateral,” and the money lent must in fact be so used.13 The first part tests function: the secured party’s credit or cash must have made the acquisition possible. The second tests fact: the value must have reached the goods.
Two kinds of creditor can meet the test. The seller can, and so can a third party, such as a bank or finance company, that lends money to a prospective buyer to enable the purchase.14 Because Article 9 lets the structure of a financing decide this status, the analysis reads the deal itself: who gave what value, and what that value bought.15
A seller finances its own sale by delivering goods before the price is paid. If the seller ships under reservation, it holds a security interest in the goods; if it ships without reservation, it holds none and has nothing to classify.16 The reserved interest secures the unpaid price, and the credit the seller extended is the value that enabled the buyer to acquire the goods. Neither the contract’s label nor the absence of a separate loan document changes that result. Whether the parties call the deal a conditional sales contract, a bailment lease, or something else, what matters is whether its substance satisfies § 9–103(b).17
A lender stands on the same footing in function but carries an extra burden of proof. Its advance puts the goods in the debtor’s hands as a seller’s credit does, yet it holds a purchase-money interest only if it can show that the money it lent was in fact used to acquire an interest in the collateral in question.18 A seller’s credit arrives as the goods themselves. A lender’s money can go anywhere, so the tracing requirement does its most visible work with lenders.
Both banks hold interests in the same tools, so the fact that decides each result is where the money went. A general lender whose advance paid wages did not bring the tools into the debtor’s hands, and its interest does not become purchase-money merely because the debtor bought the tools around the time of the loan. The same logic disposes of a loan made against goods the debtor already owns. Value that arrives after the acquisition is complete cannot have been given to enable it.
An exam stem that says a lender “financed” the debtor’s equipment invites a quick conclusion that the lender is a purchase-money creditor. The word settles nothing. Ask whether the lender’s value enabled the acquisition and went into it.
Steps three and four carry most of the weight. Step three catches the loan made against goods the debtor already holds, and step four catches the advance that was real but went somewhere else. A seller’s reserved interest usually clears both at once, because the goods and the credit travel together in a single sale.
Software Purchase-Money Interests
Purchase-money collateral is limited to goods and software, and the Code gives software its own rules.20 A machine is often useless without its program, and one financier often funds both in a single deal. Two rules result. The first treats an interest in the goods as purchase-money when it secures the price of software acquired with them. The second tests an interest in the software itself.
The first rule works on the interest in the goods. A security interest in goods is purchase-money when it secures value given to enable the debtor to acquire rights in software, if the debtor acquired the software in the same transaction as the goods and the software is for use in the goods.21 As everywhere under § 9–103, the value must actually be used for that acquisition. Without this rule, an interest in a machine would qualify only through the basic situation, which asks about value given to acquire the goods. The rule lets the same interest qualify also for value that financed the program.
The second rule gives the software its own status, and it is stricter, because four conditions must all be present.22
The first two conditions import the goods analysis. Software qualifies under this rule only through a financed acquisition of goods in which the secured party holds a purchase-money interest. The last two conditions do the limiting. The same-transaction condition ties the software to the deal the financier’s value made possible, so a program bought months later under a separate arrangement was no part of that acquisition. The principal-purpose condition ties the software to the goods by function, so a program whose main use lies elsewhere is not the machine’s program.
Now test each limit alone.
Inventory Cross-Financing
The third situation reaches across items of inventory. A security interest in inventory is purchase-money when it secures value given to enable the debtor to acquire other items of inventory in which the secured party also holds a purchase-money security interest, and the debtor must actually use the value to acquire those goods.24 Inventory is the stock a business holds for sale, and a dealer’s stock turns over constantly. The situation therefore serves a lender that finances a stream of purchases and not a single one.
