Concept
Debtor and Account Debtor
Is the collateral an account?
Debtor and Account Debtor
Article 9 uses two labels that sound alike and point in opposite directions. Under § 9-102(a)(28), a debtor is a person having an interest in the collateral, other than a security interest or other lien, whether or not that person is an obligor.1 Under § 9-102(a)(3), an account debtor is a person obligated on an account, chattel paper, or general intangible, and the term excludes persons obligated to pay a negotiable instrument, even if the instrument evidences chattel paper.2 The first definition asks who has a stake in the asset pledged as security. The second asks who owes the performance that the asset represents. Everyday speech calls anyone who owes money a debtor,3 and a student who carries that habit into Article 9 will pin the label on the wrong party.
Keller is the debtor. It owns the accounts, which are the collateral, and it has granted Summit an interest in them. Because Keller also owes Summit the $300,000, it is the obligor as well; the debtor is usually the obligor too, which is why the two roles so often fall on one person and so easily get confused.4 Summit holds a security interest, so it is the secured party and not a debtor. Each contractor owes the price of goods bought on credit, an obligation that is an account and an asset of the seller,5 so each contractor is an account debtor. None of the contractors is a debtor, because none holds an interest in the accounts; the accounts are Keller's.
The roles come apart when one person owes the secured debt and another owns the collateral. In the standard illustration, SP-1 holds a security interest in accounts owed to A to secure a debt that B owes to SP-1. A is the debtor, B is the obligor, and X, who owes A for goods A sold, is the account debtor, the person obligated on the collateral.6
Each role also carries its own rights and duties. When the security interest attaches, the debtor conveys a property interest to the creditor, and the security agreement adds the debtor's promises about payment, insurance and protection of the collateral, financial reports, and warranties.7 That agreement is effective according to its terms between the debtor and the secured party.8 The account debtor stands outside that bargain, yet the financing still reaches it: the secured party may notify the account debtor to render its performance to the secured party,9 and the account debtor, unless it has agreed otherwise, may assert against the secured party the defenses and claims in recoupment arising from its contract with the debtor.10 The two subsections below take the roles in turn.
The Debtor
Article 9 finds the debtor by looking at the property, not at the debt. A debtor is a person with a non-lien interest in the collateral, usually an ownership interest, and that stake gives the person an interest in the proper enforcement of the security interest.11 The everyday meaning of the word, one who owes an obligation to another, especially an obligation to pay money,12 points a reader to the borrower, and the borrower is the right answer only when the borrower also owns the collateral. Keller does, so Keller is the debtor because of what it owns; that it also owes the loan is a second fact that happens to point to the same person.
The test applies collateral by collateral. A debtor is the person with a property interest, other than a lien interest, in the personal property or fixtures that is subject to the security interest,13 so the same person may be a debtor as to one asset and a stranger to another.
Enforcement shows why the definition follows the property. In a secured loan, the debtor is entitled to any surplus after a sale and the obligor is liable for any deficiency; the exception is a sale of accounts, chattel paper, payment intangibles, or promissory notes, where the debtor takes no surplus and the obligor owes no deficiency.14 A third person who owns collateral pledged for someone else's debt holds the rights that go with that ownership: the right to receive from the secured party any surplus from collections made from account debtors or obligors and any surplus from a sale of the collateral, and freedom from liability for a deficiency unless the third person agreed otherwise.15
Vance is the debtor because he owns the van, and Brooks is the obligor because she owes the loan. At $62,000, the $10,000 surplus belongs to Vance, and Brooks collects nothing even though she is the one in debt. At $30,000, the $22,000 deficiency is Brooks's to pay, and Vance, who is not liable for a deficiency unless he agreed otherwise, owes none of it. A reader who hands the surplus to the borrower has followed the everyday meaning of the word. Who takes the surplus is a question about who owns the collateral, and who answers for a deficiency is a question about who owes the debt.
