Concept
Secured Party and Debtor
Is the security interest a purchase-money security interest?
Purchase-Money Security Interests
Secured Party and Debtor
Every purchase-money question turns on who holds the security interest and who acquired the goods. The test asks whether a security interest in goods secures value given to enable the debtor to acquire rights in those goods,1 so it names two actors before it asks anything else. A student who misplaces either one frames the wrong question at the first step.
Article 9 fixes the actors through definitions. A secured party is “a person in whose favor a security interest is created or provided for under a security agreement, whether or not any obligation to be secured is outstanding.”2 A debtor is a person having an interest in the collateral other than a security interest or other lien, whether or not that person is an obligor.3 An obligor is, in the usual case, the person who owes the debt.4 Collateral is the asset belonging to the debtor in which the debtor grants a security interest.5
One person usually fills both the debtor and obligor roles, so the two are easy to run together. The debtor role follows the property and the obligor role follows the debt, which means they come apart whenever the owner of the collateral is not the person who owes the money. The subsections below define the secured party first and then separate the debtor from the obligor.
Secured Party Defined
The definition of a secured party has three working parts, and each screens out a different kind of claimant. The person must hold a security interest. The interest must arise from the debtor's own agreement. And the status does not depend on whether any debt is owed at the moment.6
The first part separates secured creditors from unsecured ones. A creditor whose debtor stops paying usually begins with persuasion, perhaps through a collection agency or an attorney, and if that fails it turns either to judicial remedies or to its contract right to seize and sell the debtor's assets.7 A creditor holding only a promise to pay has the first route alone, because its contract reaches no particular asset. A creditor with a security interest has both, and only that creditor is a secured party.
The commonest error with this definition is to treat every creditor as a secured party. The question to ask is whether the creditor holds an interest in specific property, and a note with no collateral answers no. Where an interest in property does exist, the next question is where it came from.
The second part ties the interest to the debtor's consent. In the ordinary case, a security interest attaches by agreement only if the debtor agrees to grant it, value is given, and the debtor has rights in the collateral.8 The agreement need not be written. It may be evidenced by an authenticated record with an adequate description of the collateral, by the secured party's possession of specified types of collateral, or by its control of specified types of collateral.9
A lender fears that a $5,000 loan will go unpaid, so it takes the borrower's motorcycle from the garage, planning to return it once the loan is paid. The lender holds the machine, but the borrower never agreed to grant a security interest in it, so none was created and the lender is not a secured party. Possession counts only alongside the debtor's intent to create a security interest,10 and a taking without consent supplies no such intent. Had the borrower handed the motorcycle over as security for the loan, possession could have served as the evidence of agreement. The one fact that moves the answer is therefore the debtor's agreement, which keeps the choice of which creditor gets rights in which asset with the debtor.
The third part detaches the status from the loan balance. In one illustration, a bank's security agreement covered inventory then owned or later acquired and secured the existing loan and all future advances. The borrower paid the loan off for fifteen days, from December 15 to December 30, 2017, and the bank's interest still attached to secure the $50,000 advance made on December 30 and the $25,000 advance made on September 30, 2018.11 The words “or provided for” point the same way: the status follows what the security agreement provides, whatever the borrower currently owes.12 If the status rose and fell with the balance, a borrower that repaid and redrew on a revolving basis would change the identity of its secured party every time the balance touched zero. The agreement is the stable fact, so the Code ties the label to it.
Two holders of the label appear in nearly every problem. The lender advances money and takes collateral, as the bank does above. The seller sells goods on credit and takes a security interest in them for the unpaid price. A buyer who purchases goods on credit and gives a purchase-money security interest for the unpaid price is the standard picture,13 and the seller who receives that interest is the person in whose favor it was created. A dealer that sells an SUV to a business on credit, under a contract in which the business grants the dealer an interest in the SUV for the price, is therefore a secured party without lending a dollar. A seller who sells for payment on delivery and has not shipped under reservation holds no security interest in the goods, and so is not a secured party as to them.14
Article 9 gives the lender and the credit seller the same role because it looks to what a transaction does and not to what the parties call it. Distinctions based on form or label do not control, except where the transaction is a pledge, involves control of collateral, or produces a purchase-money security interest, and in those cases the Article in some instances treats the transaction differently.15 The purchase-money interest is one of those exceptions, which is why the rest of this chapter matters.