A lender that finances a dealer’s stock rarely finances one item. It advances money against many purchases and often adds a cross-collateral clause, which makes each item collateral for the prices of the other items as well as its own.25 Each advance, taken alone, satisfies the basic test. The difficulty comes later. As items sell, a payment can be applied to the loan on one item that is still on the lot and still securing the prices of others. Viewed item by item, the remaining claim no longer secures the price of the item it burdens. The inventory situation answers by viewing the financing as a whole, so the claim keeps its purchase-money status. Because the secured party must hold a purchase-money interest in the other items, the rule reaches only a financier whose own value brought that stock in.
One illustration shows the rule at work. A dealer’s inventory financing covers Chevrolets and other inventory, and under the dealer’s method of accounting the loans against the Chevrolets are treated as satisfied. A bank argues that the remaining claim against the Chevrolets is therefore a non-purchase-money security interest. The bank loses, because § 9–103(b) provides that the loan against the Chevrolets, as other inventory, remains a purchase-money loan.26
A cross-collateral clause can also appear where the inventory situation does not apply, and the result changes. In one tractor illustration, the clause makes two tractors subject to the security interest against the purchase price of the eight remaining tractors. That latter interest is not purchase-money and earns no super priority under § 9–324, but once perfected it still defeats a trustee in bankruptcy, for example.27
Set the two lenders side by side. Each holds a security interest in a dealer’s inventory, but the Chevrolet financier stands behind purchase-money loans for other inventory and the line-of-credit lender stands behind none. That difference, and not the label “inventory financing,” decides status. Later sections take up the refinancing and payment-allocation rules that govern how long the status lasts.
Consignor’s Deemed Interest
Article 9 defines a consignment as a transaction, regardless of its form, in which a person delivers goods to a merchant for the purpose of sale, and the definition goes on to add further conditions.29 A transaction that meets the definition earns its purchase-money label directly: “The security interest of a consignor in goods that are the subject of a consignment is a purchase-money security interest in inventory.”30 The Code states the result outright. It does not ask, as the goods situations do, whether value enabled the consignee to acquire the goods.
The label arrives at the end of a short chain. A transaction that meets the definition makes the consignor’s interest a security interest in the goods delivered to the merchant. The consignor then becomes the secured party, the consignee the debtor, and the goods the collateral.31 The consignor is the person that delivers the goods, and the consignee is the merchant to which they are delivered, so the roles sorted out earlier in this chapter map onto the parties by their places in the delivery.32 Section 9–103(d) then attaches the purchase-money label and fixes the collateral as inventory.
The deeming rule answers a problem of outside appearances. Third persons, such as other secured parties or creditors of the consignee, are in much the same position whether a consignment is intended as a secured transaction or not. Sections 9–103(d) and 9–324(b) therefore set steps for a consignor who wants priority over a secured party that has filed against the consignee’s inventory.33 The consignor must file before the consignee receives possession of the goods and must give written notice to every other secured party who has filed. The notice must state that the consignor expects to deliver goods on consignment to the consignee, describe the goods by item or type, and be given within five years before the consignee receives them.34 The notice protects an earlier inventory lender that examines its collateral regularly. Without it, that lender might count all the inventory on the debtor’s premises as its own, not knowing that another creditor had financed some of it.35
Every link in the chain depends on the definition, so test the definition first. The goods must be delivered to a merchant for sale. The merchant must deal in goods of that kind under a name other than the consignor’s, must not be an auctioneer, and must not be generally known by its creditors as substantially engaged in selling the goods of others.36 The definition also screens out goods that were consumer goods immediately before delivery.
A stem that uses the word “consignment” does not settle the question, because the label means nothing if the definition fails. In one illustration, a consumer delivers used household goods to a store that sells secondhand goods. The store will sell them, remit the proceeds minus a 10% commission, and return whatever it does not sell. Even if a court finds a true consignment and not a consignment intended as security, the goods were consumer goods immediately before delivery, so the transaction falls outside Article 9, and law other than Article 9 controls the rights of the parties and of the store’s creditors.37 A transaction that is in substance a true consignment but falls outside the definition is not governed by Article 9 and is in effect a bailment.38 With no Article 9 security interest in the picture, no purchase-money status arises.