Concept
Classifying a Right to Payment
Is the collateral an account?
Classifying a Right to Payment
Two definitions do most of the work when you classify a right to be paid. Section 9-102(a)(2) makes an account a right to payment of a monetary obligation, earned or not, that is owed for one of eight listed sources and that the exclusion sentence at the end of the definition does not remove.1 Section 9-102(a)(42) works from the other side: a general intangible is any personal property that no more specific category claims, and the definition subtracts accounts and the specialized categories by name.2 Between them, a right to be paid money ends up with one label and one set of rules. The label matters because the requirements for a security interest differ with the type of collateral, and a lender that misclassifies the right may describe the collateral wrongly or take the wrong perfection step.3 The steps below turn the earlier sections into a sequence of questions for any right to payment, and the fact patterns that follow run the sequence.
A right is not an account merely because its description matches a listed source. A seller's right to the price of property sold fits the first source, and the exclusion sentence still removes it when an instrument or chattel paper evidences the right.4 The definitions work by subtraction, so the sequence asks the exclusion questions first: the note, the bank balance, or the loan is usually visible on the face of a fact pattern, while the question what the money is owed for may need a second reading. The residual labels come last by design. A general intangible is whatever personal property remains after every named category has taken its share, so reaching for that label early skips the questions that define it.5
Each step either ends the inquiry or passes the right to the next question, and the party labels come last, once the collateral has a name.
The second and third steps change the answer most often, because a single piece of paper or a single word in the facts can move a right out of the account category. A student who matches the right to a listed source and writes account has skipped the questions the exclusion sentence exists to ask. The fifth step guards against the reverse error. Accounts, instruments, and chattel paper are intangible too, so intangibility alone does not make a right a general intangible, and the residual label is correct only when every earlier question has returned no.6
An exam stem that says only that Albert sold his car to a neighbor on credit has not yet told you what Albert owns, because the answer turns on what, if anything, the neighbor signed. If the neighbor made a bare promise to pay later and nothing was written, no exclusion applies, and the right to the price of property sold is an account.7 If the neighbor's obligation to pay is in writing, the right may be an instrument, and a writing that contains a promise to pay is a promissory note, a subset of instruments.8 If Albert holds a record in which the neighbor both promised to pay and granted a security interest in the car, the obligation is chattel paper.9 A negotiable note delivered together with a security interest in the goods sold produces the same package, as in an appliance dealer's credit sales to contractors.10 The car, the sale, and the price are identical across the versions, and only the paper changes. The paper also fixes the perfection steps: a secured party files a financing statement and, when a record exists, takes possession of a tangible instrument or tangible chattel paper or takes control of electronic chattel paper.11
The paper must be a writing, so the ladder has one more rung that is easy to miss. If a buyer authenticates an electronic record promising to pay to the order of the seller, the record is not a writing and creates no instrument, so the seller's right to the price remains an account.12 If the record's terms provide that the account debtor will pay whoever has control of the record, the right is a controllable account, which is a kind of account and not an instrument.13
Small Company's portfolios show the same sorting applied to a whole business. Its credit card receivables are accounts: a cardholder's obligation to pay arises out of card use, a listed source, and the funds-advanced exclusion carves card use back in.14 Its automobile loans are chattel paper, because each obligation is itself secured by the automobile.15 Business speech calls both portfolios receivables, but the two labels carry different steps. The client must file or take possession as to the chattel paper, and it must file as to the accounts too, because accounts qualify for automatic perfection only if they are not a significant part of Small Company's accounts.16
A single card purchase can produce both an account and a payment intangible. When a buyer pays a merchant with a card issued by an issuing bank, the issuing bank's right to be paid by the buyer is an account, but the merchant's right to the amounts its acquiring bank receives from the card network in settlement is a payment intangible.17 The two rights differ in who owes and why. The cardholder owes because of card use, a listed source. The acquiring bank owes a monetary obligation that matches no listed source and that no instrument, chattel paper, or other specialized category claims, so the merchant's right falls into the residue, with the acquiring bank as the account debtor on it.18
Suppose Local Mortgage Co. wants to borrow from Big Bank against real estate loans, each evidenced by a promissory note. The right the bank takes as collateral is the right to be paid on those notes. A promissory note is an instrument, and the exclusion sentence removes any right evidenced by an instrument from the account category, so the collateral is instruments and not accounts.19 The label opens the choice of perfection step. Filing is available, but possession protects better: only the holder of a note can enforce it, so a secured party in possession leaves no one else able to enforce the note, and possession itself perfects.20 Had no note evidenced the loans, the funds-advanced exclusion would still keep the right out of the account category, and it would fall into the residue as a payment intangible.21
Once the collateral has a name, the parties take their labels from three separate questions, and one financing can put a different person under each label.
Each label comes from its own definitional test. The debtor is the person with an interest in the collateral other than a security interest or lien, whether or not that person is an obligor.22 The account debtor is a person obligated on an account, chattel paper, or general intangible, and the definition excludes persons obligated to pay a negotiable instrument, even one that evidences chattel paper.23 A secondary obligor is an obligor whose obligation is secondary or who holds a right of recourse against the debtor, another obligor, or property of either.24 The debtor test looks to ownership of the collateral and not to the duty to pay, while the account-debtor test looks to the duty to pay and not to ownership.