Vance's rights depend on Granite's knowing that the van belongs to him. Short of that knowledge, a secured party may deal exclusively with the person who owes the obligation, has no duty of inquiry, and the Code does not address a debtor's authority to put up property owned by someone else.16
The definition leaves out the creditor's side of the transaction. A lien is an interest in property that gives its holder a right to possession of some of a debtor's property if the debtor fails to perform its obligations,17 and the definition sets aside both liens and security interests. Summit, which holds only a security interest in Keller's accounts, is therefore not a debtor, and neither is SP-1 in the earlier illustration.18
Two further paragraphs of the definition reach beyond owners who pledge. Paragraph (B) makes a seller of accounts, chattel paper, payment intangibles, or promissory notes a debtor, and paragraph (C) makes a consignee a debtor.19 Article 9 calls the buyer of those assets the secured party and the seller the debtor,20 so Keller would remain the debtor even if it sold the accounts to Summit outright. The consequences change in that case, as noted above: the debtor takes no surplus and the obligor owes no deficiency.21
The Account Debtor
The Article 9 definition identifies an account debtor by what it owes. It reaches a person obligated on an account, chattel paper, or general intangible,23 and the label tracks the everyday sense of debtor, one who owes an obligation to another.24 That puts the account debtor at the far end of the collateral from its owner. Each of Keller's contractors owes the price of washers and dryers and so is an account debtor, while neither Keller, who owns the accounts, nor Summit, which holds the security interest in them, is obligated on them. A student who asks who owns the pledged asset has asked the debtor question. The account debtor question asks who must pay.
The working test is to find the person who owes what the collateral represents. In the plainest case, A buys a good on credit from B, and A's obligation to pay B is an account and an asset of B.25 If B grants a lender a security interest in that account, A is the account debtor, B is the debtor, and the lender is the secured party. B and the lender both appear in the financing, yet neither owes anything on the account.
Chattel paper supplies a second kind of obligation. A dealer sells equipment to a farmer under a conditional sales contract, which is a security agreement relating to specific equipment and so is chattel paper. When Dealer transfers the contract to its bank, by outright sale or to secure a loan, the bank is the secured party, Dealer is the debtor, and Farmer is the account debtor.26 Donald's pledge to Sabrina shows the same sorting. Donald gives Sabrina a security interest in his accounts and chattel paper to secure a $50,000 debt, and Pauline buys a machine from Donald for $5,000 down and a promise to pay $20,000 in ninety days, secured by the machine. Pauline's promise plus the security interest she gave Donald is chattel paper under Article 9.27 Pauline is obligated on it, so she is an account debtor, and Donald, who owns the chattel paper and has pledged it, is the debtor. The definition treats a person obligated on a general intangible the same way.28
The definition withdraws one group of obligors from the category. A buyer who owes the price of goods on credit owes an account. When a buyer instead signs a negotiable note for what it owes, the right to payment is not an account; it is an instrument and a promissory note, and an asset of the seller.29 The definition follows that result: a person obligated to pay a negotiable instrument is not an account debtor, even if the instrument evidences chattel paper.30 The maker of a note stays outside the category when the note is part of chattel paper, as when a promissory note accompanies a conditional sales contract and the writings together are chattel paper.31 An assignee of the note looks to Article 3 for its rights.32
Larkin is an account debtor, because it is obligated on an account that Rowe owns. Moreno is not, because Moreno is obligated to pay a negotiable instrument. In the everyday sense both customers are Rowe's debtors; only one is an Article 9 account debtor. Rowe is the debtor as to both rights, and First Lender is the secured party.
The label matters because the Code deals with the account debtor directly. The secured party may notify the person obligated on the collateral to render its performance to the secured party,33 and once an assignee satisfies the notice requirements of § 9-406, the account debtor must pay the secured party what it owes the assignor; Pinnacle, an account debtor on accounts that Widget Company assigned, must pay the secured party.34 The account debtor keeps its position on the underlying contract. Unless it has agreed otherwise, it may assert against the secured party the defenses and claims in recoupment arising from that contract,35 and § 9-403 ordinarily gives effect to an account debtor's agreement not to assert claims or defenses.36 A contractor who bought a defective washer from Keller can therefore raise the defect against Summit unless the contractor agreed otherwise.