The label also stretches beyond the core definition. It covers a person that holds an agricultural lien, a consignor, a person to which accounts, chattel paper, payment intangibles, or promissory notes have been sold, a trustee or agent for a secured party, and a person that holds a security interest arising under certain provisions of Articles 2, 2A, 4, and 5.16 The agricultural lienholder shows how far the stretch goes: its lien arises from a separate state statute, not from a security agreement, yet Article 9 defines it as an agricultural lien and governs how the holder perfects it.17 The interests arising under Articles 2, 2A, 4, and 5 likewise require neither a security agreement nor filing.18 This chapter works with the core definition.
Debtor and Obligor Contrasted
The secured party is the lender or seller who holds the interest, and two other roles surround it that students often blur. Article 9 defines the debtor as “a person having an interest, other than a security interest or other lien, in the collateral, whether or not the person is an obligor.”20 Two parts do the work. The first asks whether the person holds a non-lien interest in the collateral, which in most instances means an ownership interest.21 The second says the answer does not depend on whether the person also owes the debt, so a person can be a debtor without owing a cent. The full definition also reaches a seller of accounts, chattel paper, payment intangibles, or promissory notes, and a consignee.22
An obligor is, in the usual case, the person who owes the debt.23 Set side by side, the two definitions follow different things: the debtor role follows the property, and the obligor role follows the debt. In most transactions one person fills both roles, as when a retail store that owns its inventory borrows money and gives the lender a security interest in that inventory. The roles become visible when the person who receives the loan is not the person who supplies the collateral. Attachment points the same way, because the person who grants the interest must have rights in the collateral or the power to transfer them,24 and the debtor, as the person whose property is encumbered, is the one who must agree to the grant.25
The Code keeps the two roles apart because the debtor is the person with a stake in proper enforcement of the security interest, by virtue of a non-lien interest in the property, usually ownership.26 The debt is a separate matter that the obligor answers for. Tying the debtor label to the property interest lets the label track whoever's property is at risk.
The phrase “other than a security interest or other lien” does separate work. A secured party holds an interest in the collateral too, so without the exclusion every secured party would also be a debtor as to the same goods, and two creditors with competing liens on one asset would each be both secured party and debtor. Excluding lien holders keeps the term pointed at the party whose rights in the goods are being encumbered.
The guarantor in that scene sits on the debt side of the line. A secondary obligor is usually a surety or guarantor, someone who answers for another person's debt without owning the encumbered property.27 Three questions therefore sort the people in any secured transaction:
- The secured party is the person in whose favor the security agreement creates the interest, so ask who may look to the collateral if payment fails.28
- The debtor is the person with a non-lien interest in the collateral, so ask whose property is encumbered.29
- The obligor is the person who owes the secured debt, so ask who must pay.30
A fourth label, account debtor, misleads because it contains the word debtor. In one illustration, Bright sells widgets to Ames on open account and assigns the account due from Ames to Cole Finance as security for Bright's own debt to Cole. Cole is the assignee and secured party, Bright is the assignor and debtor, and Ames is the account debtor.31 Ames does owe money, but it owes the money on the collateral itself, while the secured debt is Bright's debt to Cole. Reading “account debtor” as the person whose property is encumbered points to the wrong party. The Article's account-debtor rules also step aside where an assignment of chattel paper is evidenced by a negotiable instrument, and the assignee's rights then fall under Article 3.32
This vocabulary feeds directly into the purchase-money test, which asks whether value was given to enable the debtor to acquire rights in the goods. The debtor in that question is the person who acquires the goods, and a common synonym is the buyer who purchases on credit and gives a purchase-money security interest for the unpaid price.33 A guarantor who stands behind the price owes a debt but acquires nothing, so the guarantor changes who can be made to pay and leaves the identity of the debtor unchanged.